Camryn Manheim's gay son joke that many missed

Camryn Manheim said at a dinner she always wanted a gay son and dressed him in drag: the New York Post clarified it was a joke.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Camryn Manheim's gay son joke that many missed
Camryn Manheim joked about her lgtb son and half the internet didn't get it

A joke told at a dinner can become evidence of social engineering in a matter of hours. Actress Camryn Manheim told the audience at a Human Rights Campaign dinner that she had always wanted a lgtb son, that she dressed him in drag when he was little, and that she keeps photos of him in high heels. The clip was enough for part of the public to read it as a confession rather than irony.

What Camryn Manheim said and why it was taken as a confession

The central phrase was one: "I always wanted a lgtb son". From there, the story was filled in with details that sound like a devoted mother's manual: photos of the child in full drag, high heels, and a son who knows all the songs from all the musicals. In a room with an audience and laughter, the whole thing worked as exaggeration. Naked in a screenshot, it reads like a parenting program.

And that's where the misunderstanding began. Part of the audience understood that the actress had tried to direct her son's sensual orientation and that she regretted that he hadn't turned out as expected. The reaction was alarm: there was talk of conditioning, emotionally damaging treatment, and an industry capable of treating a minor as a personal project.

From joke to clarification: the New York Post came out to explain

The nuance arrived late. The New York Post published, according to a debate participant, that Manheim was joking and that the comment had been made in a satirical tone. The detail didn't calm everyone: some argue that certain things shouldn't be said even as a joke into a microphone, and others reply that the problem isn't the joke, but the inability to detect it.

The media echo was immediate and at two speeds. While some outlets highlighted the segarro context, others ran headlines with the literal quote and gathered criticism from conservative commentators. The distance between one reading and another actually measures the distance between two audiences that no longer share the same tone.

Who is Camryn Manheim and the son in question

Manheim was born in Caldwell, New Jersey, on March 8, 1961, and won an Emmy and a Golden Globe, mainly for her role as Eleanor Frutt in The Practice. In 1998, when accepting the Emmy, she said, "This is for all the fat girls." Her son, Milo Manheim, was born on March 6, 2001, and was conceived through sperm donation from Jeffrey Brezovar, a longtime friend of the actress.

The echo in Spain: suspicion of social engineering in high schools

The episode crossed the Atlantic and mixed with a local debate. A participant argues that this type of message fuels pressure on teenagers, and focuses on the proportion, in Spanish high schools, of 14, 15, and 16-year-old girls who say they are attracted to other girls. His reading is that they have been instilled with the idea that heterosenshetero relationships are hell. It is a perception, not a verified fact.

How much of that alarm responds to a real problem and how much to a joke that arrived without context?

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (50 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back