Amazon's El Cid: Controversial Cast and Cancelled After Two Seasons

Amazon's El Cid: Controversial Casting and No Third Season

Amazon announced a series about El Cid led by Jaime Lorente, presenting it as a journey through the kingdoms, cultures, and religions that coexisted on the Iberian Peninsula. The ending was less epic: two seasons and no renewal. No official statement, no closed finale. The project launched with plans for a release in 200 countries, a rollout that fueled expectations and suspicions alike. The choice of protagonist was the first clash: not due to his career, but because of his physique and what part of the audience expected from a character mythologized over centuries.

What is known about the cast and production

The casting placed Jaime Lorente in the role of Rodrigo Díaz de Vivar. The proposal did not want to stick strictly to the poem; the presentation itself insisted on showing the context of kingdoms and cultures that shared territory. That interpretation — viewing El Cid as a figure of coexistence — was exactly what lit the fuse. Much of the conversation read it as a rewriting operation with a contemporary label, while others criticized judging it before seeing a single frame.

Why did it stop at two seasons?

The series aired two batches and then stopped. There was no official explanation, and the cut came just before the most recognizable episodes of the character: the murder of Sancho, the Oath of Santa Gadea, and the exile. Years later, the issue resurfaced, pointing to a hypothesis for non-renewal: that the product didn't fully fit the sensibilities shaping the current catalog. It is a hypothesis, not data from the producer. Without confirmation from any side, the doubt remains open.

The historical El Cid served no single cause

Anyone who has read more than the poem encounters a character uncomfortable for simple narratives. Noble turned mercenary is the synthesis used by the best-documented sources: he served various lords and changed sides depending on who hired him. Some recall that places like Tortosa or Sagunto saw him fight both inside and outside the siege depending on who paid. Neither a hero of one flag nor a villain: a professional soldier. That complexity, they point out, is often left out of simpler versions of the character.

27-kilo armor against the image of a skinny hero

The debate about the protagonist's build has an interesting counterpoint. According to calculations circulating in the discussion, a medieval warrior equipped moved at least 27 kilos of light armor; heavy sets reached 50 kilos. Translated into those terms: the typical physique of someone surviving that looked more like a rugby player than an extra. The objection wasn't just about appearance, but coherence with the portrayed profession. Here, available material works against easy criticism: an actor can be convincing without having the stature of a real warrior, and cinema has proven this for a century.

The precedent that already adapted El Cid on television

This isn't the first time Spanish television approaches the character. El Ministerio del Tiempo dedicated an episode to the Crusades era and was accused then of the same tic as now: presenting the peninsula as an Eden of coexistence versus fanatical Christians. The reproach repeats season after season. It is worth remembering that the discussion about El Cid's skin tonalidad is much older than the platform currently airing it: it is a deep cultural battle, not a new catalog trend.

---

With two seasons available and an open ending, a third installment seems improbable. Improbable is not impossible: platforms revive projects as easily as they shelve them, and the character has plenty of material for two more batches. If someone funds it again, the question won't be how much it respects the poem. It will be who benefits from El Cid serving one cause or the opposite.