Struggling to insure an old car with no insurance history in Spain

How to insure an old car with no history: the insurers' maze

When you've gone more than five years without a car insurance policy, insurers see you as a risk. And if the vehicle is a 1999 Citroën Xsara Picasso, the equation becomes almost impossible. A driver who has held a licence for 30 years but has no recent insurance was quoted 1,300 euros by AXA for basic third-party cover. The paradox: a car worth barely 500 euros on the second-hand market required insurance worth three times its value.

The problem of having no history

Traditional insurers severely penalise anyone who has not had a policy in their own name in the past five years, even if they have decades of driving experience. The industry's internal logic holds that such drivers are statistically more likely to have accidents, although there is no data to prove it. In practice, many end up asking relatives to take out the policy while they appear as occasional drivers — a solution that works but doesn't build up seniority for the future.

The Consortium alternative

For those with no one to cover them, there is the route of the Consorcio de Compensación de Seguros (Spain's public Insurance Compensation Consortium). All it takes is two written refusals from private insurers for the Consortium to be obliged to accept the policy. The catch: cover is limited to civil liability and third parties only, with no glass, theft or fire. The estimated price is around 250 euros a year, far below commercial offers. It's a legal way to stay on the road without breaking the bank, although the Consortium itself describes it as a basic last resort.

Lying on the questionnaires: a calculated risk

Some choose to falsify their history. One real case: the driver told Verti he had been insured with Mutua Madrileña until two years earlier, when in fact he had gone more than five years without any policy. The insurer offered him extended third-party cover for 500 euros. Lying may work in the short term, but if there's a serious accident, the company can refuse to pay once it discovers the falsehood.

---

The question that remains: how long will it be necessary to resort to tricks to insure old cars? Until insurers adopt fairer algorithms or the Consortium stops being a stopgap, many drivers will remain trapped in a system that penalises those who have been without a car, even with a spotless driving record.

Related forum discussions

• What's the best air freshener you've ever put in your home? · 15 replies
• Sales soaring in Europe: 2,805,872 100% electric cars in the last 12 months · 14 replies
• I'm fat, I weigh 90kg, and I'm going to start going to the gym 3 days a week at 6am · 222 replies
• Those of you taking Spanish civil service exams: do you use the rounds system or the carry-over system? · 16 replies