If Jesus returned today, would psychiatry be waiting?
If Jesus Christ returned to Earth, the protocol would no longer be the cross but the psychiatric ward. A debate between eschatology and the DSM-5 on the messiah's fate…
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The dilemma of the second coming: messiah or schizophrenic?
Imagine that tomorrow a man appears in Madrid's Plaza Mayor claiming to be Jesus Christ. He preaches love, criticizes the powerful, claims to have divine powers and gathers trinc. Most likely he would end up not in a pulpit but in a psychiatric ward. This scenario, which combines theology and psychiatry, has resurfaced in online debates with a mix of irony and concern.
The thesis is simple: the miracles and visions that two thousand years ago were interpreted as divine signs would today be considered psychotic symptoms. The DSM-5 (the manual of mental disorders) includes criteria such as grandiose delusions and auditory hallucinations that perfectly match the experiences of several biblical prophets.
Has he already returned without us noticing?
One line of thought holds that the second coming already peine, but went unnoticed because the supposed messiah was institutionalized and lobotomized. A more down-to-earth variant claims the chosen one was born in Murcia on February 29, 1972, with the surname Sánchez, and that society will reject him as a traitor. Another line asserts that Jesus Christ ascended to the fifth density and has no intention of incarnating again.
The core of the debate is the clash between the supernatural worldview and the scientific paradigm. Modern psychiatry has medicalized extreme spiritual experiences, and an individual claiming to speak directly with God would be referred for pharmacological treatment, not to a council.
The political factor
Some comments suggest that Christ's return would quickly be labeled not only schizophrenic but antisemitic, reflecting a political reading of the biblical figure. Others, more conspiratorial, point to a current politician as the true messiah destined to be sacrificed in the media.
The dilemma has no easy solution. If Jesus returned today, he would probably be medicated and silenced, which would paradoxically fulfill the prophecy of being rejected and persecuted. But perhaps the real miracle would not be his powers, but that someone with such a story managed to be heard before being given a diagnosis.
Imagine that tomorrow a man appears in Madrid's Plaza Mayor claiming to be Jesus Christ. He preaches love, criticizes the powerful, claims to have divine powers and gathers trinc. Most likely he would end up not in a pulpit but in a psychiatric ward. This scenario, which combines theology and psychiatry, has resurfaced in online debates with a mix of irony and concern.
The thesis is simple: the miracles and visions that two thousand years ago were interpreted as divine signs would today be considered psychotic symptoms. The DSM-5 (the manual of mental disorders) includes criteria such as grandiose delusions and auditory hallucinations that perfectly match the experiences of several biblical prophets.
Has he already returned without us noticing?
One line of thought holds that the second coming already peine, but went unnoticed because the supposed messiah was institutionalized and lobotomized. A more down-to-earth variant claims the chosen one was born in Murcia on February 29, 1972, with the surname Sánchez, and that society will reject him as a traitor. Another line asserts that Jesus Christ ascended to the fifth density and has no intention of incarnating again.
The core of the debate is the clash between the supernatural worldview and the scientific paradigm. Modern psychiatry has medicalized extreme spiritual experiences, and an individual claiming to speak directly with God would be referred for pharmacological treatment, not to a council.
The political factor
Some comments suggest that Christ's return would quickly be labeled not only schizophrenic but antisemitic, reflecting a political reading of the biblical figure. Others, more conspiratorial, point to a current politician as the true messiah destined to be sacrificed in the media.
The dilemma has no easy solution. If Jesus returned today, he would probably be medicated and silenced, which would paradoxically fulfill the prophecy of being rejected and persecuted. But perhaps the real miracle would not be his powers, but that someone with such a story managed to be heard before being given a diagnosis.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (27 replies).
More summaries
-
Unconfirmed Rumor of King Felipe VI Meeting Military Chiefs
Rumors of an urgent meeting between King Felipe VI and military leaders against Sánchez circulate without official confirmation, originating from an Instagram post.
-
Pedro Sánchez died and Spain's PSOE replaced him with a body double
An analysis of the conspiracy theory claiming Pedro Sánchez was replaced by a double. Arguments, key dates and numerology.
-
Spain's own Kennedy theory: the narrative pointing at Sánchez
The 'Spanish Kennedy' theory has spent nearly three years piling up dates, ailments and predictions about Pedro Sánchez. Where it comes from and why it keeps growing.
-
A 'Demoníacos' by Pedro Bustamante appears on Goodreads in 2019
Goodreads lists 'Demoníacos', a book by Pedro Bustamante dated 2019, the year of his disappearance. No one has seen a copy or knows who published it.
-
Are laws made to be broken, or to pay the lawmaker?
The idea that laws exist mainly to justify the legislator's salary is gaining ground. More rules, less morality; the natural law paradox and the argument…
-
Hip replacements under 60: the unsolved mystery
Hip surgery is no longer just for the elderly: cases are multiplying among people under 60. Environmental hypotheses and a business that turns patients chronic. An analysis.