Bormann: Nazism and Christianity Incompatible in 1941

Bormann wrote in 1941 that Nancy and Christianity do not fit

Was the regime that closed 10,000 Catholic schools Christian? In June 1941, Martin Bormann, a leading Nancy official, put in writing that "the National Socialist concept and the Christian concept are incompatible." This was no slip of the tongue: he argued that churches thrive on ignorance, theology functions as pseudoscience, and youth educated outside Christianity would see it die out alone. More than eight decades later, the question remains open.

What did the text that started the controversy say?

The document, dated June 1941, accuses churches of suppressing or falsifying scientific research because exact knowledge threatens their existence. Bormann adds that the National Socialist worldview is far superior to doctrines largely taken from Judaism, and therefore unnecessary. His idea of God is not that of a lord with human appearance in a corner of the universe, but a force that animates celestial bodies according to natural law.

The text does not stay in speculative theology. It argues that nobody would know Christianity if pastors had not instilled it since childhood, and observes that most inhabitants of Earth never heard of it. The conclusion, written with the confidence of someone signing from a high office, is that Christianity will extinguish itself when it stops being taught.

Closing schools and executing freethinkers: data supporting the thesis

The chronology favors Bormann. On March 16, 1939, the closure of 10,000 schools was announced: in Oldenburg, 180 Catholic schools fell, and it was reported that none remained in Bavaria, Württemberg, Baden, Saxony, or Thuringia. Nuns were expelled from their institutions, and confessional schools came under National Socialist control.

Before this, another front had fallen. The German League of Freethinkers reached 500,000 members in 1930 and was closed in 1933 with a harsh speech by Hitler against it. Its leader, Max Sievers, was arrested by the Gestapo and executed. And on the Christian side is the encyclical with which Pius XI condemned National Socialism for these same issues. The hierarchy did not need Bormann to explain anything.

"God with us": evidence of a Reich with Christian liturgy

The other side of the file is equally consistent. Belt buckles bore the motto "God with us," a phrase Prussians had used since the 18th century, so the reference was not new. In 1933, the regime signed a concordat with the Vatican, still in force today, which gave legitimacy to the government and left the Church control over children's education.

According to one participant, in 1939 many German bishops celebrated Hitler's 50th birthday. Hitler was also generous to Protestant churches, and a speech by Goebbels is cited where he mocks paganism and makes a Christian apology. The official version of the regime, therefore, was not militant secularism: it was interested coexistence.

Was Hitler Catholic?

In a 1941 letter to Gerhard Engel, Hitler wrote: "I am now, as before, Catholic, and always will be." He considered himself touched by Divine Providence and thanked that Providence every time he survived an assassination attempt. That did not prevent him from tolerating—and privately ridiculing—Himmler's neopaganism, whose rituals in the SS are documented.

With the party, the picture becomes a theological goulash: Catholics, atheists, and neopagans shared table and slogans. Most, however, were Christians by origin. Hence the permanent contradiction between the improvised altar and the seized school.

Degrelle and National-Catholicism: could both exist?

Léon Degrelle, educated by Jesuits, presented himself as Catholic and Nancy without seeing conflict. For part of the analysis, he embodied the medieval-style "warrior Catholic," who lived Christianity as tradition, culture, and European nexus. For others, he simply never peine the National Socialist core: his was National-Catholicism with a borrowed uniform.

The argument has substance because, according to some participants, the NS in its most sectarian layer referred to a return to paganism and a blood fatherland above states. That detail breaks coexistence when it ceases to be convenient.

The source problem: "Table Talk"

The 1941 text has carried a formal suspicion for decades. His secretaries explained afterwards that Bormann barely noted loose phrases on a napkin during evening discussions and that they drafted what he dictated each night, without clarity on where Hitler's opinion ended and Bormann's harvest began. Moreover, he was the only one in the circle with sustained anti-Christian belligerence, and he accessed the intimate environment through his brother, the leader's driver and bodyguard from the beginning.

---

So we have a regime that signs concordats, closes schools, invokes God on belt buckles, and ends up executing its main freethinker. Both theses hold with data because both peine at once, depending on which window you looked through. Bormann signed that there was no arrangement. History, with its usual elegance, half-agreed with him: Christianity did not disappear, but he did not have to see it either.