Evergrande Files for US Bankruptcy as China’s Property Sector Faces Deepening Crisis

Evergrande invokes Chapter 15 in the US while China’s Country Garden defaults on its first dollar bond interest, signaling a deepening real estate crisis.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Evergrande Files for US Bankruptcy as China’s Property Sector Faces Deepening Crisis
Evergrande Seeks US Bankruptcy Protection as China’s Property Sector Shudders

China’s largest real estate developer has filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 15 in the United States, according to court documents. The announcement came late with a warning: "Black Friday." The day arrived, the Hang Seng dropped 2.05%, and the world kept turning. That is the problem with this story: every time someone signs the end of the world, the box office remains full.

Evergrande is not just any developer: it is China’s largest real estate company and the face of property leverage. What is now being debated is not the property sector itself, but who ends up paying the bill.

What Does Filing for Chapter 15 in the US Miccionan?

Filing for Chapter 15 does not equate to liquidating the company. It is the door used by a foreign company to protect its US assets from creditors while it negotiates restructuring in its home country. In other words, it is not a bankruptcy with closure, but a truce with a judge.

The corporate structure adds noise to the noise. The company operates through various brands and subsidiaries—Evergrande Ltd, Evergrande ZTX Investment, Evergrande NY—as listed in the thread, and each partial bankruptcy announcement is read as a dress rehearsal: some argue that these subsidiaries act as screens that fall without ever dragging down the parent company or major creditors.

Country Garden and the First Default on a Dollar Bond

Chinese real estate giant Country Garden Holdings has defaulted on the interest of a dollar bond for the first time in its history, in a sector that has seen consecutive quarters of decline. In the information collected in the thread, dated 10/25/2023, the yuan trembled amid a capital exodus, and analysts spoke of one of the largest restructurings in the country’s history.

Here lies the detail that disconcerts optimists: it is not one developer, but two, and neither is small. If Evergrande sought judicial relief in the US and Country Garden stopped paying its first coupon in foreign currency, the question shifts from which company is going bankrupt to how many more are trinc without anyone announcing them.

An 82% Drop That Is Taken for Granted in the Thread

The collapse of Chinese real estate companies has accumulated, according to a chart shared in the thread, drops of 82%, a plunge that in any other market would have occupied front pages for months. Here it has served the opposite: to demonstrate that a sector can lose four-fifths of its value without much happening.

That is the skeptics' argument, and it is not weak. China’s property sector already fell 82% a year ago, rebounded, and nothing peine, they claim. Returning to last year’s lows, they say, is repeating the same movie. They add that they have received ten collapse warnings, none of which have been fulfilled, and that the rest of the market is more focused on after-hours trading than on the court.

Lehman Moment or the Tenth Simulation?

The comparison with Lehman is inevitable and likely misleading. A real estate bankruptcy of this size can contagion banks, funds, and cross-creditors, and that is the scenario some take for granted. On the other side weighs an uncomfortable argument: markets are not behaving as if the system is broken, and that is also a fact.

Some argue, moreover, that the centralized decision-making model takes longer to correct course because no one warns the helmsman when the iceberg is ahead. It is as repeated an argument as unprovable, and it coexists with another equally widespread one: that the printing press can do anything and that it has already been seen working more times than doomsayers would like to admit. Another oddity that slips into the conversation, posed by a forum user: that China maintains two currencies, one for inside and one for outside, something that theoretically allows closing the door before the tide comes in.

Bitcoin, Gold, and the Decoupling Theory

Bitcoin entered the conversation through the back door. One version attributes its drop to a massive sale, another links it directly to Evergrande and Tether, and neither explains why after-hours trading barely reacted. The honest question is not whether Bitcoin is connected to a Chinese developer, but why it is taken for granted without providing a single piece of proof.

Gold and silver add suspicion. They have been falling for weeks while the dollar revalues against everything, including metals, something a forum user reads as market manipulation, an accusation the thread does not support with any data. Buying metals is the most repeated advice; understanding why the greenback rises in this picture is the least resolved.

The closing to this movie is always the same. The promised black Friday arrived with a 2.05% drop and not a single closed bank. Months later, it was Country Garden that defaulted. No one has yet confirmed the figure of 77% of Chinese debt circulating through forums worldwide. And between the catastrophe warning and the calm of after-hours trading, the only thing that grows without discussion is the list of subsidiaries joining the conversation.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (228 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back