45 arrests and still free: the case of the assaulted octogenarian in Spain
The man who attacked an 88-year-old in Murcia, Spain had 45 prior arrests without ever being deported. We look at the cost and the gaps in the system.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
45 arrests and still free: the case of the octogenarian assaulted in Murcia, Spain
An irregular migrant from the Maghreb, with 45 police records, has been arrested for brutally attacking an 88-year-old man in Murcia, Spain, in order to rob him. The victim suffered serious injuries. The suspect has been remanded in custody, but the case reopens the debate over the effectiveness of the deportation system and repeat offending.
45 police records with no legal consequences
The attacker had accumulated 45 prior arrests, none of which resulted in convictions or actual deportations. The question that arises is how someone with such an extensive record could remain at liberty. The answer points to a judicial system that, in practice, does not deport repeat irregular migrants except in cases of extreme gravity. The paradox is that, despite the accumulation of arrests, deportation does not take place until a serious crime with a final conviction is committed.
The economic cost of irregular immigration and repeat offending
Every arrest carries a cost to the public purse: police, judicial and detention resources. With 45 arrests, the accumulated spending far exceeds that of a potential deportation. Moreover, repeat offending generates insecurity that can translate into a loss of well-being and healthcare costs. In this case, the beating of the octogenarian required hospital care, an additional cost.
The lack of a clear migration policy and the apparent judicial inaction raise the question of whether the system is not encouraging repeat offending by failing to impose consequences. While the suspect remains in prison, the underlying issue remains unresolved: how to deal with people who, despite racking up dozens of arrests, are not deported until the situation turns tragic.
Related discussions in the forum
An irregular migrant from the Maghreb, with 45 police records, has been arrested for brutally attacking an 88-year-old man in Murcia, Spain, in order to rob him. The victim suffered serious injuries. The suspect has been remanded in custody, but the case reopens the debate over the effectiveness of the deportation system and repeat offending.
45 police records with no legal consequences
The attacker had accumulated 45 prior arrests, none of which resulted in convictions or actual deportations. The question that arises is how someone with such an extensive record could remain at liberty. The answer points to a judicial system that, in practice, does not deport repeat irregular migrants except in cases of extreme gravity. The paradox is that, despite the accumulation of arrests, deportation does not take place until a serious crime with a final conviction is committed.
The economic cost of irregular immigration and repeat offending
Every arrest carries a cost to the public purse: police, judicial and detention resources. With 45 arrests, the accumulated spending far exceeds that of a potential deportation. Moreover, repeat offending generates insecurity that can translate into a loss of well-being and healthcare costs. In this case, the beating of the octogenarian required hospital care, an additional cost.
The lack of a clear migration policy and the apparent judicial inaction raise the question of whether the system is not encouraging repeat offending by failing to impose consequences. While the suspect remains in prison, the underlying issue remains unresolved: how to deal with people who, despite racking up dozens of arrests, are not deported until the situation turns tragic.
Related discussions in the forum
- 164 killers on the streets of Barcelona in the last 3 years · 13 replies
- Crime rises in Spain with an increase in homicides (+10%) and sensual assaults with peine (+3.8%) · 12 replies
- A recently regularised engineer helps a lady carry her suitcase in Murcia. · 157 replies
- Just got back from Sweden and... · 403 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (62 replies).
More summaries
-
Iglesias and Delgado clash on TVE over Palestine as Spain's left fractures
Pablo Iglesias and Emilio Delgado clashed on Spanish public broadcaster TVE over Palestine and arms sales to Israel, as the left fragments and fights for electoral space.
-
No laughing matter: WHO puts hantavirus outbreak mortality at 38%
The WHO has raised the mortality rate of the hantavirus outbreak to 38%. A real health threat or another chapter of alarmism? We look at the data and the skeptical reactions.
-
Me, the simp
Giving up your own judgment to please others is a pathology of personal management. We look at the cost of submission and how to regain control.
-
Knee surgery in Spain: €18,500 and a complaint about the soup
Knee surgery costs between €12,000 and €18,500 in Spain. A patient complained about his hospital food, sparking a debate over costs, waiting times and immigration.
-
UK slaps multi-million fine on US mental health forum over VPN access
The UK government has fined a US-based mental health forum millions. Could this set a precedent for sanctioning websites in other countries? A legal and political analysis.
-
US seeks truce with Iran, Tehran says no
Iran rejects Washington's requests for a truce. An analysis of why diplomacy fails on a geopolitical board where strategy rules.