Manual transmission resists in Europe, but the data tells a different story
In the US, 98% of cars are automatic. In Spain, manual registrations dropped from 97% to 41% since 2001. What is slowing the transition?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Manual transmission resists in Europe, but the data tells a different story
In the United States, 98% of the vehicle fleet is automatic. In Spain, the figure is much lower, but the trend is clear: manual transmission has fallen from 97% of registrations in 2001 to 41% in 2024. In other words, most new cars sold here are already automatic. Italy is at 48%, and Germany has dropped to 18%. The fleet on the road is old, but what is being bought is different.
Why is manual still alive?
The reason is not the drivers' «stupidity», as some claim. There are rational arguments: manual transmissions are cheaper to buy and maintain, and breakdowns are less frequent and costly. When an automatic fails, it can miccionan a bill for thousands of euros. Furthermore, since 2019, you can obtain the B license with an automatic, but this adds Code 78, which prevents driving a manual without repeating the practical exam. This administrative barrier has slowed the transition.
The future is automatic
Electric and hybrid cars are all automatic, so the trend will continue to grow. The problem is that many drivers do not change the oil in the automatic gearbox, because many brands do not include it in official maintenance. This can lead to expensive breakdowns. Meanwhile, the debate continues: manual transmission causes no problems until it does, and automatic transmissions also break down. The difference is that a manual can be repaired in any workshop, while the automatic requires specialists.
The analysis reaches a standstill regarding one point: licensing regulations. Until Code 78 is eliminated or obtaining the license without restrictions is facilitated, many drivers will continue to choose manual transmission out of simple pragmatism. However, the data leaves no doubt: the era of manual transmission is ending, albeit slowly.
In the United States, 98% of the vehicle fleet is automatic. In Spain, the figure is much lower, but the trend is clear: manual transmission has fallen from 97% of registrations in 2001 to 41% in 2024. In other words, most new cars sold here are already automatic. Italy is at 48%, and Germany has dropped to 18%. The fleet on the road is old, but what is being bought is different.
Why is manual still alive?
The reason is not the drivers' «stupidity», as some claim. There are rational arguments: manual transmissions are cheaper to buy and maintain, and breakdowns are less frequent and costly. When an automatic fails, it can miccionan a bill for thousands of euros. Furthermore, since 2019, you can obtain the B license with an automatic, but this adds Code 78, which prevents driving a manual without repeating the practical exam. This administrative barrier has slowed the transition.
The future is automatic
Electric and hybrid cars are all automatic, so the trend will continue to grow. The problem is that many drivers do not change the oil in the automatic gearbox, because many brands do not include it in official maintenance. This can lead to expensive breakdowns. Meanwhile, the debate continues: manual transmission causes no problems until it does, and automatic transmissions also break down. The difference is that a manual can be repaired in any workshop, while the automatic requires specialists.
The analysis reaches a standstill regarding one point: licensing regulations. Until Code 78 is eliminated or obtaining the license without restrictions is facilitated, many drivers will continue to choose manual transmission out of simple pragmatism. However, the data leaves no doubt: the era of manual transmission is ending, albeit slowly.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (120 replies).
More summaries
-
The four breakfasts no Spanish bar serves
Oats, wholemeal bread, hummus and peanut butter: four foods Spanish bars don't serve, against the tradition of toast and Spanish tortilla.
-
Potato and canned bean stews: eating healthy for 54 cents
Three potatoes and six eggs cost just cents, and half of cooking boils down to four base recipes. Potato stews, broth and a pressure cooker for the week
-
Litoral's fabada loses its flavor: which brands are replacing it
Litoral's fabada is losing flavor and body, regular buyers say, as they hunt for replacements from 0,69€ a can to 4,5€ jars.
-
Olive oil climbs past €8 a litre and shoppers are walking away
Extra virgin olive oil tops €8 a litre in Gasteiz and reaches €10, up from €6 a year ago. More and more shoppers are taking it off their lists
-
A Land Rover and 20.000 euros in repairs in just four years
Mireia has spent about 20.000 euros on repairs to her Land Rover, with only 173.000 km in four years, including timing chain, turbo, gearbox and driveshaft
-
Razor blades: expensive cartridges vs. cheap double-edge
A 100-pack of double-edge blades costs €9–12 and gives five shaves per blade; the expensive cartridge is done after five uses.