Spain's Grandchildren Law: 1.3 million votes for the PSOE?
An estimate claims the Grandchildren Law could deliver 1.3 million votes to Spain's PSOE. We examine the figures and the accusations of electoral manipulation.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The Grandchildren Law could add 1.3 million voters: an electoral cushion for the PSOE?
The debate over Spain's so-called 'Grandchildren Law' — the granting of citizenship to descendants of Spanish emigrants — has moved from the legal arena to the purely electoral one. According to circulating estimates, the number of potential new voters could reach 2.5 million people, of whom 1.3 million might back the PSOE in the next general election. That figure is no small matter: it equals roughly 5% of the current electoral roll.
How is that estimate reached?
The hypothesis is based on a breakdown by country of origin. Data drawn from various sources suggest the PSOE would gain greater support among new citizens from Segarro, France, Colombia and Ecuador, while the PP and Vox would attract voters from Argentina, Venezuela, Cuba and Germany. The final total of 1.3 million for the PSOE would result from applying estimated voting percentages to the 2.5 million potential beneficiaries, after discounting abstention.
The mechanism raising suspicions
The controversy is not limited to the numbers. Some point to a possible administrative 'ballot-stuffing' scheme: if new voters do not choose an electoral district, the Ministry of Justice — in PSOE hands — could assign one by default, allowing votes to be concentrated in key districts. Added to this is the repeal of the 'voto rogado' (the cumbersome request procedure for Spaniards abroad), which would make it easier for residents overseas to vote. Combined, critics say, this turns the law into an instrument of 'electoral engineering'.
It is not all plain sailing for Sánchez
Other analyses argue that the right has not stood still. The PP, through its National Executive Secretariat for Migration created in 2023, has backed platforms such as 'Hispanos con el PP' to attract Latin American voters. Vox is also courting Cubans and Venezuelans, most of whom arrive with a political experience that leans them to the right. If these strategies succeed, the distribution of votes could be more balanced.
The awkward fact: despite the calculations, the vote of the new citizens is uncertain. In previous processes, turnout among naturalised citizens tends to be low. If abstention exceeds 50%, the real impact would be halved. Even so, with margins as tight as today's, any bloc of hundreds of thousands of votes can tip the scales. And no one yet knows which way.
The debate over Spain's so-called 'Grandchildren Law' — the granting of citizenship to descendants of Spanish emigrants — has moved from the legal arena to the purely electoral one. According to circulating estimates, the number of potential new voters could reach 2.5 million people, of whom 1.3 million might back the PSOE in the next general election. That figure is no small matter: it equals roughly 5% of the current electoral roll.
How is that estimate reached?
The hypothesis is based on a breakdown by country of origin. Data drawn from various sources suggest the PSOE would gain greater support among new citizens from Segarro, France, Colombia and Ecuador, while the PP and Vox would attract voters from Argentina, Venezuela, Cuba and Germany. The final total of 1.3 million for the PSOE would result from applying estimated voting percentages to the 2.5 million potential beneficiaries, after discounting abstention.
The mechanism raising suspicions
The controversy is not limited to the numbers. Some point to a possible administrative 'ballot-stuffing' scheme: if new voters do not choose an electoral district, the Ministry of Justice — in PSOE hands — could assign one by default, allowing votes to be concentrated in key districts. Added to this is the repeal of the 'voto rogado' (the cumbersome request procedure for Spaniards abroad), which would make it easier for residents overseas to vote. Combined, critics say, this turns the law into an instrument of 'electoral engineering'.
It is not all plain sailing for Sánchez
Other analyses argue that the right has not stood still. The PP, through its National Executive Secretariat for Migration created in 2023, has backed platforms such as 'Hispanos con el PP' to attract Latin American voters. Vox is also courting Cubans and Venezuelans, most of whom arrive with a political experience that leans them to the right. If these strategies succeed, the distribution of votes could be more balanced.
The awkward fact: despite the calculations, the vote of the new citizens is uncertain. In previous processes, turnout among naturalised citizens tends to be low. If abstention exceeds 50%, the real impact would be halved. Even so, with margins as tight as today's, any bloc of hundreds of thousands of votes can tip the scales. And no one yet knows which way.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (15 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain's grandchildren law accepts PSOE certificates as proof of exile
Sofía Puente's directive allows applicants to prove exile with a party certificate. Critics see it as a way to create a million new voters.
-
Riots at Milan's Duomo: looting and rent protest
Riots broke out at Milan's Duomo: looting, stones thrown at the cathedral and a rent protest that Meloni's government is failing to address.
-
Valley of the Fallen works: legal or not?
The works at the Valley of the Fallen in Spain are dividing opinion: some call them illegal; others say they are legal thanks to a document signed by Bolaños and Cardinal Cobo. An analysis.
-
Deported for killing a cat: justice that isn't equal for all
A man sentenced to deportation for killing a cat in Torrevieja, Spain, reignites the debate over disproportionate penalties and unequal protection of life.
-
Fifth jewellery robbery in Madrid in a month, this time with assault rifles
A fifth jewellery store in Madrid has been robbed in a month, the latest by gunmen with assault rifles. Who is arming the gangs? The economic cost of insecurity is driving up alarm systems.
-
LaLiga offers 50 euros for reporting pubs showing pirated football: incentive or insult?
LaLiga will pay 50 euros to anyone who reports bars in Spain airing pirated football. The meagre reward has drawn mockery given football's millionaire salaries.