AI for long videos: revolution or hype at 80 euros per music video?
AI tools can generate music videos for 80 euros, but temporal consistency breaks down in longer sequences. Are we looking at a revolution or just hype?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
AI for long videos: revolution or hype at 80 euros per music video?
You upload a song, wait 30 minutes, and the machine hands you back a music video with characters, synced lips and varied shots. No prompts, no reference photos, no effort. The promise is tempting. The reality, for now, chokes as soon as you ask for more than twenty seconds of narrative coherence.
The tools setting the pace
Runway Gen-3 Alpha, Viggle, Haiper and Kuaishou top the list of platforms that let you generate video from text or audio. The mechanics are simple: you upload a song or a text, pick a style, and the system generates complete scenes. The cost, according to shared experiences, comes to around 80 euros for a three-minute music video. A figure that makes traditional production budgets look pale.
But the fine print matters. Generation works in bursts: each scene is processed separately, and transitions between shots often show an annoying flicker of frames. Temporal consistency – keeping the same face, clothes and lighting between cuts – remains the Achilles' heel. For a short video with fixed shots and repetitive loops, the result is passable. For a 30-minute film with narrative continuity, the system falls apart without manual review.
The credit trap
Another uncomfortable reality: the platforms run on prepaid credits. If you try to generate a long sequence, the system stops when the credits run out, leaving static, repetitive shots that are not the result of a technical failure but of a paywall. The phrase "the little machine wants more money" sums up the experience of anyone who has tried to squeeze the free demo.
The near future: when will we see AI-generated films?
The optimists argue that pogre is exponential. A year ago people said these tools only produced "crap"; now they already deliver acceptable music videos for artists and production companies. If the pace holds, generating short films without human intervention could be viable in a year or two. Skeptics point out that temporal consistency is an engineering problem that cannot be solved with more data alone: keeping characters, settings and emotions consistent across long sequences requires advances in visual memory models that are not yet mature.
The contest between promise and reality remains open. For 80 euros, anyone can have a music video. For the 30-minute film, we will have to wait – and pay for a lot more credits.
Related discussions in the forum
You upload a song, wait 30 minutes, and the machine hands you back a music video with characters, synced lips and varied shots. No prompts, no reference photos, no effort. The promise is tempting. The reality, for now, chokes as soon as you ask for more than twenty seconds of narrative coherence.
The tools setting the pace
Runway Gen-3 Alpha, Viggle, Haiper and Kuaishou top the list of platforms that let you generate video from text or audio. The mechanics are simple: you upload a song or a text, pick a style, and the system generates complete scenes. The cost, according to shared experiences, comes to around 80 euros for a three-minute music video. A figure that makes traditional production budgets look pale.
But the fine print matters. Generation works in bursts: each scene is processed separately, and transitions between shots often show an annoying flicker of frames. Temporal consistency – keeping the same face, clothes and lighting between cuts – remains the Achilles' heel. For a short video with fixed shots and repetitive loops, the result is passable. For a 30-minute film with narrative continuity, the system falls apart without manual review.
The credit trap
Another uncomfortable reality: the platforms run on prepaid credits. If you try to generate a long sequence, the system stops when the credits run out, leaving static, repetitive shots that are not the result of a technical failure but of a paywall. The phrase "the little machine wants more money" sums up the experience of anyone who has tried to squeeze the free demo.
The near future: when will we see AI-generated films?
The optimists argue that pogre is exponential. A year ago people said these tools only produced "crap"; now they already deliver acceptable music videos for artists and production companies. If the pace holds, generating short films without human intervention could be viable in a year or two. Skeptics point out that temporal consistency is an engineering problem that cannot be solved with more data alone: keeping characters, settings and emotions consistent across long sequences requires advances in visual memory models that are not yet mature.
The contest between promise and reality remains open. For 80 euros, anyone can have a music video. For the 30-minute film, we will have to wait – and pay for a lot more credits.
Related discussions in the forum
- - - - Carmen García, the top PAU 2022 score, gives you some advice · 26 replies
- The PSOE youth wing is coming on strong: "the right are Franco's heirs, posh snobs and bad people" · 16 replies
- Teachers on strike in Valencia outraged after police shoved a woman standing in the middle of the road · 74 replies
- The most bubble-prone town in Spain · 61 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (25 replies).
More summaries
-
Montse Mínguez's 7,000 m² luxury villa linked to a fund
Montse Mínguez shares a luxury villa on a 7,000 m² plot with her partner, with ownership attributed to the Nest Life fund, according to El Español.
-
Video of a Tesla Roadster flying splits viewers
A video circulating on social media shows a Tesla Roadster lifting off over a Tesla Semi and performing a barrel roll. Some viewers suspect it is a simulation.
-
Viral tweet claims 29 relatives of an 1880 emigrant were granted Spanish citizenship
A tweet claims 29 relatives were granted Spanish citizenship through a single ancestor who emigrated in 1880. The case reopens the debate over fraud controls in Spain's citizenship-by-descent process.
-
Viral Mercadona receipt comparing 2016 and 2026 is fake, and prices haven't doubled
The viral Mercadona receipt comparing 2016 and 2026 is fake: different products, a non-existent street and a papyrus-like texture. Real inflation is far below double.
-
Explosion at Alberta military base: hospitals overwhelmed, casualties unconfirmed
An explosion at CFB Wainwright, a military base in Alberta, Canada, has left hospitals overflowing, schools converted into shelters, and casualty figures still unconfirmed by Defence.
-
Javier Bardem criticized for backing protests while owning property empire
Social media posts attack Javier Bardem for supporting youth protests while being credited with a property empire and a home in Beverly Hills.