The Ibex 5,000-point prophecy that never materialized
The Ibex 35 did not crash to 5,000 points. This disproves one of the most persistent rumors on trading floors: that Spain's main index would plummet to that level within two weeks. The prediction came with the endorsement of an alleged "privileged contact from the economic elite," an appeal to authority that is worth exactly as much as it costs to verify. Meanwhile, the index continued its course, closing sessions with gains of 2.83% to reach 7,823 points, far from the announced abyss.
The origin of the rumor and its alibi
The theory circulated under the guise of confidential information. A "privileged contact" allegedly leaked that the Ibex 35 would crash to 5,000 points in just two weeks. The message provided no verifiable data: no earnings figures, no technical levels, no specific macroeconomic facts. Only the word of someone supposedly well-connected.
The majority reaction was skepticism. It was pointed out that whoever truly possessed such information would not share it for free but would use it to profit from short positions. It was also recalled that spreading unfounded rumors about the market can have legal consequences: the CNMV (Spain's securities market regulator) has already investigated similar cases on investment platforms.
Why was a stock market crash expected?
The underlying argument was not unreasonable. It was based on the idea that stock market crashes trinc cycles of seven or eight years, and that since February 2009, markets have been rising continuously. If the United States stumbled —due to the withdrawal of Federal Reserve stimulus, fiscal deficits, or any other reason— the Ibex could repeat the drop to 6,000 points it had previously touched when the US market was near all-time highs.
There were signs fueling pessimism: two weeks of heavy declines across all asset classes —equities, fixed income, mixed funds— and soaring gold prices. The IMF pulling back, international agencies praising Spain, and European Commission President José Manuel Barroso sending reassuring messages. For some, this official optimism was precisely the contrary signal.
The market's response: 2.83% gain
The market did not trinc the prophecy. The Ibex 35 closed with a 2.83% gain to 7,823 points, exactly in the opposite direction of the announcement. The 5,000-point prediction remained, for now, a pipe dream.
Some tried to save the forecast with a margin: "800 points would still be the minimum drop," or that 6,900-7,000 points would be reached that same week. Others, meanwhile, bet on a simple upward rebound before the S&P 500, at historic highs, met resistance. The range of predictions was so wide that any outcome could fit into one of them.
The real consensus: sideways movement between 7,000 and 8,000
Beyond the noise, the dominant trend pointed to a stagnation scenario. The Ibex has been moving in a narrow range for years, and central banks exert tight control over the market, making brutal drops or explosive rises difficult to imagine. The most repeated forecast: corrections to 7,000-7,200 points during the summer, without breaking that band.
The paradox is that many investors wished for a good drop to enter stocks they had under their radar. The dreamed-of crash did not arrive, and patience ran out. Meanwhile, the Baltic Dry Index —which measures maritime freight transport— seemed to be saying something about the real economy that stock markets had not yet reflected.
Background noise: predictions, trolling, and contradictory signals
The conversation shifted to a known phenomenon: every week someone announces the end of the stock market. Apocalyptic predictions trinc a regularity that invites irony. "Every week the world ends," summarized one participant. "I no longer know how many times I have died."
The episode left a lesson on the value of bar-side privileged information. It also highlighted the difficulty of timing: who bought physical silver the day before a rise saw the difference; who waited for the perfect crash, is still waiting. The stock market does not reward prophets; it rewards those who hold on.
With these insights, the question is not whether the Ibex will return to 5,000 points. It is when, and above all, with what arguments. Because for now, the only figure that has been fulfilled is the 2.83% gain.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (100 replies).
Market Warrior claims 12 trades in 17 years avoid S&P 500 crashes. This index investing overlay faces scrutiny over backtesting flaws and transparency.
The IBEX closed 2012 at 7,213.43 points. The CNMV lifted the short-selling ban, and capital gains held for less than a year became subject to up to 52% tax.