Poopularity: the ranking site for what people hate is sinking
Poopularity, a ranking site where you vote for what you hate, is failing because nobody understands whether the poop is a negative vote. The irony of AI that doesn't do the…
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Poopularity: the ranking of the most hated that nobody understands
Starting a business now takes nothing more than a vacation, a Claude account and a couple of afternoons with Codex. That's how Poopularity was born, a live ranking site covering food, animals and other categories, with a twist: here you don't vote for what you like, but for what you hate. The number one spot is the most hated thing of the moment. The concept is deliberately simple, almost scatological: a poop to punish, a toilet tank to defend. But there's a serious problem: users can't tell whether the poop is a negative or a positive vote.
The confusion is no small matter. The creator himself admits that "in my head it made sense", and the criticism points out that the toilet metaphor communicates nothing. One commenter suggests swapping the icon for a flower: bad smell versus good smell, a concept that would be understood in seconds. The lesson here is a classic one: an MVP must be explainable in the blink of an eye, and if it depends on your explanation, it's dead.
The business model has another shadow: free daily votes and the option to buy extra votes. The person behind it admits that his theory is that nobody will pay for this nonsense. And some joke that AI hasn't delivered the white-collar work it promised: if a machine wrote the code, why do we still have to give design feedback? The design details — flat backgrounds, transparent boxes, nonexistent hierarchy — are a manual on how not to build a website in 2026. Even AGI couldn't have done better. Or maybe it could, if someone had asked for its opinion.
Here the analysis ends, with no resolution. The website exists, it's free, it's in English and it's looking for its market. Whether anyone figures out whether to flush or not is another story.
Starting a business now takes nothing more than a vacation, a Claude account and a couple of afternoons with Codex. That's how Poopularity was born, a live ranking site covering food, animals and other categories, with a twist: here you don't vote for what you like, but for what you hate. The number one spot is the most hated thing of the moment. The concept is deliberately simple, almost scatological: a poop to punish, a toilet tank to defend. But there's a serious problem: users can't tell whether the poop is a negative or a positive vote.
The confusion is no small matter. The creator himself admits that "in my head it made sense", and the criticism points out that the toilet metaphor communicates nothing. One commenter suggests swapping the icon for a flower: bad smell versus good smell, a concept that would be understood in seconds. The lesson here is a classic one: an MVP must be explainable in the blink of an eye, and if it depends on your explanation, it's dead.
The business model has another shadow: free daily votes and the option to buy extra votes. The person behind it admits that his theory is that nobody will pay for this nonsense. And some joke that AI hasn't delivered the white-collar work it promised: if a machine wrote the code, why do we still have to give design feedback? The design details — flat backgrounds, transparent boxes, nonexistent hierarchy — are a manual on how not to build a website in 2026. Even AGI couldn't have done better. Or maybe it could, if someone had asked for its opinion.
Here the analysis ends, with no resolution. The website exists, it's free, it's in English and it's looking for its market. Whether anyone figures out whether to flush or not is another story.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (33 replies).
More summaries
-
Sol, Terra or Astra: which AI is cheapest for coding
AI coding plans range from 20 to 100 euros a month: a 20-dollar subscription delivers 45 to 75 minutes of intensive work per day.
-
Spain's €3,000 Kit Digital grant acts as a hidden rental scheme
The Kit Digital grant promises €3,000 for SMEs, but the computer voucher functions as a high-priced rental with constant monitoring. Analysis and user experiences.
-
Pica Pica 24 Hours: What the Franchise Promises vs. What the Franchisee Gets
Pica Pica 24 Hours markets itself as a turnkey vending business, but in one case cleaning and neighbor complaints fell to the franchisee.
-
Forum debate: 140 euro sunglasses vs 25 euro pair
A forum user buys Hawkers for 25 euros rather than risk 140 euro Ray-Bans. The debate claims polycarbonate and UV400 protection are equivalent. There…
-
27m² rent-free premises in Spain: newsstand, supplements or rent it out?
An unemployed man in Spain owns a 27m² commercial space and is torn between opening a shop or renting it out. Forum users estimate 300-400€ in rent versus 4,000€ in revenue needed for a business.
-
IT freelancer in Spain: how to pay less tax without inventing expenses
A Spanish IT freelancer looks for deductible expenses to pay less income tax. Tax brackets don't work the way he thinks, and the real list of deductions is short.