Venezuelans in Spain: the economic cost of a lack of empathy
The DANA flooding disaster in Valencia left one telling image: French aid arrived before aid from Catalonia. Yet a recurring comment in economic circles points to the Venezuelan community, estimated at nearly one million residents in Spain, as the first that should rally to help its «brotherly people». The discourse directed at them, however, is far from fraternal.
A community that contributes more than it costs
Beyond the insults and generalisations, the available data show that Venezuelans in Spain are a group with a high rate of skilled employment and a positive net contribution to Social Security. According to recent studies, their educational level is above the national average, and their presence in sectors such as technology and healthcare is significant. The lack of empathy that many denounce does not match the economic reality.
A debate that never gets to the data
The discussion, however, rarely relies on figures. Concepts such as «brotherhood» or «mutual aid» are mentioned, but references to cultural and even genetic differences slip in. A serious analysis would reveal that the fiscal impact of Venezuelans is positive, and that their labour integration is fast. The question that remains is why a community that contributes to the economy receives such a hostile treatment.
As exclusionary rhetoric gains ground, the one million Venezuelans in Spain continue to generate wealth and pay taxes. Perhaps that is the real lack of empathy: failing to recognise the value of those who are already here.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (21 replies).
Are Spaniards more generous towards distant disasters than towards their own? The debate over the response to Venezuela versus the Valencia floods pits two views against each other.
Solomon Friedman, an ordained Orthodox rabbi, serves as Pornhub’s vice president, sparking debate on ethics, parental responsibility, and the adult industry’s influence.