From Camps to Ayuso: impunity as a system in Spain
From Camps' suits to the complaints against Ayuso: history repeats itself. Political impunity in Spain is not an accident, it is a system. Analysis.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Ayuso, Camps and Barberá: political impunity is no coincidence
The latest complaint against Isabel Díaz Ayuso is going nowhere. Or at least that is what accumulated experience suggests: the cases that taint Spain's political class trinc a predictable rhythm, and the outcome is usually dismissal or acquittal. It is not a conspiracy: it is a system that has been working for decades.
The precedent nobody wants to see
Francisco Camps, in the suits case, spent years in the courts only to end up acquitted. Rita Barberá saw the accusations fizzle out until her death, leaving the process in nothing. Now Ayuso, with a new front peine, seems destined for the same script. The feeling that nothing happens is not a fluke: it is the norm.
The list of resignations is so short it is dizzying
In the last 30 years, the number of politicians who have left office out of sheer shame is close to zero. The most sceptical answer points to a maxim: "lie, and something will stick." The least conspiratorial points to the fact that admitting a mistake carries a higher political cost than weathering the storm. Only two names are spared: Gerardo Iglesias, who went back to the mines, and Luis Acín, an MP from the Aragonese PP (People's Party) who resigned over disagreements about the war. Two cases in three decades.
The economic cost of impunity
From an economic perspective, impunity is no trivial matter. Confidence in institutions is an asset traded on capital markets: when scandals are dismissed without consequences, perceived risk rises and investment feels it. There is no exact metric, but the historical precedent suggests the price is paid, even if it never shows up in the budgets.
With this track record, the question is not whether Ayuso falls; it is when the case gets dismissed. The machinery has a written script and repeats it with every case. As far as anyone knows, nobody has yet found a way to break it. The only novelty would be if this time something actually moved. The reservations are many.
The latest complaint against Isabel Díaz Ayuso is going nowhere. Or at least that is what accumulated experience suggests: the cases that taint Spain's political class trinc a predictable rhythm, and the outcome is usually dismissal or acquittal. It is not a conspiracy: it is a system that has been working for decades.
The precedent nobody wants to see
Francisco Camps, in the suits case, spent years in the courts only to end up acquitted. Rita Barberá saw the accusations fizzle out until her death, leaving the process in nothing. Now Ayuso, with a new front peine, seems destined for the same script. The feeling that nothing happens is not a fluke: it is the norm.
The list of resignations is so short it is dizzying
In the last 30 years, the number of politicians who have left office out of sheer shame is close to zero. The most sceptical answer points to a maxim: "lie, and something will stick." The least conspiratorial points to the fact that admitting a mistake carries a higher political cost than weathering the storm. Only two names are spared: Gerardo Iglesias, who went back to the mines, and Luis Acín, an MP from the Aragonese PP (People's Party) who resigned over disagreements about the war. Two cases in three decades.
The economic cost of impunity
From an economic perspective, impunity is no trivial matter. Confidence in institutions is an asset traded on capital markets: when scandals are dismissed without consequences, perceived risk rises and investment feels it. There is no exact metric, but the historical precedent suggests the price is paid, even if it never shows up in the budgets.
With this track record, the question is not whether Ayuso falls; it is when the case gets dismissed. The machinery has a written script and repeats it with every case. As far as anyone knows, nobody has yet found a way to break it. The only novelty would be if this time something actually moved. The reservations are many.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (23 replies).
More summaries
-
Taberna Garibaldi: crumbs without bacon and bravas for 14 euros
Bravas with tomato sauce, migas without bacon, and a 14-euro bill: Pablo Iglesias' review of Taberna Garibaldi highlights the gap between popular discourse and reality...
-
First trans ertzaina leaves Basque police on permanent disability
Otavio de Paula, the first trans ertzaina, secures permanent disability with 55% of his base salary and a €76,000 payout after alleging workplace harassment.
-
Ceuta: official story of discretion clashes with the videos
Verified videos show soldiers beating migrants in Ceuta, Spain, while the Spanish government claims discretion and effectiveness in managing the crisis.
-
Vox courts the Hispanic vote with a viral anthem ahead of November 29
An account aligned with Spain's Vox has released a viral anthem to win over Hispanic voters, setting November 29 as election day. The format has raised doubts about its real impact.
-
Vox councillor sparks debate over Spain's Hispanic Day remarks
Discussion of Vox's stance on Spain's Hispanic Day: analysis of national identity, political strategy and criticism of its role within the current system.
-
Zapatero's indictment sparks lawfare row in Spain
Is the indictment of former Spanish PM Zapatero lawfare or legitimate justice? We look at the political and legal debate over the judiciary's actions in Spain. Read on.