The European Parliament considers saying goodbye to Google as its search engine
The news has made a big splash: the European Parliament has taken the first step toward abandoning Google as its default search engine. A measure that sounds like a gesture of digital sovereignty, but which many analysts greet with the same faith as an election promise.
What exactly has the Parliament approved?
According to Xataka, the institution has started the process of unlinking Google's search engine from its IT systems. The decision, still at an early stage, aims to reduce dependence on US tech giants and foster European alternatives. However, skeptics point out that Brussels has been announcing similar moves for years without citizens noticing any real change.
Skepticism about its real effectiveness
The prevailing analysis among those who closely trinc European digital policy is scathing: this is a political gesture, not a technical one. The widespread suspicion is that whichever search engine ends up being implemented will be nothing more than a front-end still using Google's engine behind the scenes, paying for what used to be free. Or, worse still, that the money earmarked for building an alternative will end up in the hands of the usual suspects: 'politicians' friends and family' and companies like Palantir, while the real alternatives —Qwant, Firefox— remain underfunded.
The real alternatives that already exist
While the bureaucracy moves at a snail's pace, ordinary users have been using Qwant, Ecosia or DuckDuckGo as search engines for years, and Firefox has survived Chrome's onslaught. The gap between what citizens can do on their own and what institutions are willing to implement keeps growing.
An uncertain future of subsidies and promises
The timeline for the European Parliament to actually carry out this change is anyone's guess. Those who have seen other EU tech projects —the autonomous car, the European cloud— expect little to come of it. As some sum it up with irony: 'They couldn't run a lemonade stand, yet they aspire to replace the world's most advanced tech companies through decrees.' The question is whether this step will end up being just another announcement or, for once, Europe proves it can compete without using the services of those who dominate the market.
Related discussions in the forum