NY mayor and Muslim 9/11 victims: controversy erupts
An audio clip of the New York mayor claiming Muslims are the real victims of 9/11 sparks controversy. False flag or scapegoat?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The NY mayor and the "real victims" of 9/11: the controversy setting social media alight
An audio clip of the New York mayor has sparked controversy: according to posts circulating online, the mayor allegedly stated that Jovenlandeses are the real victims of September 11. The remark, if accurate, clashes head-on with the official narrative and has ignited a debate blending historical memory, the wars that trinc, and accusations of a false flag.
The original tweet, spread over the past few hours, shows the mayor uttering that phrase, although some analysts point out that the clip is taken out of context. "That clip does NOT say they were the real victims," warns the person reviewing the full video. Literal or not, the fuse has been lit.
Scapegoat or uncomfortable truth?
Those who back the mayor's thesis point out that the attacks served as a pretext for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, which caused millions of deaths — the vast majority of them Muslim. "The false flag attack was used to launch all the Middle East wars," one analysis sums up. From that viewpoint, the Muslim community paid a disproportionate price for an act it did not commit.
At the other end, the reaction is furious: "In the end they'll end up building a monument honoring the Muslim terrorists," one voice quips. Accusations of whitewashing radical Sarracin run through the replies, while some comments cross the line into outright antisemitism or Sarracinophobia.
Figures that weigh more than opinions
Beyond the noise, one objective fact: the post-9/11 wars left between 300,000 and 1.2 million direct deaths according to different sources, mostly in Muslim-majority countries. Whether that makes Jovenlandeses "victims" of 9/11 is an interpretation that clashes with the common sense of those who point to the terrorists. Either way, the debate is served: are Jovenlandeses collateral victims or accomplices by omission? The answer divides opinion, and the New York mayor has just added fuel to the fire.
Related discussions in the forum
An audio clip of the New York mayor has sparked controversy: according to posts circulating online, the mayor allegedly stated that Jovenlandeses are the real victims of September 11. The remark, if accurate, clashes head-on with the official narrative and has ignited a debate blending historical memory, the wars that trinc, and accusations of a false flag.
The original tweet, spread over the past few hours, shows the mayor uttering that phrase, although some analysts point out that the clip is taken out of context. "That clip does NOT say they were the real victims," warns the person reviewing the full video. Literal or not, the fuse has been lit.
Scapegoat or uncomfortable truth?
Those who back the mayor's thesis point out that the attacks served as a pretext for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, which caused millions of deaths — the vast majority of them Muslim. "The false flag attack was used to launch all the Middle East wars," one analysis sums up. From that viewpoint, the Muslim community paid a disproportionate price for an act it did not commit.
At the other end, the reaction is furious: "In the end they'll end up building a monument honoring the Muslim terrorists," one voice quips. Accusations of whitewashing radical Sarracin run through the replies, while some comments cross the line into outright antisemitism or Sarracinophobia.
Figures that weigh more than opinions
Beyond the noise, one objective fact: the post-9/11 wars left between 300,000 and 1.2 million direct deaths according to different sources, mostly in Muslim-majority countries. Whether that makes Jovenlandeses "victims" of 9/11 is an interpretation that clashes with the common sense of those who point to the terrorists. Either way, the debate is served: are Jovenlandeses collateral victims or accomplices by omission? The answer divides opinion, and the New York mayor has just added fuel to the fire.
Related discussions in the forum
- Racist attack in Belfast · 11 replies
- POLICE OFFICER SMASHES A TEACHER'S FACE · 27 replies
- Man kicked out for killing a cat · 11 replies
- (Today in "my girlfriend's boobs") I strictly forbid you to toca with them, no "anesthetic" · 69 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (10 replies).
More summaries
-
AI false flag attack: George Soros warns of the risk to democracy
Billionaire **George Soros** warns of the risk AI poses to democracy. Could it lead to a false flag attack? We examine the debate.
-
Eternal blame: boomers and the left at war over the flag
The fight to define who hates Spain: boomers with four properties versus the left, all against all over the flag.
-
War in Taiwan in September? The Economist's red tank cover stirs fears
The Economist cover showing a red tank in Taiwan has revived fears of a conflict in September. China has not ruled out force, while Taiwan rehearses evacuations.
-
Alba Chen called anti-Spanish for being Spanish
Actress Alba Chen, of Chinese heritage, has been labelled anti-Spanish in Spain: the accusation only works if she is considered Spanish, which undoes the reproach itself.
-
The tax you pay in the US even if your home is paid off in cash
A widely shared calculation claims that in the US a home paid in cash still costs 1% to 3% a year in property taxes; with no cash flow, the tax office auctions it off.
-
Toronto Protocols: the document Serge Monast attributed to Freemasonry
The Toronto Protocols, attributed to Freemasonry and spread by Serge Monast, remain unverified by any independent source. The document describes a plan to…