Irene and Pablo Camp in Sol: The 15-M of a Handful

Irene and Pablo camp in Sol amid housing decree fervor, reviving 15-M spirit despite criticism over low turnout and alleged funding.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Irene and Pablo Camp in Sol: The 15-M of a Handful
Irene and Pablo Camp in Sol to Revive the Housing 15-M

A couple sets up their tent in Puerta del Sol as night falls. Around them, a small group—much gray hair, more than one bald head—and a banner evoking 2011. The protagonists, Irene and Pablo, utter the phrase of the day: "We're here tonight and for as many nights as it takes." The new housing encampment doesn't resemble the 15-M in photos. It looks like its remake.



What is the New Sol Encampment?

The protest occupies Puerta del Sol to demand a shift in housing policy, with the rental decree in the spotlight. Public support includes figures from cinema and activism, like actor Carlos Bardem, who called to "come, spread the word, and cooperate."

The star backing comes from Irene and Pablo, who have placed the encampment at the center of their agenda. The scene, however, is not the human tide of May 2011. It's a handful of people who could fit on a sidewalk.



Who Funds the Encampment: Spontaneous or Directed?

Here's where it gets complicated. One line of analysis suggests nothing is spontaneous and that there's structure and budget behind it. According to this narrative, the tenants' union, channeled through idrabcn.com and the Comuns political party, allegedly has 1.15 million euros for such actions. The political orbit of Ada Colau is also cited as the movement's political matrix.

The accusation is unproven. But the shadow of public funding has become the critics' favorite argument: if there's money, they argue, there are no real people.



What Has Changed Since the 2011 15-M?

The comparison with May 2011 is inevitable and doesn't fare well. Back then, there were young people, students, a generation fueled by the anger of unemployment and evictions. Now, forty-somethings and nearly fifty-year-olds abound: many of the same people, fifteen years older.

The most persistent criticism points to the trajectory of several promoters who went from the plaza to institutions and comfortable homes, and who are now calling people back to the street.



Ceuta, Catalonia, and the Double Standard

Underlying it all is the uncomfortable comparison: if tents and stalls are tolerated on the beach in Ceuta, why not in Puerta del Sol? The paradox is presented as a denunciation of double standards depending on who is camping.

And a pointed question: why Madrid, if Catalonia is the region with the most evictions? A detail that, they say, reveals the territorial bias of the protest.



What the Media Shows vs. What's Seen in the Plaza

Direct witnesses describe a plaza with fewer people than what appeared on screen. The television coverage—live specials, loud headlines—allegedly inflated an event that, on the ground, could fit on a couple of balconies.

This gap between what is seen and what is broadcast is, for many, the best summary of the moment.



Podemos 2.0 and the Forecast of Oblivion

The most common prediction is rapid oblivion. Over every forecast looms the shadow of Podemos 2.0: some anticipate the party's end; others, the umpteenth failed attempt to bring the street back to the center.

In the end, the figure that throws things off is not the banner: it's the over a million euros that, according to critics, drives the machinery of an encampment that yesterday fit into a handful of people. Where that money comes from remains the unanswered question.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (177 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back