Catalan politics faces a paradox unsettling Junts and ERC leadership. A social media poll suggests support for Pedro Sánchez's government hurts Junts in the Catalan Parliament while Sílvia Orriols' Aliança Catalana gains traction. El Confidencial reports that Waterloo insiders believe Junts benefits from Moncloa calling early general elections before damage becomes irreversible. However, Puigdemont does not control the calendar.
What polls say about Aliança Catalana
The starting point is a poll placing Aliança Catalana as the only party rising alongside Vox. Support for Sánchez's government weakens Junts in the Parliament, with only Orriols' party growing according to this data. Electoral analysis suggests every seat Aliança Catalana wins in Lleida and Girona comes from Junts' pool. The C-25 highway, running from Cervera to Caldes de Malavella, is described as the corridor where votes previously considered captive by Puigdemont are rapidly shifting.
Some argue Aliança Catalana and Vox electorates do not overlap. Most voters for one would never vote for the other due to national identity issues. Vox attracts former PP, CiU, Cs, and some PSC voters. Aliança Catalana's challenge primarily affects Junts, and secondarily ERC.
Puigdemont's calculation and threat to drop Sánchez
According to El Confidencial, Waterloo believes early general elections benefit Junts. The reason is survival, not ideology. If Aliança Catalana surges further, it could become the leading separatist force, potentially costing Junts seats, per internal calculations. Junts has threatened to withdraw support from Sánchez and warned bases to "prepare for a new cycle." Yet this threat expires: later elections miccionan worse results.
Junts' antiestéticar of Aliança Catalana has specific parliamentary implications. Attempts to force a vote on delegating migration competencies are stuck in crossfire. Analysis suggests this maneuver aims to make Podemos label Junts xenophobic. Podemos opposes transferring immigration powers to Catalonia. Consequently, Junts appears vulnerable on its right flank without gaining left-wing support.
Orriols' consistency and abstention in general elections
Aliança Catalana does not contest general elections. Supporters cite this as proof of consistency: an independentist party rejecting the Spanish framework contradicts itself by entering Congress. Conversely, this limits their electoral ceiling and protects Junts in the lower house. For now.
The Puigdemont-Orriols rivalry involves generational and rhetorical differences. Junts' project, program, and decisions revolve around Puigdemont. When voters look beyond the ex-president to daily street issues, Aliança Catalana's focus on immediate problems eclipses others. This message resonates in rural Catalonia while Junts continues selling Waterloo's agenda.
Vote transfer polls fail to capture
Some believe polls underestimate votes Aliança Catalana steals from ERC. Admitting this shift would prematurely suggest Aliança Catalana could become the second-largest force behind PSC. Such a scenario would reorder the separatist map, turning Junts and ERC from necessary partners into minor players.
Discussions on Aliança Catalana's future echo past patterns in Catalan politics. Small parties promise much but change when they grow. ERC and CiU vowed not to pact with Article 155 supporters but did so anyway. Puigdemont's party promised to leave Madrid. Small parties talk big; once established, narratives shift. The question remains whether Aliança Catalana will be the exception or trinc the rule.
Analysis stalls at the same point it began: no one knows if early elections save Junts or accelerate its replacement. Puigdemont holds the calculator, Orriols controls the road, and Sánchez has the key. With these three elements, the Catalan board lacks a clear owner.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (115 replies).
Silvia Orriols (Aliança Catalana) faces fines yet sees rising polls. Details on the political phenomenon challenging Catalonia's independence movement.
Morocco establishes a committee to assert claims over Ceuta and Melilla, following the Spanish government's delayed admission of Moroccan naval incursions.