Russian Media Claims 15,000 Ukrainian Troops Encircled in Donbas

Russia claims 15,000 Ukrainian troops encircled in Donbas

The encirclement is closed. This was the announcement made by Russian media in May 2022: between 15,000 and 16,000 Ukrainian military personnel would have been trapped between Severodonetsk and Lisichansk, in the heart of Donbas. The source is the self-proclaimed Luhansk People's Republic, later replicated by outlets such as Gazeta.ru and Iz.ru and easily searchable on Yandex without a VPN. The fine print admits another reading: the encirclement is not consolidated. What exists is an order not to retreat and three bridges shelled by artillery.

How many Ukrainian soldiers are in the pocket?

The figures vary depending on who tells them. The initial announcement spoke of 16,000 troops inside the cauldron. The version from the Luhansk People's Republic, dated May 17, lowered it to a group of 15,000 soldiers. And there are estimates that go much higher: military sources cited from South America raise the total deployed in the Severodonetsk salient to 40,000 men, with the cream of the crop of the Ukrainian army concentrated there as it has been a war front since 2014. With this range, any headline is defensible. And that is exactly the problem.

Three bridges and one road to escape

Geography does not deceive as much as figures do. Severodonetsk is on the other side of the river and has only three exit bridges, all within range of Russian artillery. The northern bridge is under heavy mortar fire from Voivodka, about four or five kilometers away. With the bridgehead at Bilogorovka, Lisichansk would have only one road to receive supplies.

It is important to clarify what being surrounded means here. There is no consolidated physical encirclement. There is something more uncomfortable: a rear area of more than twenty kilometers of opening where every communication route is within ten kilometers of Russian positions. At that distance, the shell flies little and hits often. Neither a clean retreat nor tranquil reinforcements.

Zaluzhny wanted to retreat, but the order was to resist

Here tactics cross with politics. Versions circulating among military analysts place the commander-in-chief of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, Valerii Zaluzhnyi, proposing abandoning the fortified zone and withdrawing salvageable units toward Slavyansk, where positions are better. The attributed response from Volodymyr Zelenskyy was the opposite: reinforce Severodonetsk and Lisichansk to sustain the defense.

The reason would not be military, but narrative. Kyiv needed a victory to tell. It is the type of decision judged years later, and almost always with the known outcome.

Stalingrad, Falaise, and the myth of the decisive encirclement

History works against enthusiasm. The Soviet army was surrounded many more times than it managed to surround others, and Stalingrad was its only spectacular encirclement of the entire war. The Germans captured millions of prisoners with theirs in 1941, and it did not help them win. In the great Soviet encirclement, about 250,000 men remained.

The figure repeated these days is different. In 2014, in Donbas, an offensive by forces presented as local would have left about 10,000 Ukrainian soldiers out of action in an encirclement maneuver. The Ukrainian high command took nearly a year to acknowledge it.

Kyiv, Chernihiv, Sumy, and Kharkiv: the encirclements that failed

Those who distrust the announcement remember this. Attempts to surround urban centers at the start of the campaign did not close, and Russian forces ended up withdrawing from several fronts. With available troops, they argue, it is impossible to reproduce encirclements from World War II: there will be no hundreds of thousands of prisoners, nor probably tens of thousands.

The counterargument is that the phase has changed. With fewer open fronts, better logistics, and artillery as the main tool, the conditions are different. On the opposite side, it is pointed out that Ukrainian artillery maintains an efficiency advantage from day one, that the United States realized this and is reinforcing that asset, and that Russian attrition in this chapter is notable. Two narratives, zero neutral ground.

---

What will be decided in the coming days is not the war, but whether the Ukrainian high command sacrifices veteran units for a headline or preserves them for the next line. Artillery has already chosen its part of the work. With those distances, speaking of an orderly retreat sounds more like a desire than a plan.