Germany Does Not Ban Charging Electric Cars at Home, Limits Power

A German regulation limiting electric car charging power does not ban long trips. A royal decree has been turned into fake news.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Germany Does Not Ban Charging Electric Cars at Home, Limits Power
Germany does not ban electric charging, it limits power

A viral message claims that in Germany, "charging for 3 hours will soon only provide 50 km" and that private charging for long journeys will cease to be possible, all in the name of the electrical grid. The assertion is spreading as a frontal attack on electric cars. The problem, point out those who have looked into the regulation, is that it mixes a real decree with an invented conclusion.

What's true about the German limit?

What exists is section 14a of the Energy Industry Act, promoted by the Federal Network Agency (BNetzA). Its objective is to allow operators to reduce charging power during times of grid stress. The practical effect is not a ban on trips: it is a power cap, set around 4.5 kW, which would affect not only cars but also heating equipment of 6 kW or more.

The calculation fueling the fake news converts that reduced power into range: three hours for about 50 km. From there to the headline of a "ban" is a leap that no document supports.

The core issue: electrifying everything and the grid that can't keep up

Beneath the fake news lies a serious debate. If cars, heating, and industry switch to electricity, the system will require several times the current generation and grid capacity. It points to a Norwegian level of electrification for which not all European countries are equipped. And the finer detail, concerning the power cap and its fine print, remains unresolved.

Here the trail goes cold. Neither the regulation is finalized nor the real effect on long trips has been measured. There is only a number, that of power, and no figure on how many journeys it truly affects.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (17 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back