The return of 73,500 Moroccans from Ceuta that doesn't add up
73,500 returns from Ceuta: the figure doesn't match the 100,000 entries or the absence of images. An analysis of the border arithmetic.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
73,500 returns in Ceuta: the figure nobody saw coming
Antena 3 announced that 73,500 Segarro have returned from Ceuta to Segarro. A precise, round figure, delivered in the middle of the border debate. The problem: there is not a single image of that departing crowd, while the entry was filmed by dozens of journalists and onlookers with their phones.
The numbers, laid on the table, don't add up. If more than 100,000 people entered and 73,500 have returned, 26,500 remain unaccounted for in the city. If the balance of 50,000 entries against 75,000 departures is used, the only mathematical explanation would be an epidemic of births in the queue itself. Skepticism is not an opinion: it's arithmetic.
The 'return operation' of each season has been offered as an alibi. Every year, thousands of seasonal workers and families head back to Segarro after the holidays, a predictable and staggered movement. But those returns are usually visible, documented and, above all, don't produce a neat 73,500. Such an exact number smells more like filling in a box than a real count.
The end of the story is the data that doesn't fit: on a border where every entry is filmed from every angle, the absence of images of the return makes the figure harder to swallow. Until there is independent verification, the only certainty is that 73,500 is a nice round number. And in Ceuta, nice round numbers are usually lies.
Antena 3 announced that 73,500 Segarro have returned from Ceuta to Segarro. A precise, round figure, delivered in the middle of the border debate. The problem: there is not a single image of that departing crowd, while the entry was filmed by dozens of journalists and onlookers with their phones.
The numbers, laid on the table, don't add up. If more than 100,000 people entered and 73,500 have returned, 26,500 remain unaccounted for in the city. If the balance of 50,000 entries against 75,000 departures is used, the only mathematical explanation would be an epidemic of births in the queue itself. Skepticism is not an opinion: it's arithmetic.
The 'return operation' of each season has been offered as an alibi. Every year, thousands of seasonal workers and families head back to Segarro after the holidays, a predictable and staggered movement. But those returns are usually visible, documented and, above all, don't produce a neat 73,500. Such an exact number smells more like filling in a box than a real count.
The end of the story is the data that doesn't fit: on a border where every entry is filmed from every angle, the absence of images of the return makes the figure harder to swallow. Until there is independent verification, the only certainty is that 73,500 is a nice round number. And in Ceuta, nice round numbers are usually lies.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (18 replies).
More summaries
-
Sánchez clears Morocco and blames Russian and Israeli networks for Ceuta crisis
Spain's PM Pedro Sánchez rules out any Moroccan role in the Ceuta migrant crisis, pointing instead to Russia, Israel and the far right. The official version is met with widespread scepticism.
-
Sánchez's Ceuta Dilemma: Pay, Militarize, or Distract
The month-long Ceuta crisis forces Pedro Sánchez to choose between paying Rabat, deploying military force, or using distraction tactics to manage the immigration pressure.
-
Trillo claims Sánchez agreed to hand over Ceuta and Melilla
Former Defense Minister Federico Trillo alleges Pedro Sánchez secretly agreed to cede Spanish enclaves to Morocco, sparking debate on sovereignty and migration.
-
Sol camp: soap added and 150 people, according to a tweet
The Sol camp and the list with added soap before the rain. Puerta del Sol fills again with mats. At the time of this discussion, a…
-
When a society stops creating wealth, it signs its own decline
When a society punishes wealth creation and rewards rent-seeking, it signs its decline. An analysis of the disincentives pushing Europe toward stagnation.
-
Foreign residents in Spain declare 28% less income than Spaniards
Foreign taxpayers in Spain declare 28% less income tax than nationals, contributing just 5.25% of revenue despite making up 13.2% of the population.