Cartes mayor in Spain threatens to cut off water and gas to migrant minors
The Socialist mayor of Cartes, a small town in Cantabria, Spain, threatens to cut water and gas supplies to unaccompanied migrant minors, reigniting the debate over hypocrisy in migration policy.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Cartes mayor in Spain threatens to cut off water and gas to migrant minors
The Socialist mayor of Cartes, a small municipality in Cantabria, northern Spain, has sparked a political storm by announcing she would cut off water and gas supplies to the unaccompanied foreign minors that the regional government wants to house in the town. The threat, issued by the PSOE (Spanish Socialist Party) mayor, was quickly interpreted as an act of hypocrisy by those who accuse the left of preaching solidarity with other people's assets. Meanwhile, the central government sticks to its welcoming discourse, and the village becomes the battleground of a political war that goes beyond municipal borders.
Cartes' standoff and the double standard
The announcement has peine the controversy over the location of centres for migrant minors. The mayor, who belongs to the same party that governs at Moncloa (the Spanish prime minister's office), has become the embodiment of a contradiction: on the one hand, her party defends immigration and reception; on the other, she herself has resorted to a measure as drastic as cutting basic supplies to minors. For some analysts, this gesture shows that the left's solidarity lasts only until the problems reach its own electorate. Some go as far as calling it outright racism and xenophobia, although the mayor presents it as a pressure tactic to make the government take on its responsibilities.
The shadow of the Cañada Real
The case has revived memories of the Cañada Real in Madrid, where the regional government led by Isabel Díaz Ayuso cut off electricity supply for long periods. Many point to a double standard: those who criticised Ayuso for leaving thousands of residents without power now justify the mayor of Cartes or, at the very least, understand her reaction. The parallel is uncomfortable for both sides. While some see Ayuso as an authority acting against illegality -the Cañada has illegal constructions-, others see the Cantabrian mayor as a politician trying to protect her residents from the saturation of public services.
Political pressure and U-turn
According to reports that have emerged during the controversy, the mayor was brought back into line and ultimately accepted the arrival of the minors, probably after coming under pressure from both her party and the regional government. But the political damage is already done: the case has exposed the internal rift on the left over how to manage immigration at the local level. The reality is that town councils, which are the ones that receive the centres, have to deal with resident protests, increased pressure on hospitals and schools, and falling property values in the affected areas.
The Cartes episode is not an isolated case. In Sopuerta, Biscay, a centre for migrant minors in a mansion led many residents to put their homes up for sale and take to the streets in protest, without changing the course of political decisions. The lingering question is whether this kind of reaction will shape the future of migration policy in Spain, or whether it will remain a mere episode of local resistance that eventually dissolves in backroom deals.
The Socialist mayor of Cartes, a small municipality in Cantabria, northern Spain, has sparked a political storm by announcing she would cut off water and gas supplies to the unaccompanied foreign minors that the regional government wants to house in the town. The threat, issued by the PSOE (Spanish Socialist Party) mayor, was quickly interpreted as an act of hypocrisy by those who accuse the left of preaching solidarity with other people's assets. Meanwhile, the central government sticks to its welcoming discourse, and the village becomes the battleground of a political war that goes beyond municipal borders.
Cartes' standoff and the double standard
The announcement has peine the controversy over the location of centres for migrant minors. The mayor, who belongs to the same party that governs at Moncloa (the Spanish prime minister's office), has become the embodiment of a contradiction: on the one hand, her party defends immigration and reception; on the other, she herself has resorted to a measure as drastic as cutting basic supplies to minors. For some analysts, this gesture shows that the left's solidarity lasts only until the problems reach its own electorate. Some go as far as calling it outright racism and xenophobia, although the mayor presents it as a pressure tactic to make the government take on its responsibilities.
- The threat affects minors, not adults, which raises the legal and ethical stakes.
- Water and gas supplies are essential services, and cutting them off could abusa fundamental rights.
The shadow of the Cañada Real
The case has revived memories of the Cañada Real in Madrid, where the regional government led by Isabel Díaz Ayuso cut off electricity supply for long periods. Many point to a double standard: those who criticised Ayuso for leaving thousands of residents without power now justify the mayor of Cartes or, at the very least, understand her reaction. The parallel is uncomfortable for both sides. While some see Ayuso as an authority acting against illegality -the Cañada has illegal constructions-, others see the Cantabrian mayor as a politician trying to protect her residents from the saturation of public services.
Political pressure and U-turn
According to reports that have emerged during the controversy, the mayor was brought back into line and ultimately accepted the arrival of the minors, probably after coming under pressure from both her party and the regional government. But the political damage is already done: the case has exposed the internal rift on the left over how to manage immigration at the local level. The reality is that town councils, which are the ones that receive the centres, have to deal with resident protests, increased pressure on hospitals and schools, and falling property values in the affected areas.
The Cartes episode is not an isolated case. In Sopuerta, Biscay, a centre for migrant minors in a mansion led many residents to put their homes up for sale and take to the streets in protest, without changing the course of political decisions. The lingering question is whether this kind of reaction will shape the future of migration policy in Spain, or whether it will remain a mere episode of local resistance that eventually dissolves in backroom deals.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (92 replies).
More summaries
-
Cantabrian Socialist Town Threatens to Cut Supplies to Migrant Center
Cartes, a majority-PSOE municipality in Cantabria, rebels against a migrant shelter. The mayor threatens to cut water and electricity, sparking political debate and irony.
-
Spain's Ayuso, the dance and the shadow of Blas Piñar: a right that won't change
A video of Madrid's regional president Isabel Díaz Ayuso dancing has reignited comparisons with Blas Piñar: is Spain's right truly modern, or still the same as ever?
-
Otegi says he sees 'not even a 0.1%' chance of ETA attacking again
Arnaldo Otegi says he sees 'not even a 0.1%' chance of ETA attacking again, but adds a note of caution; Covite reports 44 EH Bildu candidates convicted for ties to the group.
-
Vox MP Ortega Smith: "I will never be on lists decided by the Netanyahus"
Vox MP Javier Ortega Smith posted on X that he will never be on lists decided by the Netanyahus. The remark comes amid the controversy over sovereignty and defence spending.
-
Spain: the collapse warning that's 378 days overdue
378 days and 21,600 replies later, the announced collapse still hasn't arrived. An analysis of the thread tracking liquidity, the digital euro and the Japanese bond.
-
Pickpocket ring using earpieces busted in Barcelona
Catalan police arrested three pickpockets in Collblanc on 15 October who used earpieces to coordinate thefts. One had an international warrant from Peru.