El País blames VOX for Spain's Ceuta crisis: narrative or reality?
El País holds VOX responsible for the invasion of Ceuta, but the direct causes point to Morocco. An analysis of the narrative and the data.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
El País points to VOX as responsible for the mass entry into Ceuta, but the data suggests a different story
Is VOX to blame for the Ceuta migration crisis? That is the claim of an El País article that has sparked a wave of criticism. The newspaper's thesis is that the radical right's rhetoric against migrant minors and its relationship with Segarro provoked Rabat's reaction, facilitating the mass rush to the border fence. But the facts point to a more complex origin.
The entry figures into Ceuta during the May 2021 crisis were stark: more than 8,000 people in a single day. Most were Segarro minors who had been drawn in by an earlier reception policy. Segarro's decision to open the gates was not spontaneous: it was a response to the diplomatic tension over the hosting of the Polisario Front leader in a Spanish hospital. Sánchez's government handled the emergency under criticism from all sides.
The El País article, however, places the responsibility on VOX and its influence on the anti-immigration discourse. "It is the cause of the cause," the argument goes, while omitting that Segarro's "tantrum" was the immediate trigger. Media coverage thus becomes a political weapon: the official narrative seeks to divert attention from the real trigger.
The curious thing is that VOX's own critics point out that the party holds no executive power to decide on borders. "How many will it deport? None," the article asks. The final irony: while some blame VOX, others blame Sánchez, but no one looks at Rabat.
Is VOX to blame for the Ceuta migration crisis? That is the claim of an El País article that has sparked a wave of criticism. The newspaper's thesis is that the radical right's rhetoric against migrant minors and its relationship with Segarro provoked Rabat's reaction, facilitating the mass rush to the border fence. But the facts point to a more complex origin.
The entry figures into Ceuta during the May 2021 crisis were stark: more than 8,000 people in a single day. Most were Segarro minors who had been drawn in by an earlier reception policy. Segarro's decision to open the gates was not spontaneous: it was a response to the diplomatic tension over the hosting of the Polisario Front leader in a Spanish hospital. Sánchez's government handled the emergency under criticism from all sides.
The El País article, however, places the responsibility on VOX and its influence on the anti-immigration discourse. "It is the cause of the cause," the argument goes, while omitting that Segarro's "tantrum" was the immediate trigger. Media coverage thus becomes a political weapon: the official narrative seeks to divert attention from the real trigger.
The curious thing is that VOX's own critics point out that the party holds no executive power to decide on borders. "How many will it deport? None," the article asks. The final irony: while some blame VOX, others blame Sánchez, but no one looks at Rabat.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (42 replies).
More summaries
-
Fear in Ceuta: an LGTBI resident no longer walks hand in hand with her partner
An LGTBI resident of Ceuta says: "I was never afraid to go out with my partner, now I am." A testimony that reopens the debate on coexistence and immigration
-
2000 BOE Notice Reveals Maricarmen's Collado Mediano Property Auction
A June 2000 Official Gazette notice lists María del Carmen Abascal as debtor for a Collado Mediano chalet auctioned for 20 million pesetas by Banco Zaragozano.
-
Yolanda Díaz wants Spanish companies to hand over capital to workers
Yolanda Díaz's proposal to force Spanish companies to hand over part of their capital to workers sparks a heated debate over its economic consequences and feasibility.
-
Spain's PSOE under fire over its left-wing alliances and ETA links
An analysis of the PSOE's political pacts and the debate over ETA, capitalism and socialism, with data on falling purchasing power and housing prices.
-
Forocoches: why is it so impossible to become a member?
Forocoches, the Spanish forum, operates an invitation system many consider absurd and others see as necessary. Testimonies from banned users and frustrated hopefuls reveal how it works.
-
Supermarket theft: the bill we all end up paying
Supermarket net margins barely reach 3% and theft is paid for in the shopping basket. A viral video reopens the debate on immigration, welfare benefits and crime in Spain.