Low cost as a mirror of Spain's economic lumpenisation
The rise of Primark, own-label brands and discounters reveals a process of cultural and material impoverishment affecting millions of households in Spain.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Low cost as a mirror of Spain's economic lumpenisation
Primark turned over 68 million euros in Spain in 2008 with 11 stores. Five years later, with 35 outlets, sales had soared to 972 million. Ryanair, meanwhile, went from 25 million domestic passengers over the five years 2002-2007 to 28.45 million in 2011 alone, snatching the lead from Iberia. These are two pieces of the same puzzle: the Spanish economy has surrendered to low-cost consumption, and behind that phenomenon there is more than just cheap prices.
Own-label brands take over the shopping basket
Inflation in 2022 accelerated a process already under way. According to the consultancy IRI, the market share of own-label food products jumped to 43.5%, a six-point rise in just five weeks. Mercadona, Lidl and Aldi gained market share in 2021 while traditional retailers shrank. The discounter is becoming the dominant pattern of consumption, not by choice but by objective necessity.
Waiter wages for a waiter economy
The analysis those in power like least points to the productive structure. A country specialising in tourism, hospitality and low value-added services generates jobs with low incomes and precarious contracts. Someone earning 1,200 euros cannot afford quality clothing or a varied diet. The consequence is visible on the streets: uniform aesthetics, deteriorating public spaces, a loss of cultural reference points. 'Lumpenisation' is not an ideological concept: it is the snapshot of a sinking middle class.
The debate over causes: inequality or cultural change?
While some point to structural inequality —low wages, unaffordable housing, inflation— as the engine of the process, others focus on migration phenomena and shifts in values. What nobody disputes is the outcome: the coexistence of severe poverty affecting four million people (a figure from Cáritas and EAPN updated in 2022) with mass consumption of disposable, ultra-cheap products. The question hanging in the air is whether the low-cost economy is a lifeline or a drag that entrenches precarity.
Primark turned over 68 million euros in Spain in 2008 with 11 stores. Five years later, with 35 outlets, sales had soared to 972 million. Ryanair, meanwhile, went from 25 million domestic passengers over the five years 2002-2007 to 28.45 million in 2011 alone, snatching the lead from Iberia. These are two pieces of the same puzzle: the Spanish economy has surrendered to low-cost consumption, and behind that phenomenon there is more than just cheap prices.
Own-label brands take over the shopping basket
Inflation in 2022 accelerated a process already under way. According to the consultancy IRI, the market share of own-label food products jumped to 43.5%, a six-point rise in just five weeks. Mercadona, Lidl and Aldi gained market share in 2021 while traditional retailers shrank. The discounter is becoming the dominant pattern of consumption, not by choice but by objective necessity.
Waiter wages for a waiter economy
The analysis those in power like least points to the productive structure. A country specialising in tourism, hospitality and low value-added services generates jobs with low incomes and precarious contracts. Someone earning 1,200 euros cannot afford quality clothing or a varied diet. The consequence is visible on the streets: uniform aesthetics, deteriorating public spaces, a loss of cultural reference points. 'Lumpenisation' is not an ideological concept: it is the snapshot of a sinking middle class.
The debate over causes: inequality or cultural change?
While some point to structural inequality —low wages, unaffordable housing, inflation— as the engine of the process, others focus on migration phenomena and shifts in values. What nobody disputes is the outcome: the coexistence of severe poverty affecting four million people (a figure from Cáritas and EAPN updated in 2022) with mass consumption of disposable, ultra-cheap products. The question hanging in the air is whether the low-cost economy is a lifeline or a drag that entrenches precarity.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (42 replies).
More summaries
-
Record overcrowding in Spain: 4 million people in severe poverty
Spain leads the rise in overcrowding in the EU: 4 million people in severe poverty, slum flats with 40 tenants and sky-high rents.
-
Mercadona's model divides opinion: neither cheap nor great
Is Mercadona more expensive than Aldi and Lidl? We analyse the Spanish chain's model: prices, own-brand products, suppliers and employment.
-
PSOE Spokesperson Mínguez Faces Questions Over Partner's 30 Rentals
Data on the 30 rental properties owned by PSOE spokesperson Montse Mínguez's partner emerges, as she labels inquiries a personal attack.
-
Row in Spain's Basque Country over migrants used as cannon fodder
An image of migrants at a protest linked to the Basque pro-independence movement has reignited the debate over their use as human shields and political tensions in the Basque Country.
-
What an AI says a war with Morocco would cost Spain
The AI claims Spain would gain territory and Western Sahara would become an ally. The real cost: millions of refugees and the closure of the Schengen area.
-
Last military officer convicted of Víctor Jara's murder arrested in Chile
Chilean police have arrested the 80-year-old former military man, who had been on the run for a quarter of a century. He was convicted of torturing and murdering singer-songwriter Víctor Jara in 1973.