Navarra offers €200 annual grant for women in STEM degrees

Navarra to pay €200 annually to women in technical degrees

The Government of Navarra has approved a €200 annual grant for students enrolled in science, technology, engineering, or mathematics degrees. The measure, reported by Diario de Navarra, applies to all university years and aims to correct the gender gap in technical classrooms, where female presence remains minority. However, the figure has sparked a storm of criticism for what many consider a symbolic amount — barely €16.66 per month — and for the exclusively sensual criterion used for distribution.

Aid that doesn't even cover two coffees a month

The amount was the first target. A quick calculation yields €16.66 monthly, a sum that hardly alters the decision to enroll in Computer Engineering or Telecommunications. Some argue the incentive is so ridiculous it borders on an insult; conversely, others claim any help, however small, is welcome amid rising tuition fees. But irony prevails: if the goal is attracting female talent to STEM fields, €200 a year won't buy a single calculus textbook.

Gender discrimination prohibited by the Constitution

The second front is legal. Several voices have pointed out that the measure clashes with Article 14 of the Spanish Constitution, which prohibits any discrimination based on sens. The aid is granted solely to women, without equivalent compensation for men in feminized degrees like Nursing, Education, or Philology. Criticism is unanimous here: if the aim is balancing percentages, the criterion should be underrepresentation in each degree, not the student's sens. The paradox is evident: one form of discrimination is being combated with another.

Ministry of Equality and silence on male-dominated degrees

The lack of mirror measures for men has been another frequent reproach. Data cited by critics highlight a gender gap in universities that also harms males: they drop out earlier and represent only 43% of undergraduate enrolments, compared to 57% of women. In Vocational Training and non-university studies, male dropout rates reach 15.9%, nearly double that of females. If the objective is real equality, the Navarra aid only covers part of the problem.

Pension precedent and antiestéticar of an unlivable country

Beyond this specific case, the measure has fueled deeper discontent. Some interpret it as a symptom of the feminization of society and a State distributing handouts instead of incentivizing merit. Others see it as simple electoral calculation: the Navarra Government, in coalition with Bildu and PSOE, seeks to secure young female votes at low cost. The shadow of Opus Dei universities in the region adds a local ingredient to a controversy that transcends academia.

Is gender discrimination in university grants constitutional?

The short answer is probably no. Article 14 of the Constitution establishes that Spaniards are equal before the law, prohibiting discrimination based on birth, race, sens, religion, or opinion. An exclusive aid for women in STEM could be considered positive action, a concept admitted by the Constitutional Court in very limited cases with proportional measures. Here, the negligible amount and lack of a comprehensive plan question that proportionality. The ball is now in the courts' court.

---

Ultimately, the measure achieved something seemingly impossible: uniting left-wing and right-wing critics. Some over the amount, others over the criteria, all over the substance. Does anyone really believe €200 a year will change career choices?