Abandoned Asturian Palaces: The Cost of Preserving Indian Mansions
Why are Asturian Indian mansions abandoned despite million-euro renovation costs? Explore the legacy of wealth, family disputes, and regional decline.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The drama of Asturian Indian mansions: splendor in ruins
In Asturias, palaces built with American fortunes rot in remote villages, while Cantabria has barely any abandoned ones. Videos of two of these mansions show collapsed roofs, dampness, and even livestock wandering through salons that once hosted parties. The paradox is not a lack of interest, but the demographics and economy of a region emptying out at a forced pace.
The cost of pomp: million-euro renovations for inherited whims
The figures speak: a full renovation respecting the original aesthetic exceeds one million euros, while the purchase price hovers around 300,000–500,000 euros. On top of that comes a sky-high property tax (IBI) and continuous special assessments. Heirs, sometimes scattered among dozens of family branches with modest economies, prefer not to face the bottomless pit. As one source in the analysis summarizes: 'Too big for a vacation home, too small for a hotel.' The location doesn't help either: many stand by the N-634 highway or the narrow-gauge train, 20 km from the sea, far from trendy tourist spots like Llanes or Ribadesella.
The breeding ground: a territory in demographic and economic decline
Asturias leads Spain in suicide rates, and its birth rate hits rock bottom with 0.3 children per Asturian woman. The heavy industry installed by Franco –steelworks, mines, shipyards– was dismantled through restructuring and the ruling left. The result: a region many call 'the Detroit of the northern Spanish,' where without a job at Arcelor or a civil service post, there is barely any future. Youth emigrate to the UK to fry chicken in fast-food chains (LFCs), and those who remain can hardly afford to maintain a 19th-century palace. Endemic left-wing politics, according to one current of opinion, has condemned Asturias to ruin, but the causes run deeper: a culture of subsidies, alcoholism inherited from mining, and a lack of generational turnover.
The dilemma of the Indianos: rentiers vs. investors
Contrary to the myth of the speculative Indiano, many of these returned emigrants invested in infrastructure (roads, schools) and created companies like Galerías Preciados or El Corte Inglés in Asturias. But most built these mansions out of sentimentalism, to die in their village and rub it in the neighbors' faces. Once that purpose is fulfilled, there is no practical use. The few that are sold are bought by vulture funds at demolition prices, as has already peine with other properties across Spain.
The question hanging in the air is whether these palaces, silent witnesses to an era of splendor, will ultimately be destroyed by the pickaxe or if some remote-income millennial will dare to restore them to life. For now, the only movement comes from YouTubers rediscovering them.
Related forum debates
In Asturias, palaces built with American fortunes rot in remote villages, while Cantabria has barely any abandoned ones. Videos of two of these mansions show collapsed roofs, dampness, and even livestock wandering through salons that once hosted parties. The paradox is not a lack of interest, but the demographics and economy of a region emptying out at a forced pace.
The cost of pomp: million-euro renovations for inherited whims
The figures speak: a full renovation respecting the original aesthetic exceeds one million euros, while the purchase price hovers around 300,000–500,000 euros. On top of that comes a sky-high property tax (IBI) and continuous special assessments. Heirs, sometimes scattered among dozens of family branches with modest economies, prefer not to face the bottomless pit. As one source in the analysis summarizes: 'Too big for a vacation home, too small for a hotel.' The location doesn't help either: many stand by the N-634 highway or the narrow-gauge train, 20 km from the sea, far from trendy tourist spots like Llanes or Ribadesella.
The breeding ground: a territory in demographic and economic decline
Asturias leads Spain in suicide rates, and its birth rate hits rock bottom with 0.3 children per Asturian woman. The heavy industry installed by Franco –steelworks, mines, shipyards– was dismantled through restructuring and the ruling left. The result: a region many call 'the Detroit of the northern Spanish,' where without a job at Arcelor or a civil service post, there is barely any future. Youth emigrate to the UK to fry chicken in fast-food chains (LFCs), and those who remain can hardly afford to maintain a 19th-century palace. Endemic left-wing politics, according to one current of opinion, has condemned Asturias to ruin, but the causes run deeper: a culture of subsidies, alcoholism inherited from mining, and a lack of generational turnover.
The dilemma of the Indianos: rentiers vs. investors
Contrary to the myth of the speculative Indiano, many of these returned emigrants invested in infrastructure (roads, schools) and created companies like Galerías Preciados or El Corte Inglés in Asturias. But most built these mansions out of sentimentalism, to die in their village and rub it in the neighbors' faces. Once that purpose is fulfilled, there is no practical use. The few that are sold are bought by vulture funds at demolition prices, as has already peine with other properties across Spain.
The question hanging in the air is whether these palaces, silent witnesses to an era of splendor, will ultimately be destroyed by the pickaxe or if some remote-income millennial will dare to restore them to life. For now, the only movement comes from YouTubers rediscovering them.
Related forum debates
- El Jueves Magazine ordered to pay 6,000 euros to Christian Lawyers · 13 replies
- Disgusting advertising in New York · 55 replies
- Members of the Spanish Flotilla arriving at Bilbao airport · 138 replies
- UCO enters Ferraz, the PSOE headquarters · 16 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (267 replies).
More summaries
-
PSOE loses support in Asturias mining basins: Marlaska booed in Mieres as Barbón faces sharp criticism.
Tension in Asturias: a resident confronts Adrián Barbón, while booing directed at Marlaska follows an event. Local indignation is heard loud and clear.
-
Extortioner dies in Valencia after being beaten for stopping fleeing motorcyclists
A local extortionist, known as a 'gorilla', died in Valencia after being beaten by motorcyclists while trying to stop those who fled a hit-and-run accident.
-
UK bars face rising costs while resisting price hikes
Operating costs surge 15-20% while prices remain frozen, creating a survival dilemma for small hospitality businesses in the UK.
-
Spain April 28 blackout: Technical failure or energy grid collapse?
Analysis of Spain's April 28 blackout reveals experts debating whether the cause was renewable overproduction or centralized power grid vulnerability.
-
Rajoy’s comments on French national team spark diplomatic row with Élysée
France deems Rajoy’s remarks on its squad unacceptable. The former prime minister reopens debates on identity and immigration while Sánchez remains silent.
-
Valencian wins school language poll by narrow margin in Spain
Valencian edges out Spanish in a school language consultation, with 50.53% support, 58.6% turnout, and results split along regional lines.