Catalan workers could earn €1,000 more a year under independence, backers claim

A Catalan worker on an average low salary would earn €1,000 more a year if Catalonia became independent, according to its supporters

The economic promise of Catalan independence boils down to one figure: an extra thousand euros a year for a worker on a below-average wage. The argument rests on the so-called "fiscal deficit": the money Catalonia contributes to the Spanish state which, if retained, would allow – according to this thesis – a tax cut worth 33% of the savings. The other 66% would go to fund the new responsibilities of an independent state: army, embassies, pensions. The calculation, however, has sparked a fierce debate in which the numbers never quite add up.

How the fiscal deficit is split: the key to the calculation

The proposal, detailed by one of the participants in the thread, is based on an unidentified study estimating the total savings from the fiscal deficit. Two thirds of that amount would fund the new state and the remaining third would go towards tax cuts. The tax reduction, applied across all brackets, would miccionan a net income gain of around €1,000 gross a year for the worker on a thousand-euro salary. The figure has become a rallying cry for economic independence supporters, who see secession as a direct route to higher wages.

The risks missing from the calculation: the EU, banks and exports

Critics point out that the calculation ignores key variables. The first: leaving the European Union and NATO. Without the EU umbrella, Catalonia would be outside the single market, with tariffs of 20% on its exports to the rest of the EU according to some estimates. The second: capital flight. The threat of a mass withdrawal of deposits from La Caixa – Catalonia's largest bank – could trigger a financial crisis that would wipe out any fiscal gain. Third: the historical debt. Some opponents of independence put forward a bill of 100 trillion euros for the investments Spain has made over the past 200 years, a figure that on its own would make any savings unviable.

Class versus nation: the underlying debate

Beyond the figures, the thread reveals an ideological rift that goes beyond economics. While some see independence as liberation from interterritorial solidarity – which they call plunder – others denounce independence as a smokescreen for the Catalan bourgeoisie to perpetuate the exploitation of workers. "The sacred union of all classes around the interests of the fatherland," one participant quips, paraphrasing Lenin. The discussion quickly descends into insults and name-calling, but makes one thing clear: the economic debate cannot be separated from the political one.

With the data available, the promise of a thousand euros a year remains just that: a promise. The numbers are full of assumptions that neither independence supporters nor unionists have managed to prove empirically. In a Catalonia that today is still an autonomous community of Spain, the worker on a thousand-euro salary earns exactly the same. And the debate, like independence itself, remains up in the air.

Related debates in the forum

• Are you ready for the false flag attack at the World Cup opening? · 56 replies
• Feijóo pressures Junts and PNV to back a motion solely to trigger elections. · 21 replies
• How could we expel naturalised immigrants? · 291 replies
• The crap surrounding Pedro Sánchez and the PSOE is overflowing · 42 replies