You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
One dead and 30 injured on Singapore to Bangkok flight
A 73-year-old British man died and 30 people were injured after a Boeing 777 dropped 6,000 feet on a flight from Singapore to Bangkok. Seatbelts were crucial.
One dead and 30 injured on Singapore to Bangkok flight
A 73-year-old British passenger died and 30 others were injured on a Singapore Airlines flight traveling the London-Bangkok route. The aircraft, a Boeing 777, suffered a sudden drop of about 6,000 feet, tossing those not wearing seatbelts into the air. "Suddenly, the plane began to tilt and there were tremors," one passenger reported. "Everyone who was seated and without a seatbelt was immediately thrown toward the ceiling." Some hit the overhead bins with such force that they dented them. Boeing issued a statement of condolence, ensuring their "thoughts" were with the passengers and crew. Subsequent debate has been split between those who see a manufacturer failure and those who point out that the 777 has decades of service without structural issues.
Details of the incident and the aircraft
According to a discussion post, the 777 is a model with more than 1,500 units flying and only two previous "accidents": the shootdown in Ukraine and the disappearance of MH370. That track record leads part of the analysis to rule out a design flaw and focus attention on severe turbulence. The plane weighs more than 300 tons and, despite the violence of the episode, the structure remained intact. "The fact that a plane like the 777 turns into a giant blender and remains structurally intact gives an idea of how well it is built," one post summarizes. The other current points to altitude and the route: flying over Asia and Europe involves crossing complicated turbulence zones, and some argue that climate change is aggravating these episodes.
The seatbelt: the only real defense
The most repeated coincidence is that wearing a seatbelt would have prevented most of the injuries. "Unless you are going to get up, you must keep your seatbelt fastened at all times on planes," one participant summarizes. The described sequence matches a loss of lift: the aircraft drops like an elevator until it regains air under the wings. In those seconds, anyone standing or unsecured is thrown. There are accounts of similar episodes flying over the Himalayas with drops of up to 1,000 meters, and a case in the 70s on a flight to Palma de Mallorca. The seatbelt sign is not decorative: any severe turbulence turns the aisle into a trap.
Loss of confidence in the manufacturer
Boeing's recent track record weighs more than any technical data. The two 737 Max accidents, with hundreds dead, resulted from software that corrected an imbalance caused by engines that were more powerful and heavier than those originally designed for that structure. "At first the software failed and it took two planes crashing to ground the fleet," one post recalls. Added to this is that the 787 had to change manufacturers due to production problems, with parts of the fuselage being lost mid-flight. The conclusion of much of the analysis is that the problem is not the 777, but the company's drift.
Who flies Boeing and who avoids it
Ryanair operates solely with Boeing. Air Europa uses Boeing mainly and carries questioning due to the 1,000 million euro public bailout linked to Begoña Gómez. Some claim they will refrain from flying with those airlines as a precaution. Against that, the opposing argument is that commercial aviation remains the safest mode of transport and that the antiestéticar of flying is a bias: the probability of dying on a journey is tiny compared to traveling by road. The discussion often drifts into the realm of phobia, and there are no data there to convince anyone.
The shadow of climate change
Part of the analysis maintains that severe turbulence is becoming more frequent due to global warming, which alters high-altitude wind patterns. The idea circulates strongly on social networks and appears cited in the debate itself. There is no closed technical consensus on how much this specific episode is due to that factor, but the hypothesis is gaining weight in aviation forums. What is a fact is that the route between Asia and Europe crosses some of the most unstable zones on the planet.
The shocking fact is not the drop: it is that an aircraft of more than 300 tons withstands such a jolt and lands intact. The uncomfortable question is not whether the 777 is safe, but how many of the injured would have escaped with their seatbelts fastened.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (102 replies).
Judge Peinado demands Begoña Gómez prove her London trip after finding no entry stamp in her passport. The UK has not stamped passports since 2004. A reversal of the burden of proof?
Begoña Gómez has requested the Madrid Court restore her passport, arguing that "the summer season is approaching," while her defense maintains there is no flight risk.