Is being Catholic now left-wing? The debate splitting believers
Has the Catholic Church's social doctrine shifted to the left? Accusations of Freemasonry, comparisons with socialism and a Pope who makes conservatives uncomfortable.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The Church, that awkward political player with no clear label
Among economic and political circles, an idea is gaining ground: the social doctrine of the Catholic Church, with its emphasis on the poor, distributive justice and criticism of deregulated capitalism, would fit better within left-wing thinking than on the right. A growing current holds that institutional Catholicism, especially under Pope Francis, has shifted towards pogre positions on economic and social matters. On the other side, some argue that reducing faith to a left-right axis is an intellectual trap.
The shadow of Freemasonry and ecclesial "wokism"
One of the accusations that keeps resurfacing is that the Church is controlled by Freemasonry, and that its recent rhetoric – against the free market, in favour of state regulation and critical of consumerism – is proof of it. Those making the claim point to comparisons between the homilies of the last two popes: while Benedict XVI was seen as more orthodox on economics, Francis has multiplied his denunciations of "savage capitalism". For others, however, there is no such control: the Church has always been a trans-political institution, and its social message is not leftist but evangelical.
Ancient socialism or revolutionary heresy?
The discussion reaches heights of historical irony when Christianity is described as "the socialism of Antiquity". A provocation that some take to the extreme: the Church, in its alliance with Rome, would have adulterated Jesus's original message to channel it down a non-revolutionary path, thus becoming an anti-Christian structure. The left, according to this thesis, would be a secular version of that same clericalism. An ideological muddle that leaves the reader with the feeling that, in this territory, nothing is what it seems.
The numbers that add up (or don't)
There are no reliable statistics on how many believers feel represented by the Vatican's social message. What can be observed is a rift between part of traditional Catholicism, which views the environmentalist and market-critical turn with suspicion, and another part that applauds it. In practice, Pope Francis's economics – condemnation of financial speculation, calls for a fairer economy – clashes with the policies of many conservative governments, but also with part of his own flock.
The dilemma remains open. While some read the encyclicals as a left-wing programme, others see them as the defence of an impossible third way. The truth is that, for now, the "Catholic" label no longer guarantees a vote at the ballot box, and the sceptic who has made it this far will know that the answer is neither black nor white, but an awkward ecclesial grey.
Related debates in the forum
Among economic and political circles, an idea is gaining ground: the social doctrine of the Catholic Church, with its emphasis on the poor, distributive justice and criticism of deregulated capitalism, would fit better within left-wing thinking than on the right. A growing current holds that institutional Catholicism, especially under Pope Francis, has shifted towards pogre positions on economic and social matters. On the other side, some argue that reducing faith to a left-right axis is an intellectual trap.
The shadow of Freemasonry and ecclesial "wokism"
One of the accusations that keeps resurfacing is that the Church is controlled by Freemasonry, and that its recent rhetoric – against the free market, in favour of state regulation and critical of consumerism – is proof of it. Those making the claim point to comparisons between the homilies of the last two popes: while Benedict XVI was seen as more orthodox on economics, Francis has multiplied his denunciations of "savage capitalism". For others, however, there is no such control: the Church has always been a trans-political institution, and its social message is not leftist but evangelical.
Ancient socialism or revolutionary heresy?
The discussion reaches heights of historical irony when Christianity is described as "the socialism of Antiquity". A provocation that some take to the extreme: the Church, in its alliance with Rome, would have adulterated Jesus's original message to channel it down a non-revolutionary path, thus becoming an anti-Christian structure. The left, according to this thesis, would be a secular version of that same clericalism. An ideological muddle that leaves the reader with the feeling that, in this territory, nothing is what it seems.
The numbers that add up (or don't)
There are no reliable statistics on how many believers feel represented by the Vatican's social message. What can be observed is a rift between part of traditional Catholicism, which views the environmentalist and market-critical turn with suspicion, and another part that applauds it. In practice, Pope Francis's economics – condemnation of financial speculation, calls for a fairer economy – clashes with the policies of many conservative governments, but also with part of his own flock.
The dilemma remains open. While some read the encyclicals as a left-wing programme, others see them as the defence of an impossible third way. The truth is that, for now, the "Catholic" label no longer guarantees a vote at the ballot box, and the sceptic who has made it this far will know that the answer is neither black nor white, but an awkward ecclesial grey.
Related debates in the forum
- I don't get why women go for this guy and treat him as a sens symbol. I find him hard to look at. · 64 replies
- Leire's agenda. Was Patxi the segarro or the dimwit with ears · 170 replies
- Things are getting messy in Tehran (Part II) · 541 replies
- Antonio Turiel is in his bulking phase · 21 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (34 replies).
More summaries
-
The Future of the Catholic Church: Priests Marrying and Having Children
The Catholic Church might relax celibacy for priests, allowing marriage and parenthood in response to the vocation crisis.
-
Catholic faithful in Spain split from Church over immigration
The gap between the Vatican's universalist discourse and the migration concerns of ordinary believers is dividing Catholic parishes across Spain.
-
Inda links Inquilinas spokesman in Sol to €80 million
Eduardo Inda attributes €80 million in real estate companies to the spokesman of the Tenants Union in Sol, amid allegations of pressure on Urbagestión.
-
Spain's November 29 scenario if the housing decrees fall
If the right votes down Spain's housing decrees, fears grow within the PSOE of a snap election on November 29, and street protests enter the equation.
-
Voting PSOE so corruption leaves office with the government still standing
The case for the useful vote for Spain's PSOE, so corruption cases surface while the government stays in power, is gaining ground ahead of the 29N election. The calculation and its risks.
-
Germany registers 88,599 electric cars in September, 34.5% of the market
A tweet claims Germany sold 88,599 electric cars in September, 34.5% of the market. Spain lags at 9.6% and struggles with broken chargers.