Meditation myths: it’s not about clearing your mind

Meditation isn’t about clearing your mind: what you actually do

The most common misconception is that stopping thinking or blanking the mind is possible, even during sleep. The thread starter states plainly: “things that don’t happen even when we are asleep. A myth.” From there, various responses address a question that sounds like a joke but isn’t: what exactly does someone do while supposedly meditating? The short answer: there’s no single way. The long answer fills this article.

What meditation is and isn’t, according to practitioners

The most repeated definition doesn’t talk about emptying anything, but about training attention: cultivating concentration, unifying consciousness, and gaining calm and clarity. It’s an ancient method, not a fad, although the term has been decades prostituted by new age marketing, according to one participant. There is broad agreement on one point: meditation isn’t about stopping thoughts, it’s about directing and focusing thought on something concrete—breathing, a body part, a memory. Thoughts keep coming; the difference lies in not getting hooked on them.

Many describe the process as a succession of spaces: a thought arrives, you let it pass, another comes, you let it pass. These gaps between thoughts widen, bringing relaxation. Others put it less mystically: it’s taking the microphone away from the chattering mind, the one that criticizes, plans, and repeats nonsense, to enjoy a few minutes of silence while awake. An exercise in mental hygiene, in the words of a psychiatrist cited in the conversation.

Do you have to sit in lotus position to meditate?

No. Posture matters less than the image suggests. You can meditate lying down, walking, or, as the initial post cheekily asks, while sitting on the toilet. What almost all descriptions share is the anchor: breathing and bodily sensations help return to the present moment when the mind wanders. The goal, they agree, is to deactivate past memories and future projections for a while. Nothing more, nothing less.

Confusion arises from mixing three distinct things: contemplative practice, coaching posturing, and the paraphernalia of retreats and mystical circles. Regarding the latter, there is critical unanimity: charlatans with their singing circles and miracle methods have proliferated, always attracting the same type of client, according to some participants. That the packaging is ridiculous doesn’t invalidate the content, but helps understand why so many people view the subject with suspicion.

Attributed benefits and those that aren’t

The list of supposed advantages is long: less mental noise, more presence, better emotion management, relief from acute suffering. Several responses cite studies on brain effects and science-backed benefits, though evidence mixes with exaggerated expectations. One example of miscalibrated expectation: believing meditation serves to suppress suffering. Suffering signals that something is wrong and needs fixing; it’s a symptom, not an enemy to silence, according to one participant.

There is consensus on how difficult it is. The mind is a bastard, summarizes one response: thoughts pop up here and there, reliving or imagining situations, and some people live entirely inside their heads. Talking to those thoughts, calming them, ignoring them, and reaching the instant where the murmur stops: that is meditating. It lasts a sigh. And from there, they say, you can build.

Meditating, praying, and hiking: the same family

Comparison with prayer appears several times. Repeating the Creed, a verse from the Quran, or a mantra works as an anchor and produces a state similar to meditation: repetition hacks the mental chatter, according to some. It’s not the only way. Some argue that walking in the mountains, listening to birds, smelling the air, and looking at greenery is enough: contact with nature purifies and orders, making problems seem less grave upon return. Meditation would then be carrying that moment within, to use it when anger or agitation arrives.

The underlying disagreement isn’t technical, but about expectations. Some see a useful, free tool; others, a form of inaction that cages the tiger and strips its essence. The most serious criticism isn’t against the practice, but against its use: repressing anguish instead of facing it with action. Meditation, at best, is a tool. Like any tool, it admits good, bad, and outright stupid uses.

---

What happens when you sit to meditate and fall asleep two minutes later? It happens. Often. With these foundations, the question isn’t whether meditation works, but if anyone truly knows what they’re doing when they say they meditate.