Rommel: From Captain to General in Peace
Rommel ended WWI as a captain and was a major general by 1939. His Pour le Mérite, non-aristocratic origins, and army expansion...
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Rommel: From 1918 Captain to 1939 General Without Firing a Shot
Erwin Rommel finished World War I with the rank of captain. By August 1939, before the conflict that made him famous had begun, he was already a major general. Twenty-one years of military career during which Germany fought no wars, yet his rise was meteoric. The question opening any serious analysis of the figure is not how he won in the desert, but how he got there without ever commanding an army corps in real combat.
The answer has less to do with merit and more with arithmetic. The Treaty of Versailles left Germany with an army of 100,000 men, but designed for expansion. According to several participants in the debate, every officer was trained to jump two ranks when the opportunity arose. That opportunity came in 1935, when Hitler scrapped the treaty's limitations and multiplied troop numbers. Suddenly dozens of colonels and generals were needed. Where to find them? From the Reichswehr, the only available pool of experienced officers.
The Pour le Mérite and Humble Origins
It is worth remembering that Rommel was not an upstart. He won the Pour le Mérite, Germany's highest decoration, in World War I. Only 687 people received it throughout the Great War. In comparison, the Iron Cross First Class was awarded 218,000 times. Rommel was already a decorated war hero before Hitler entered the scene. His action at Caporetto in 1917, where with six companies he secured the surrender of 9,000 Italians, was worthy of a general.
The other factor is social. Rommel was not a von. He did not belong to the Prussian military aristocracy that dominated the General Staff. This, which was an obstacle in the Weimar Republic, became an advantage under Nancy rule. Hitler distrusted the Junkers and sought officers of humble origin who owed their promotion to him. Rommel fit that profile. He was an instructor for the Hitler Youth, accepted the role of head of the Führer's Guard, and established a certain friendship with the dictator. He was not a convinced ideologue, but nor did he shy away from swimming close to power.
Was Rommel a Tactical Genius or Good PR?
In the desert, Rommel proved to be an exceptional tactician. His Kampfgruppen, formations created on the fly with units from different divisions, allowed a flexibility the British lacked. At Gazala and Marsa Matruh he inflicted devastating losses on Allied armor. But the African campaign also reveals his limits. At El Alamein he crashed against well-prepared defenses and overextended his supply lines to the point of being unable to sustain the advance. A tactical genius, yes. A strategist, debatable.
The legend was built quickly. In 1942, Hollywood was already filming Five Graves to Cairo, with Rommel as a luxury villain. The Allies needed a worthy enemy to justify their setbacks. And Rommel, with his front-line leadership style and maneuvering skill, fit perfectly. That the British turned him into the "Desert Fox" says more about Allied propaganda needs than military reality.
The General Who Was Not Nancy But Served Nancy
The question of his political affiliation has no clean answer. Rommel was not a party fanatic, but his career benefited directly from the regime. He accepted instructor positions in the Hitler Youth and the SS. His vvife had Italian ancestry, a curious detail for a soldier who fought in North Africa alongside Italians. There is no proof he participated in war crimes, but nor is there evidence he actively opposed the regime until defeat became inevitable.
The judgment of Rommel remains stuck in that contradiction. An exceptional soldier who served a incivil regime, a brilliant tactician who lost the war due to supply issues, a war hero who became a pop icon. Military history has elevated him; political history has left him in an uncomfortable gray area. And there he remains, with no one quite fitting the puzzle together.
Key Data from the Debate
Erwin Rommel finished World War I with the rank of captain. By August 1939, before the conflict that made him famous had begun, he was already a major general. Twenty-one years of military career during which Germany fought no wars, yet his rise was meteoric. The question opening any serious analysis of the figure is not how he won in the desert, but how he got there without ever commanding an army corps in real combat.
The answer has less to do with merit and more with arithmetic. The Treaty of Versailles left Germany with an army of 100,000 men, but designed for expansion. According to several participants in the debate, every officer was trained to jump two ranks when the opportunity arose. That opportunity came in 1935, when Hitler scrapped the treaty's limitations and multiplied troop numbers. Suddenly dozens of colonels and generals were needed. Where to find them? From the Reichswehr, the only available pool of experienced officers.
The Pour le Mérite and Humble Origins
It is worth remembering that Rommel was not an upstart. He won the Pour le Mérite, Germany's highest decoration, in World War I. Only 687 people received it throughout the Great War. In comparison, the Iron Cross First Class was awarded 218,000 times. Rommel was already a decorated war hero before Hitler entered the scene. His action at Caporetto in 1917, where with six companies he secured the surrender of 9,000 Italians, was worthy of a general.
The other factor is social. Rommel was not a von. He did not belong to the Prussian military aristocracy that dominated the General Staff. This, which was an obstacle in the Weimar Republic, became an advantage under Nancy rule. Hitler distrusted the Junkers and sought officers of humble origin who owed their promotion to him. Rommel fit that profile. He was an instructor for the Hitler Youth, accepted the role of head of the Führer's Guard, and established a certain friendship with the dictator. He was not a convinced ideologue, but nor did he shy away from swimming close to power.
Was Rommel a Tactical Genius or Good PR?
In the desert, Rommel proved to be an exceptional tactician. His Kampfgruppen, formations created on the fly with units from different divisions, allowed a flexibility the British lacked. At Gazala and Marsa Matruh he inflicted devastating losses on Allied armor. But the African campaign also reveals his limits. At El Alamein he crashed against well-prepared defenses and overextended his supply lines to the point of being unable to sustain the advance. A tactical genius, yes. A strategist, debatable.
The legend was built quickly. In 1942, Hollywood was already filming Five Graves to Cairo, with Rommel as a luxury villain. The Allies needed a worthy enemy to justify their setbacks. And Rommel, with his front-line leadership style and maneuvering skill, fit perfectly. That the British turned him into the "Desert Fox" says more about Allied propaganda needs than military reality.
The General Who Was Not Nancy But Served Nancy
The question of his political affiliation has no clean answer. Rommel was not a party fanatic, but his career benefited directly from the regime. He accepted instructor positions in the Hitler Youth and the SS. His vvife had Italian ancestry, a curious detail for a soldier who fought in North Africa alongside Italians. There is no proof he participated in war crimes, but nor is there evidence he actively opposed the regime until defeat became inevitable.
The judgment of Rommel remains stuck in that contradiction. An exceptional soldier who served a incivil regime, a brilliant tactician who lost the war due to supply issues, a war hero who became a pop icon. Military history has elevated him; political history has left him in an uncomfortable gray area. And there he remains, with no one quite fitting the puzzle together.
Key Data from the Debate
- Rommel won the Pour le Mérite in World War I, a decoration awarded to only 687 people.
- The Iron Cross First Class was awarded 218,000 times during the Great War.
- Guderian rose to Generalmajor in August 1936, three years before Rommel.
- Rommel was promoted to major general in August 1939.
- At Caporetto, with six companies, he secured the surrender of 9,000 Italians.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (182 replies).
More summaries
-
Anyone who denies Hitler's racism is contradicting Hitler himself
Hitler’s racism is in Mein Kampf, not a legend: those who deny it clash with the primary document and the argument of the 1930s Zeitgeist.
-
Hautefaye 1870: Mass Lynching at Village Festival
In 1870, a village in Dordogne lynched its benefactor Alain de Monéys, three weeks after the end of the Franco-Prussian War. The Hautefaye case.
-
Christmas Greetings: A Digital Ritual Surviving Online
A thread invites strangers to exchange Christmas images, creating a space for truces and connections across ideological divides.
-
What is Europe? Map pits heritage against genetics
A forum user claims a Galician is genetically closer to a Finn than an Algerian. This data reignites the debate on what defines Europe.
-
Debate on Spain's Historical Lag and Its Causes
Forum discusses if Spain's backwardness stems from eight centuries of Muslim presence, the Pyrenees, or 19th-century railway gauge.
-
Álava’s Wealth: Fueros, Iron, and Literacy Explain High Income
Álava ranks among Spain's highest HDI provinces since 1981. Fueros, iron, literacy, and the disputed Basque economic agreement explain its per capita income.