The question is not new, but it always sparks debate. The starting premise is uncomfortable: much of the rock sung in Spanish has aged poorly and falls short in sound and variety compared to British or US bands. Nevertheless, some names played in another league. And they are not all the usual suspects.
The most cited case is Barón Rojo. Their album Volumen Brutal was released in 1982 and recorded at Battery Studios in London, the same place where Iron Maiden registered The Number of the Beast. Bruce Dickinson himself collaborated on a track, and the band performed that summer at the Reading Festival. Few credentials better defend the idea that competition was possible here too.
Those Who Sang in English to Cross Borders
Recording in English was not exclusive to Barón Rojo. Muro released Mutant Hunter in English around 1990. Avalanch and Warcry have also issued several albums in that language, aiming for a market beyond the Iberian Peninsula. These were conscious attempts to export, not just to show off locally.
The problem, argue the skeptics, is that Hispanic rock was always very insular. It is claimed that the Anglo-Saxon market acted as a filter: only quality proven work arrived, while national production was compared as a block, including mediocrity. Under those conditions, the comparison always loses.
Triana, Smash, and Andalusian Rock Looking Outward
Not everything was heavy metal. In the seventies, bands formed that are now reclaimed without hesitation. Smash, from Seville and psychedelic, is placed by some on par with any comparable foreign group. Triana, Topo, and Asfalto appear in the same list, with the particularity that their songs, filtered through Andalusian rock, still sound like something unique.
Power metal also has defenders. Opera Magna is described as an underrated group with nothing to envy from more famous genre peers. In the 2000s, there was a wave of fantasy-themed power metal that came and went within the decade, leaving little mark beyond the niche circuit.
The Singer Who Missed Hard Rock
There is a curiosity running through the conversation that goes beyond heavy metal: Camilo Sesto. His version of Getsemaní has been compared to Ian Gillan's, with some claiming he surpassed it. He is attributed a privileged voice, in the orbit of Joe Lynn Turner or Don Dokken, and an image that, in a white tunic, would not have looked out of place with Judas Priest at the time. He never sang like that again.
The other side is Tino Casal, who died in 1991, pointed out as one of the few Spanish artists with real capacity to rival foreign stars. Casal's production on Obús's early albums is described as very British. These are isolated cases, but they point to an uncomfortable question: how much talent was lost due to lack of industry?
Industry as the Only Foreign Merit
The harshest current argues that groups like WASP or Twisted Sister owe their position to the industry, not musical superiority. Against this stand bands like Soziedad Alkoholika, Angelus Apatrida, Ángeles del Infierno, Obús, Ktulu, or Crisix, which are attributed equal or superior technical levels. The discussion then shifts to the perennial problem: how many rock bands have published at least one album in Spain, thirty thousand or more, and what percentage have actually been heard.
The argument extends to Latin America, with Soda Stereo, Los Fabulosos Cadillacs, or Brujería listed among those with nothing to envy. And globally: The Hu from Mongolia, Ultra Vomit from France, Baby Metal from Japan. The conclusion is that talent knows no borders, but distribution does.
In the end, the question remains unanswered. Some will keep humming Rosendo, others prefer Angelus Apatrida. The only provable fact is that Barón Rojo recorded in the same studio as Iron Maiden, and in 1982, not just anyone could do that.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (103 replies).
Iron Maiden sells out stadiums at 80 Euros per ticket while launching its own beer brand, reissuing its catalog, and sparking debate over the new drummer.