Who pays €2,500 for a 40 m² basement in Madrid
Twenty people in 40 m², one bathroom and €2,500 a month in rent: the rental market and seasonal contracts, after the Sol camp in Madrid.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The 40 m² basement where twenty people pay €2,500 a month
A basement with no windows or heating. 40 square metres. Twenty people —including two girls and two babies— sharing a single bathroom. The rent: €2,500 a month. The case was reported by El País and has since become the defining image of a rental market no longer measured in square metres, but in how many people can be crammed inside.
A controversy has been built on that image, one that starts with the camp at Sol. One claim making the rounds holds that nine out of ten campers are children of Spaniards and that migrants are barely seen there. Not because they don't exist, but because, according to one of the messages, many were working, and because the housing market itself places them elsewhere.
Who shows up at the camp and who doesn't
Against that thesis, another part of the analysis points out that a camp is not a census. Some argue that the students on display come from families with means, able to spend a weekend at Sol and then head off on Erasmus to Rotterdam. Others reply that many of the absent were, quite simply, at work.
The detail that keeps coming back has less to do with who protests than with who collects the rent. More than half of tenants in Spain were born outside the country, and the share rises when looking only at rented households with children.
Seasonal rentals, the loophole that dodges the cap
That is the other axis of the controversy. Anyone who recently looked for a flat describes a familiar pattern: seasonal contracts, unregulated prices and a letter in April warning that it's time to leave. One person willing to pay €1,000 a month found that in spring they had to vacate the property.
The takeaway is uncomfortable for any official narrative: the problem is not only that the rent cap is insufficient, but that the seasonal formula allows it to be sidestepped. When a landlord can choose between a protected contract and one that isn't, the choice is not neutral.
The tenant who complains and the one who doesn't
The sharpest argument concerns the ideal tenant. One circulating thesis holds that the big landlord prefers someone who pays without complaint, works long shifts and never demands improvements. Facing them is the tenant who protests or asks why the rent is going up.
It is not a neutral thesis, and those who defend it load it with intent: they speak of replacement, of landlords opening doors and of a business that profits from other people's desperation. The other side replies that this framework mixes immigration with crime, and that the mix obscures the real problem, which is prices.
What the rental numbers in Spain say
The data cited is scarce, but it points in a direction uncomfortable for everyone. In rented households with children, 67.1% have as head of household a person born outside Spain. It is not an opinion about integration: it is an X-ray of who lives in rented housing and at what price.
Some read in this the proof of a business that needs people with no alternatives, and others read exactly the opposite: that the shortage of supply pushes out anyone, no matter where they come from. The only thing that admits no interpretation is the basement. 40 square metres, no windows, one bathroom, twenty people, €2,500. That figure needs no interpretation.
A basement with no windows or heating. 40 square metres. Twenty people —including two girls and two babies— sharing a single bathroom. The rent: €2,500 a month. The case was reported by El País and has since become the defining image of a rental market no longer measured in square metres, but in how many people can be crammed inside.
A controversy has been built on that image, one that starts with the camp at Sol. One claim making the rounds holds that nine out of ten campers are children of Spaniards and that migrants are barely seen there. Not because they don't exist, but because, according to one of the messages, many were working, and because the housing market itself places them elsewhere.
Who shows up at the camp and who doesn't
Against that thesis, another part of the analysis points out that a camp is not a census. Some argue that the students on display come from families with means, able to spend a weekend at Sol and then head off on Erasmus to Rotterdam. Others reply that many of the absent were, quite simply, at work.
The detail that keeps coming back has less to do with who protests than with who collects the rent. More than half of tenants in Spain were born outside the country, and the share rises when looking only at rented households with children.
Seasonal rentals, the loophole that dodges the cap
That is the other axis of the controversy. Anyone who recently looked for a flat describes a familiar pattern: seasonal contracts, unregulated prices and a letter in April warning that it's time to leave. One person willing to pay €1,000 a month found that in spring they had to vacate the property.
The takeaway is uncomfortable for any official narrative: the problem is not only that the rent cap is insufficient, but that the seasonal formula allows it to be sidestepped. When a landlord can choose between a protected contract and one that isn't, the choice is not neutral.
The tenant who complains and the one who doesn't
The sharpest argument concerns the ideal tenant. One circulating thesis holds that the big landlord prefers someone who pays without complaint, works long shifts and never demands improvements. Facing them is the tenant who protests or asks why the rent is going up.
It is not a neutral thesis, and those who defend it load it with intent: they speak of replacement, of landlords opening doors and of a business that profits from other people's desperation. The other side replies that this framework mixes immigration with crime, and that the mix obscures the real problem, which is prices.
What the rental numbers in Spain say
The data cited is scarce, but it points in a direction uncomfortable for everyone. In rented households with children, 67.1% have as head of household a person born outside Spain. It is not an opinion about integration: it is an X-ray of who lives in rented housing and at what price.
Some read in this the proof of a business that needs people with no alternatives, and others read exactly the opposite: that the shortage of supply pushes out anyone, no matter where they come from. The only thing that admits no interpretation is the basement. 40 square metres, no windows, one bathroom, twenty people, €2,500. That figure needs no interpretation.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (35 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain housing prices drop 4.6%, Madrid falls 3.8%
Notaries confirm Madrid's first price drop in nine years at 3.8%, with a national average decline of 4.6%.
-
Spain to regulate seasonal rentals following 40% surge
Seasonal rental supply has grown by 40%, now accounting for 10% of the market, while permanent rentals fell by 12%. The Ministry of Housing is forming a task force.
-
Madrid: New Housing Prices in Los Berrocales
85m² flats for €456,000 in Los Berrocales. We analyse the tension between new urban development and Madrid's maximum prices.
-
France riots: looting and the civil war narrative
The storming of Limoges town hall and the looting reopen the debate: civil war in France or social protest gone out of control? The facts and the key points.
-
Shirtless in summer: privilege or just heat? Spain's latest debate
El País reopens the debate: is it a privilege for men to go shirtless in summer? The hypocrisy of the double standard, laid bare. A no-holds-barred analysis.
-
Spain: abuse allegations drown out the economics debate
The Economy subforum fills up with abuse accusations against Más Madrid and the far left, with no data or economic proposals. A moral debate with no substance.