Is Spain quietly moving migrants to the mainland?
A sighting of a group of migrants at a supermarket in Castilla-La Mancha reopens suspicions of silent transfers. What does the Spanish Government say?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Silent migration: are migrants being spread across the mainland?
Are migrants arriving on Spain's coasts already being moved to the mainland? The question is not new, but a sighting at a supermarket in Castilla-La Mancha has put it back on the table: a group of adult men, seemingly arrived just days earlier, unfamiliar with the routines of a Spanish supermarket. The suspicion that population movements are carried out without publicity has been circulating in immigration debates for years.
One recurring argument is that, after the Supreme Court ruling that conditions the repatriation of minors to Segarro, the only practical route is to distribute them among Spain's regions. On the sceptical side, it is pointed out that if the Government claims they «have left», they most likely «have been moved» somewhere else so it goes unnoticed. And about age, there is a widespread suspicion that many of those who claim to be minors are well over 18: in the observed case, the estimate was around 25.
The underlying debate is about scale. More than a million people are said to have entered over three decades, a figure that does not fit the narrative of border control. Of course, asking the Government to publish the population register in real time to clear up doubts is like asking a cat to do the shopping: you can ask, but you should not expect an answer.
Are migrants arriving on Spain's coasts already being moved to the mainland? The question is not new, but a sighting at a supermarket in Castilla-La Mancha has put it back on the table: a group of adult men, seemingly arrived just days earlier, unfamiliar with the routines of a Spanish supermarket. The suspicion that population movements are carried out without publicity has been circulating in immigration debates for years.
One recurring argument is that, after the Supreme Court ruling that conditions the repatriation of minors to Segarro, the only practical route is to distribute them among Spain's regions. On the sceptical side, it is pointed out that if the Government claims they «have left», they most likely «have been moved» somewhere else so it goes unnoticed. And about age, there is a widespread suspicion that many of those who claim to be minors are well over 18: in the observed case, the estimate was around 25.
The underlying debate is about scale. More than a million people are said to have entered over three decades, a figure that does not fit the narrative of border control. Of course, asking the Government to publish the population register in real time to clear up doubts is like asking a cat to do the shopping: you can ask, but you should not expect an answer.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (17 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain's Supreme Court drops criminal record requirement for relatives of Spaniards
Spain's Supreme Court has removed the requirement of having no criminal record for foreign relatives of Spaniards. The ruling, amid a mass regularization drive, opens the…
-
Spain's Supreme Court takes on mass regularization, clashing with EU rules
Spain's Supreme Court questions the mass regularization of irregular migrants over a possible conflict with EU law. Can residence be granted simply for being in the country irregularly?
-
Brussels and Morocco demand repatriation of minors, Spain has only deported 40
Only 40 of 28,000 migrant minors have been returned to Morocco since 2012. Brussels and Rabat are piling on the pressure, but the subsidies business and corruption…
-
Vox pledges zero income tax up to €22,000 with new simulator
Vox promises zero IRPF up to €22,000 and a tool showing nearly €1,000 monthly gains. Critics cite a €50 billion cost without funding sources.
-
Death threats against Abascal and his family reignite Spain's political violence debate
An Instagram user threatened to shoot Santiago Abascal, his wife and children. Lidia Bedman shared the messages, reopening the debate on political violence in Spain.
-
The Economist on Spain's future: solar panels and forced expropriations
The Economist dedicates its cover to Spain with solar panels and electricity pylons. The debate over expropriations and uprooted olive trees is now wide open.