Young man faces two years in prison for grinding with a woman without her consent
A 23-year-old man faces two years in prison for grinding without consent at a nightclub in Mislata, Spain. Prosecutors argue no intimate touching is needed.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Two years in prison for grinding without consent: the new sarracena order?
A 23-year-old man faces two years in prison for dancing "perreo" (grinding) with a woman at a nightclub in Mislata, Spain, without her explicit consent. Prosecutors argue that no touching of intimate areas is needed for it to count as sensual assault. The incident, which took place on 19 April last year at 5:38 a.m., has peine the debate over the limits of consent and the drift towards punitive justice.
Dancing as a crime
The prosecution is seeking two years in prison, three years of supervised release, a restraining order keeping him at least 500 metres away from the complainant, and €1,000 in compensation. The complainant, a Venezuelan national, took four days to file the report. The prosecutor argues that grinding without consent fits the legal definition of sensual assault, even without contact with intimate areas. An interpretation that leaves to subjectivity what used to be settled with a slap or a warning.
Reactions ranging from outrage to satire
The case has been met with scepticism: ironic comments abound about the need for "written informed consent" before dancing, along with comparisons to puritan 17th-century England, which did not punish so harshly. Others point to a possible interest in obtaining residency papers or financial compensation. The shadow of opportunism hangs over the official account.
Where does flirting end and crime begin?
The question nobody answers is how a lack of consent can be proven in a gesture as ambiguous as dancing. The justice system is drifting towards a puritanism in which any unprompted physical contact can be incivil. Meanwhile, the young man awaits trial under the real threat of prison. And the debate remains open.
Related discussions in the forum
A 23-year-old man faces two years in prison for dancing "perreo" (grinding) with a woman at a nightclub in Mislata, Spain, without her explicit consent. Prosecutors argue that no touching of intimate areas is needed for it to count as sensual assault. The incident, which took place on 19 April last year at 5:38 a.m., has peine the debate over the limits of consent and the drift towards punitive justice.
Dancing as a crime
The prosecution is seeking two years in prison, three years of supervised release, a restraining order keeping him at least 500 metres away from the complainant, and €1,000 in compensation. The complainant, a Venezuelan national, took four days to file the report. The prosecutor argues that grinding without consent fits the legal definition of sensual assault, even without contact with intimate areas. An interpretation that leaves to subjectivity what used to be settled with a slap or a warning.
Reactions ranging from outrage to satire
The case has been met with scepticism: ironic comments abound about the need for "written informed consent" before dancing, along with comparisons to puritan 17th-century England, which did not punish so harshly. Others point to a possible interest in obtaining residency papers or financial compensation. The shadow of opportunism hangs over the official account.
Where does flirting end and crime begin?
The question nobody answers is how a lack of consent can be proven in a gesture as ambiguous as dancing. The justice system is drifting towards a puritanism in which any unprompted physical contact can be incivil. Meanwhile, the young man awaits trial under the real threat of prison. And the debate remains open.
Related discussions in the forum
- Norwegian abandoned by his parents as a child in India. Your thoughts. · 19 replies
- Compilation of POGRE receiving KARMA · 3579 replies
- The value of the jewellery seized from Zapatero exceeds €90 million. Breakdown inside. · 97 replies
- Rafa Nadal's state is very worrying, he looks completely gaunt. · 67 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (33 replies).
More summaries
-
Black widow of Patraix returns to Picassent prison as son turns three
Spain's prison service moves Maje from the Fontcalent mothers' unit in Alicante back to Picassent, Valencia, after her son turned three and goes into his grandmother's custody
-
14-year sentence for simultaneous rape in Bilbao: doubts over evidence
The Biscay court sentences two young men to 14 years for simultaneous rape. Gonorrhoea evidence raises doubts: she positive, they negative. Analysis...
-
Spain's Crisis: Real Estate, Politics, and Market Volatility Explained
An analysis of Spain's real estate, economic, and political bubbles, featuring key data from the Ibex 35 and official bank valuations.
-
Spain's Renfe lets pets sit next to their owners on trains
Spanish rail operator Renfe now allows dogs and cats to occupy the seat next to their owners. The move divides travellers between those who see it as a family-friendly step and those who…
-
Sexual attractiveness by age: the gap between men and women
A viral chart shows how sexual attractiveness varies by sex and age: women in free fall after 30, men holding steady until 50. Controversy and debate follow.
-
Spain makes global headlines over migration, then turns on itself
Five million more residents in eight years: the crisis that has put Spain in the world spotlight and reignited a domestic blame game.