Customs charges €41 on a $70 Einstein course: the breakdown doesn't add up

Customs charges €41 on a $70 course and the breakdown doesn't add up

An order of $69.95 — about €56 at the exchange rate — plus $30 shipping from the United States has just landed in Spain with a customs bill of €41. The buyer, who purchased a DVD course on the life and work of Albert Einstein from The Teaching Company, found that the surcharge exceeded 73% of the product's value. The numbers simply don't add up: neither import VAT nor the duty alone justify that figure. The difference, as they made a point of reminding him from the very start, has a name: the handling fee the courier company charges for processing customs clearance.

What you actually pay when importing a product from the US

The confusion between "customs duty" and "total bill" is the first misunderstanding in this case. The taxes the Spanish tax authority (Hacienda) demands on a non-EU import are three: the duty — around 4% for a DVD — import VAT — applied to the value of the product plus shipping — and, in some cases, specific charges depending on the tariff classification. On a €56 package, VAT at 18% and the duty add up to barely ten euros. The rest of the €41 corresponds to the handling fee the courier company charges on behalf of the recipient.

Some argue that this procedure is a legitimate service and that its cost is the price of not doing it yourself. Against that weighs the argument that the procedure can be done in person at Hacienda in a few minutes, at no cost, provided the package arrives via Correos (the Spanish postal service) and not a private company. The difference between the two routes is enormous: self-clearance can cost zero euros in fees, while a courier's commission runs around €30 plus VAT. The full calculation, item by item, yields a difference that surprises anyone seeing it for the first time.

The €22 exemption and the €150 threshold

Spanish regulations establish a VAT exemption for imports whose total value does not exceed €22, according to the 2010 amendment to Article 34 of the VAT Law. Above that figure, the tax applies without exception. There is also a €150 threshold below which no customs duties are charged, although VAT remains payable. That explains why a Kindle bought in the United States paid no duty but did pay VAT, while higher-value orders accumulate both charges.

The problem is not so much the existence of the taxes as the opacity with which they are applied. There is no advance notice to the buyer about the amount they will have to pay at destination, and the foreign company has no obligation to inform about each country's tax rules. Some retailers add a generic warning in the shopping cart, but nobody guarantees the package will be intercepted. The selection of which packages go through customs trinc criteria that those affected themselves describe as a lottery: some have imported products worth over €100 without paying a cent, while others have been charged on a €30 item.

The case of books and differential treatment

Books enjoy a special regime. Under an international agreement, printed paper pays no customs duties, which explains why purchases of used books from the United States arrive without any surcharge. However, VAT still applies when the value exceeds €22, and there the line between what gets through and what doesn't becomes blurry. There are documented cases of book shipments worth €27 including shipping that arrived without a problem, and others that were held.

The distinction between formats also creates unfair comparisons. Blu-Rays do pay duty, as confirmed by a buyer who imported an edition of "Atlas Shrugged" and faced a 50% surcharge on the price. The same content on paper would have passed duty-free. The cultural logic that protects the book does not extend to the disc, even though both convey the same work.

The Canary Islands and the gift that costs more than the gift

The situation worsens in territories with a differentiated tax regime. In the Canary Islands, shipments from the mainland are subject to taxation as imports, meaning a simple family gift sent via Correos can generate a tax bill higher than the value of the gift itself. The complaint is a recurring one: hardly any online retailer ships to the islands without additional surcharges, and the feeling of living in a different country within the same country has become a common refrain.

The case of shipments from the United Kingdom adds another layer of complexity. Although the country is no longer part of the European Union, packages arriving via Correos usually pass without inspection, while those handled by private couriers are systematically intercepted. A Canary Islands buyer recounted that, after receiving a package from Amazon UK with €21 in handling fees and €4 in taxes, she complained to the platform and got the fee refunded. Amazon apologized and acknowledged the error, but could not guarantee that future shipments wouldn't be handled the same way again.

The paperwork you can do yourself

Customs clearance is not intrinsically complicated. When the package arrives via Correos, the recipient gets a notice and can go to Hacienda with the documentation, obtain the tax assessment, pay it at the corresponding bank and return with the receipt to collect the shipment. The whole procedure, according to those who have done it, takes no more than half an hour and requires no technical knowledge. The difference with the private courier route is that the latter charges for a service the individual can perform themselves.

The underlying complaint is not against the tax, but against the fee. Some defend that the system works as it should and that anyone buying from abroad must accept the consequences. Others point out that the asymmetry is obvious: large corporations operate under advantageous tax regimes while the individual buying a course online gets hit with the full bill. The discussion inevitably drifts toward public spending and tax burden, with references to the cost of the administration and the need to fund services. Nobody disputes that taxes exist; what is disputed is whether €41 on a €56 product is a reasonable proportion.

---

How many of those €41 are actually taxes and how many are the courier's fee? In most cases, the answer doesn't arrive until the package is held and the bill is already irreversible.