Spanish unemployment falls by 28,700 but foreign workers drive all job growth
Unemployment in Spain fell by 28,700 people, but all net jobs created went to immigrants. The mass regularization is distorting the figures and reopening the debate.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Spanish unemployment drops by 28,700 but immigrant employment soars: success or replacement?
June's unemployment figures hide a story that goes beyond the optimistic headline. Average Social Security registrations grew by 128,533 people in the month and 605,244 year-on-year, reaching new all-time highs. But 100% of that growth came from foreign workers: for the first time in a long while, Spaniards lost jobs on net while immigrants gained them all.
The regularization that changed the numbers
Since April, coinciding with the start of the immigrant regularization process that ended on June 30, job creation accelerated at a pace matched only by the exit from the pandemic. Regularization applications surged, and with them new Social Security registrations. The dynamism is undeniable, but the quality of the jobs created and their impact on the native labour market raise doubts.
The debate: creation or replacement?
Some read the figures as a success of migration policy: more workers paying in, more revenue for the Social Security system, more consumption. Others see the Spanish working class being replaced by foreign labour willing to accept more precarious conditions. The argument that "at least there will be no shortage of waiters" clashes with the perception that wage and labour standards are being lowered.
What the figures don't hide: tensions and scepticism
Some question the credibility of the official figures, comparing them to CIS polls. But Social Security registration is an administrative record, not a survey. The discussion centres on whether this model is sustainable and whether it really benefits unemployed Spaniards. Meanwhile, the official message keeps repeating "dynamism, dynamism", but October will bring new figures that will confirm or refute the trend.
For now, the Spanish labour market is a machine for creating jobs for immigrants. For nationals, the ball is in the court of training and mobility. Or maybe not. Time —and October's data— will tell.
June's unemployment figures hide a story that goes beyond the optimistic headline. Average Social Security registrations grew by 128,533 people in the month and 605,244 year-on-year, reaching new all-time highs. But 100% of that growth came from foreign workers: for the first time in a long while, Spaniards lost jobs on net while immigrants gained them all.
The regularization that changed the numbers
Since April, coinciding with the start of the immigrant regularization process that ended on June 30, job creation accelerated at a pace matched only by the exit from the pandemic. Regularization applications surged, and with them new Social Security registrations. The dynamism is undeniable, but the quality of the jobs created and their impact on the native labour market raise doubts.
The debate: creation or replacement?
Some read the figures as a success of migration policy: more workers paying in, more revenue for the Social Security system, more consumption. Others see the Spanish working class being replaced by foreign labour willing to accept more precarious conditions. The argument that "at least there will be no shortage of waiters" clashes with the perception that wage and labour standards are being lowered.
What the figures don't hide: tensions and scepticism
Some question the credibility of the official figures, comparing them to CIS polls. But Social Security registration is an administrative record, not a survey. The discussion centres on whether this model is sustainable and whether it really benefits unemployed Spaniards. Meanwhile, the official message keeps repeating "dynamism, dynamism", but October will bring new figures that will confirm or refute the trend.
For now, the Spanish labour market is a machine for creating jobs for immigrants. For nationals, the ball is in the court of training and mobility. Or maybe not. Time —and October's data— will tell.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (32 replies).
More summaries
-
Immigrants now hold 15% of jobs in Spain, growing four times faster
Immigrant employment in Spain is growing four times faster than the overall total and now accounts for 15% of jobs. Yet their unemployment rate is double that of Spaniards. What lies behind it?
-
Immigrant Regularization: The Actual Figure Exceeds 3.5 Million
The government is preparing the regularization of up to 3.5 million immigrants, but only 31.9% contribute to Social Security. The measure is driving up unemployment and...
-
Spain Election Rumors: PSOE Refuses to Call 29-Nov Polls
Election rumors swirl around a November 29 date in Spain as Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez delays housing decrees and refuses to call early polls.
-
ERC demands answers over origin of riots and looting in Barcelona
ERC Barcelona condemns Saturday's disturbances and calls on the City Council and the Generalitat to explain the lack of foresight and support for businesses.
-
Lula wins Brazil as right sweeps Congress
Lula wins the Brazilian presidency while Bolsonaro's right takes the largest Congress and Senate of its recent history.
-
Bomb threat forces Vueling Barcelona-Gran Canaria flight into emergency landing
A Vueling flight from Barcelona to Gran Canaria in Spain made an emergency landing after a bomb threat. The aircraft was moved to a remote area surrounded by security vehicles.