Milei authorizes $2 trillion debt, denies money printing
Argentina's government authorizes $2 trillion in debt via DNU 56/2023. Analysts argue this is not money printing but a restructuring effort.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Milei authorizes $2 trillion debt as no-printing pledge wobbles
Javier Milei's government has authorized the issuance of public debt instruments worth 2 trillion pesos through Decree of Necessity and Urgency (DNU) 56/2023, published in the Official Gazette. The measure aims to cover commitments due in 2024 and includes a 1 trillion increase for operations with a minimum 90-day maturity, plus 4 billion for tenth-series consolidation bonds. This decision contradicts the president's campaign promise to stop printing money to fight inflation.
What the decree says and what it doesn't
The official text establishes the issuance of public debt to meet 2023 commitments maturing next year. Technically, this is not currency emission in the strict sense, but debt. In a fiat system, these are related but distinct operations. Issuing debt to cancel other debt results in zero net monetary emission.
The decree also increases by 1 trillion the budget law limit for 90-day operations and adds 4 billion for consolidation bonds. These figures suggest financial restructuring rather than pure monetary expansion.
Debt issuance vs. money printing
Confusion between these concepts drives the debate. Some argue public debt issuance isn't money printing; it can dry up liquidity, contain inflation, and gradually introduce dollars. Others contend that in a fiat system, issuing debt equals emitting currency. The practical difference lies in net effect: if debt cancels debt, the impact is null.
Some analysts note the move targets Leliqs (Central Bank bills yielding 133%), replacing them with one-day repos at 100%. The goal is to bypass the central bank and clean its balance sheet. This is liability restructuring: swapping short-term debt for medium-long term to buy time.
Financing costs and structural issues
Argentina's core problem isn't just issuance, but financing costs. Argentine bonds yield around 180%, while repos sit at 110%. With capital costs exceeding 25% against global averages of 3%, productive investment is unviable. The debt-vs-money debate fades when real returns cannot cover interest.
Default looms in discussions. It would destroy available financing, leaving the country without credit or investment capacity. Optimists argue buying time to rebuild credibility lowers rates. Pessimists antiestéticar runaway inflation forces default, causing severe misery.
Support for austerity and compliance risks
Support for Milei rests on the idea that austerity is inevitable and alternatives were worse. Critics argue blaming him after two weeks ignores past disasters. However, debt issuance contradicts campaign rhetoric, undermining official coherence.
The debate shifts to state versus private sector roles. One view holds less state intervention reduces corruption. Another argues the issue is lack of anti-corruption laws, not intervention itself. Argentina's history of Peronism and economic elites illustrates both perspectives.
What happens next
The debt operation aims to clean the central bank's balance sheet and buy time. Success means reduced short-term liabilities and improved credibility. Failure brings more deficit, inflation, and forced default. Predictions suggest an economic rebound within two years, enabling reelection, trinc by a drag period depending on management.
Javier Milei's government has authorized the issuance of public debt instruments worth 2 trillion pesos through Decree of Necessity and Urgency (DNU) 56/2023, published in the Official Gazette. The measure aims to cover commitments due in 2024 and includes a 1 trillion increase for operations with a minimum 90-day maturity, plus 4 billion for tenth-series consolidation bonds. This decision contradicts the president's campaign promise to stop printing money to fight inflation.
What the decree says and what it doesn't
The official text establishes the issuance of public debt to meet 2023 commitments maturing next year. Technically, this is not currency emission in the strict sense, but debt. In a fiat system, these are related but distinct operations. Issuing debt to cancel other debt results in zero net monetary emission.
The decree also increases by 1 trillion the budget law limit for 90-day operations and adds 4 billion for consolidation bonds. These figures suggest financial restructuring rather than pure monetary expansion.
Debt issuance vs. money printing
Confusion between these concepts drives the debate. Some argue public debt issuance isn't money printing; it can dry up liquidity, contain inflation, and gradually introduce dollars. Others contend that in a fiat system, issuing debt equals emitting currency. The practical difference lies in net effect: if debt cancels debt, the impact is null.
Some analysts note the move targets Leliqs (Central Bank bills yielding 133%), replacing them with one-day repos at 100%. The goal is to bypass the central bank and clean its balance sheet. This is liability restructuring: swapping short-term debt for medium-long term to buy time.
Financing costs and structural issues
Argentina's core problem isn't just issuance, but financing costs. Argentine bonds yield around 180%, while repos sit at 110%. With capital costs exceeding 25% against global averages of 3%, productive investment is unviable. The debt-vs-money debate fades when real returns cannot cover interest.
Default looms in discussions. It would destroy available financing, leaving the country without credit or investment capacity. Optimists argue buying time to rebuild credibility lowers rates. Pessimists antiestéticar runaway inflation forces default, causing severe misery.
Support for austerity and compliance risks
Support for Milei rests on the idea that austerity is inevitable and alternatives were worse. Critics argue blaming him after two weeks ignores past disasters. However, debt issuance contradicts campaign rhetoric, undermining official coherence.
The debate shifts to state versus private sector roles. One view holds less state intervention reduces corruption. Another argues the issue is lack of anti-corruption laws, not intervention itself. Argentina's history of Peronism and economic elites illustrates both perspectives.
What happens next
The debt operation aims to clean the central bank's balance sheet and buy time. Success means reduced short-term liabilities and improved credibility. Failure brings more deficit, inflation, and forced default. Predictions suggest an economic rebound within two years, enabling reelection, trinc by a drag period depending on management.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (136 replies).
More summaries
-
Milei attacks wokeness at Davos while the Central Bank remains
Milei calls wokeness a 'sinister agenda' at Davos, reopening debate on Argentina's Central Bank amid agricultural data and criticism of the money printer.
-
Milei bans deficit, restricts Central Bank in structural reform
Argentina's new law prohibits money printing for state funding and targets investment grade status amid falling inflation.
-
Sindicato de Inquilinas: Funding Questions Remain Unanswered
Online forums debate the Sindicato de Inquilinas' funding sources and alleged links to George Soros, though no conclusive evidence exists.
-
Spain's Sánchez agrees to Jordi Wild interview and his campaign panics
Sánchez has accepted an interview on Jordi Wild's podcast with live fact-checking. His campaign fears an unscripted face-off and suspicions of a pre-agreed script.
-
Europe registers 400,000 EVs in September, but just three countries drive the growth
Europe topped 400,000 electric cars in September, but Germany, France and the UK account for more than half of sales. Diesel holds its ground in Spain's used car market.
-
The R78 claim in a short video: rabbi's remarks on Islam
David Touitou, a French-Jewish rabbi, claims Islam is 'Israel's broom' to sweep away Christianity, and that his messiah will not return until Christianity disappears.