Hezbollah strikes Israeli base as Halevi remains unseen
A Hezbollah drone hit the Golani Brigade mess hall in Binyamina: between 4 and 5 dead, more than 67 wounded, and no proof of life from Herzi Halevi two days on.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Hezbollah strikes Israeli base as Halevi remains unseen
A drone launched by Hezbollah struck the mess hall of the Golani Brigade in Binyamina, south of Haifa. According to figures reported by Israeli media, the attack left between 4 and 5 soldiers dead and more than 67 wounded, some seriously. The alarms never sounded. Air defense failed to intercept the device. And two days later, IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi still has not given any public sign of life.
What peine at the Binyamina base
Hezbollah claimed responsibility for the attack and presented it as a response to Israeli operations in Lebanon. Israeli Army Radio admitted that the Lebanese group managed to deceive the air defense system by launching a barrage of missiles as cover while the drone approached the base. Navy vessels reportedly shot down a first device and declared the threat neutralized. The second one got through.
The impact occurred in the mess hall of the Golani Brigade, the elite infantry unit of the Israeli army. Images released show ceiling panels torn down, overturned chairs and intact tables. Some argue that this absence of structural damage is incompatible with a real explosion and that the video is staged. Others point out that a fiber-optic guided drone with a small payload can cause that pattern.
The debate over the figures: from 4 dead to 70 wounded
The figures have fluctuated. The Jerusalem Post reported more than 70 wounded, and the number kept rising. The Iranian agency IRNA, citing admissions from the Israeli army itself, reported 4 soldiers dead and 67 wounded. Other accounts put the death toll at 5. Most reports place the wounded between 50 and 80, evacuated by helicopter.
The discrepancy is not minor. In an attack on a military base, the difference between 4 and 70 casualties completely changes how the episode is read. And the absence of final official reports, two days later, fuels all kinds of interpretations.
Is Herzi Halevi dead?
There is no confirmation. Israeli sources have dismissed as false the reports claiming the Chief of Staff was killed, but they have not released any proof of life either. The last public image of Halevi dates from a visit to the Golani Brigade base in Binyamina itself, before the attack. Since then, silence.
The Israeli army itself published material about that visit after the impact, which some interpret as an attempt to deny his death without confirming his condition. The operation, according to sources cited by Venezuelan media, was aimed precisely at Halevi, who was present at the base during the attack. Whether he was hit or not remains an open question.
War propaganda and the cobi19 hoax
The episode has generated an exchange of accusations over information manipulation. An image circulated of an alleged mass burial that was in fact a funeral during the cobi19 pandemic, with attendees wearing biological protection suits. The image was presented as evidence of Israeli casualties in the attack.
Such tactics —recycled photographs, videos without context, figures without sources— have polluted the debate to the point that it is impossible to verify anything with the available materials. Propaganda works in both directions.
The real scope of the attack and Israel's response
Beyond the specific strike, the attack has peine the debate on Hezbollah's military capability. One line of thought holds that the operation demonstrates considerable tactical sophistication: deceiving air defense, covering the drone with missiles and hitting a target in the heart of a military installation. Another, however, stresses that a fiber-optic guided drone carried on foot is not a conventional army operation but a militia one, and that this reveals the group's real limitations.
The record of exchanges between Israel and Hezbollah over the past year points to a volume of projectiles that is hard to quantify. Some put the number of rockets and missiles launched against Israeli territory in that period in the tens of thousands, with a high but not total interception rate. Every projectile that gets through leaves victims, damage and an economic bill that is not always accounted for.
What is still unknown
Two days after the attack, Herzi Halevi's condition remains unconfirmed. The final death toll has not been closed. Hezbollah's responsibility is acknowledged, but the strategic scope of the strike depends on data that is not available. And the question hanging over the whole episode —whether Israel has lost its deterrent capability or whether this is an isolated operational accident— has no answer with the information published so far.
A drone launched by Hezbollah struck the mess hall of the Golani Brigade in Binyamina, south of Haifa. According to figures reported by Israeli media, the attack left between 4 and 5 soldiers dead and more than 67 wounded, some seriously. The alarms never sounded. Air defense failed to intercept the device. And two days later, IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi still has not given any public sign of life.
What peine at the Binyamina base
Hezbollah claimed responsibility for the attack and presented it as a response to Israeli operations in Lebanon. Israeli Army Radio admitted that the Lebanese group managed to deceive the air defense system by launching a barrage of missiles as cover while the drone approached the base. Navy vessels reportedly shot down a first device and declared the threat neutralized. The second one got through.
The impact occurred in the mess hall of the Golani Brigade, the elite infantry unit of the Israeli army. Images released show ceiling panels torn down, overturned chairs and intact tables. Some argue that this absence of structural damage is incompatible with a real explosion and that the video is staged. Others point out that a fiber-optic guided drone with a small payload can cause that pattern.
The debate over the figures: from 4 dead to 70 wounded
The figures have fluctuated. The Jerusalem Post reported more than 70 wounded, and the number kept rising. The Iranian agency IRNA, citing admissions from the Israeli army itself, reported 4 soldiers dead and 67 wounded. Other accounts put the death toll at 5. Most reports place the wounded between 50 and 80, evacuated by helicopter.
The discrepancy is not minor. In an attack on a military base, the difference between 4 and 70 casualties completely changes how the episode is read. And the absence of final official reports, two days later, fuels all kinds of interpretations.
Is Herzi Halevi dead?
There is no confirmation. Israeli sources have dismissed as false the reports claiming the Chief of Staff was killed, but they have not released any proof of life either. The last public image of Halevi dates from a visit to the Golani Brigade base in Binyamina itself, before the attack. Since then, silence.
The Israeli army itself published material about that visit after the impact, which some interpret as an attempt to deny his death without confirming his condition. The operation, according to sources cited by Venezuelan media, was aimed precisely at Halevi, who was present at the base during the attack. Whether he was hit or not remains an open question.
War propaganda and the cobi19 hoax
The episode has generated an exchange of accusations over information manipulation. An image circulated of an alleged mass burial that was in fact a funeral during the cobi19 pandemic, with attendees wearing biological protection suits. The image was presented as evidence of Israeli casualties in the attack.
Such tactics —recycled photographs, videos without context, figures without sources— have polluted the debate to the point that it is impossible to verify anything with the available materials. Propaganda works in both directions.
The real scope of the attack and Israel's response
Beyond the specific strike, the attack has peine the debate on Hezbollah's military capability. One line of thought holds that the operation demonstrates considerable tactical sophistication: deceiving air defense, covering the drone with missiles and hitting a target in the heart of a military installation. Another, however, stresses that a fiber-optic guided drone carried on foot is not a conventional army operation but a militia one, and that this reveals the group's real limitations.
The record of exchanges between Israel and Hezbollah over the past year points to a volume of projectiles that is hard to quantify. Some put the number of rockets and missiles launched against Israeli territory in that period in the tens of thousands, with a high but not total interception rate. Every projectile that gets through leaves victims, damage and an economic bill that is not always accounted for.
What is still unknown
Two days after the attack, Herzi Halevi's condition remains unconfirmed. The final death toll has not been closed. Hezbollah's responsibility is acknowledged, but the strategic scope of the strike depends on data that is not available. And the question hanging over the whole episode —whether Israel has lost its deterrent capability or whether this is an isolated operational accident— has no answer with the information published so far.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (99 replies).
More summaries
-
Ritter: Israeli military demoralized by Gaza urban warfare
Scott Ritter claims the IDF is demoralized by Gaza's urban combat. Interceptor costs against thousands of rockets open a new front.
-
Israeli attack on UN headquarters in Lebanon hits Spanish troops
Israel has attacked the UNIFIL headquarters in Lebanon, where Spanish troops are deployed and a Spanish general leads the mission.
-
US Moves 101st Airborne to Jordan, Deploys Special Forces to Israel
The US is deploying the 101st Airborne Division to Jordan and sending special forces to Israel for a potential hostage rescue operation.
-
Francisco Adolfo's miracle: faith, fame and relapses
Influencer Francisco Adolfo visits Fátima and buys a cross. Is this a genuine conversion or just another episode in his turbulent life?
-
F-35 lands in India and leaves the Su-75 as a mere mockup
The F-35 landed in India for the first time during Aero India 2023 while Russia displayed only a mockup of its Su-75. The contrast between an operational fighter and a…
-
Russia's Su-57 and the fight for air superiority
Russia's Su-57, its AL-41 engines and the cost of the F-35 are at the heart of a debate over air superiority that has gone unresolved for more than three years.