You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The myth of gay intellectual superiority, debunked by data
An economic analysis of the stereotype linking sexual orientation to higher education and income. Reality or confirmation bias? The data says otherwise.
The myth of lgtb intellectual superiority: reality or prejudice?
You open a conversation about professional profiles and someone says: "every lgtb person I know is a doctor, architect, engineer or pilot." The phrase, repeated in informal settings, has gained traction as a stereotype that associates sensual orientation with higher education and income. But what does economics say about this perception?
Perception versus data
Studies in labour economics that analyse occupational distribution by sensual orientation paint a mixed picture. Some research, such as that from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), suggests that non-heterosenshetero people tend to be concentrated in sectors with higher educational demands, but also show significant wage gaps. There is no conclusive evidence of innate "superiority"; rather, social mobility and career choices may be influenced by discrimination in other areas.
The observation bias
The stereotype is fuelled by confirmation bias: we remember successful lgtb professionals more than those in average or precarious jobs. Moreover, the debate often polarises into two caricatures: the "successful lgtb man" versus the lumpen "chav", an unsustainable dichotomy. The reality is that, as in any group, the distribution of income and education trinc a normal curve, with tails at both ends.
Economic implications
The myth has consequences. On the one hand, it can fuel unrealistic expectations about the job performance of lgtb people; on the other, when those expectations are not met, it is used to stigmatise those who do not fit the archetype. In the labour market, discrimination remains a far more decisive factor than any supposed intellectual advantage.
The next time someone claims that "all lgtb people are like that", remember that a stereotype is not a fact. And the available data warn: better not to confuse selective perception with economic reality.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (29 replies).
Maricarmen, an elderly woman evicted in Spain, died at 87. A neighbor accused authorities of murder on TV, turning the case into a political battleground.