The cushionless generation: €30,000 at age 40
How much money do you need saved to sleep well? The Banco de España puts a number on that question, and the result is uncomfortable. People between 30 and 45 years old accumulate an average financial wealth of €30,000, which in practice corresponds to the value of a home minus the remaining mortgage balance. Their parents, at the same age, already had between €100,000 and €200,000. This is not just a generational impression or a dinner-table complaint: the supervisor’s own data points to lower net wealth accumulation compared to previous cohorts. And those who do not accumulate cannot withstand shocks.
Why do young people aged 30 to 45 save less than their parents?
Two causes, neither of which can be fixed with a personal finance course. First, salaries that did not allow, and still do not allow, a large part of these generations to save. Second, housing costs—especially rent—that consume any attempt to build a safety net. The annual report from the Banco de España states it bluntly: higher housing prices, both for purchase and rental, limit household savings capacity and condition their wealth accumulation process throughout the life cycle. The effects are particularly harsh for low-income households and, specifically, among young people.
Elena’s case, a Madrid resident who has just turned 40, summarizes the mechanics. When she was young, she saved €100 a month; now she doesn’t even consider it. Her rent takes more than 60% of her income, double the 30% threshold recommended by manuals. She lived for years in Germany and returned with a small cushion that she now defends desperately, cutting travel and leisure to the minimum. Her fight is no longer about saving: it’s about ensuring life doesn’t consume what she already had.
One in three young people has delayed paying rent
The statistic bears repeating: one in three young people has had to delay or suspend their rent payment due to rising prices. More than half of young people live in rented homes, and nearly 35% of those under 44. Each increase in rent is not offset by cuts: it is offset by debt or non-payment. And that non-payment is not a sarracena problem, but an arithmetic one.
61% of renting households cannot buy even in their own municipality
Here lies the core of the issue. It is estimated that in 2021, 61% of households living in rented or donated housing did not have the necessary savings to acquire a home in the municipality where they resided, taking into account the down payment not covered by the mortgage and the expenses and taxes associated with the purchase. Without a down payment, there is no ownership; without ownership, there is no cushion; without a cushion, any bump becomes an emergency. The circle closes itself.
From €200 internships to 'external mobility'
The cohort currently aged between 35 and 40—those who entered the labor market with the burst of the real estate bubble in 2008, or just before—barely reaches €40,000 in financial wealth. They started working with internship contracts, nearly full-time hours, and pay of €200 or €300. Many emigrated en masse, in a phenomenon that the then Minister of Employment, Fátima Báñez, described as "external mobility." The euphemism did not contribute to social security.
Civil service exams, nursing, or moving back home: Plan B
With the path to homeownership closed, very different exits circulate. Several point to public employment: studying for civil service exams (oposiciones) or, directly, nursing, where several participants describe salaries above €2,000, category A1 on the way, and a burden of responsibility lower than that of a doctor. Other sectors until recently considered safe are becoming saturated: some say a veterinary job offer received more than a thousand resumes in two days.
The other major strategy is staying put. Extending cohabitation with parents—something done in countries with lower incomes and something that was common in Spain decades ago—is assumed by some as a life plan, and they tell it without drama: if you can't afford an apartment, at least you don't pay rent. Some tighten spending to the minimum, while others have moved from checking accounts to looking at investment products to get some return on the little money saved. The complete calculation, line by line, is more surprising than the headline.
What is discussed when discussing savings
The diagnosis is not unanimous. One current points to housing as the root cause: high prices, strained rents, and insufficient protected supply. Another points to wages and fragmented employment: according to figures cited by a participant, official unemployment around 13%, high temporary hiring, and part-time shifts leaving payslips of €700 to €1,200, with which you cannot even pay for a room in capital cities. And a third, more uncomfortable view, argues that the problem is habits: traveling, getting tattoos, and changing phones with a frequency incompatible with saving. Each has its data. The sum does not add up in any direction.
In the middle also appears an argument difficult to support with numbers: that the influx of foreign labor pressures wages downward. It is often claimed but rarely proven.
In the end, the figure that best portrays the era is not the €30,000, nor the 61%, nor the 13% unemployment rate. It is the idea, increasingly marginal, that at 40 the life goal is not buying an apartment, but ensuring the rent doesn't evict you from the one you already have. Cheap, certainly, it does not turn out.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (186 replies).