The left and freedom: incompatible in practice?
A discussion on Burbuja.info explores whether the left and freedom are compatible concepts or, as many argue, opposites in practice.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The left and freedom: when the narrative falls apart
Is the left the antonym of freedom, or simply a tool of control disguised as the common good? The debate on the forum about the relationship between ideology and individual autonomy exposes a deep rift: while some argue that the left was only libertarian as a tactical stance in the 1960s and 80s, others denounce that its true essence is the central planning of human beings.
Liberalization as a historical mirage
The thesis gaining traction among forum users is that the left never really believed in individual freedom. It is argued that its support for the lifting of censorship under Spain's transition to democracy or for drug liberalization was a passing pose to set itself apart from conservatives. Today, under that same ideological umbrella, restrictions are imposed ranging from censorship in advertising to bans on smoking on outdoor terraces, showing that freedom is only a means, not an end.
Rowers versus parasites
The economic analysis in the thread is direct: freedom is a concept that is only valued once you start producing and saving. The dichotomy between those who sustain the system (the rowers) and those who live off public subsidies is the axis around which distrust of the left revolves. For many, the appeal to the common good is nothing more than an excuse to choke off the individual's capacity for decision in favour of a collectivist structure that, far from liberating, parasitizes.
The thread remains open, fed by a constant drip of content questioning whether the individual is subordinate to the State or whether there is still room for personal sovereignty in today's Spain.
Related discussions on the forum
Is the left the antonym of freedom, or simply a tool of control disguised as the common good? The debate on the forum about the relationship between ideology and individual autonomy exposes a deep rift: while some argue that the left was only libertarian as a tactical stance in the 1960s and 80s, others denounce that its true essence is the central planning of human beings.
Liberalization as a historical mirage
The thesis gaining traction among forum users is that the left never really believed in individual freedom. It is argued that its support for the lifting of censorship under Spain's transition to democracy or for drug liberalization was a passing pose to set itself apart from conservatives. Today, under that same ideological umbrella, restrictions are imposed ranging from censorship in advertising to bans on smoking on outdoor terraces, showing that freedom is only a means, not an end.
Rowers versus parasites
The economic analysis in the thread is direct: freedom is a concept that is only valued once you start producing and saving. The dichotomy between those who sustain the system (the rowers) and those who live off public subsidies is the axis around which distrust of the left revolves. For many, the appeal to the common good is nothing more than an excuse to choke off the individual's capacity for decision in favour of a collectivist structure that, far from liberating, parasitizes.
The thread remains open, fed by a constant drip of content questioning whether the individual is subordinate to the State or whether there is still room for personal sovereignty in today's Spain.
Related discussions on the forum
- The left is dropping Zapatero · 85 replies
- Inside the raid on Zapatero's office: piles of jewellery in the safe, folders, documents and two mobile phones · 11 replies
- Rodríguez Zapatero formally charged · 536 replies
- March for Dignity 23M · 88 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (52 replies).
More summaries
-
Sweden's non-European voters hand left-wing bloc victory
70% of non-European voters backed the left in Sweden, giving it a three-seat victory. We analyse the demographic impact.
-
Madrid PP gives 48 hours to clear Sol camp
Madrid's PP gives 48 hours to clear the Sol encampment, citing cobblestones, stoves and knives; banners against Ayuso appear.
-
Spain's defence faces the collapse nobody mentions
The decline of Spain's Armed Forces, in the words of those who see an inevitable collapse amid budget cuts and lack of investment
-
Jordi Sevilla launches manifesto to reclaim social democracy within Spain's PSOE
Jordi Sevilla has published a manifesto to restore social democracy within Spain's PSOE and halt the far right, but the party's old guard is viewed with scepticism.
-
Nazism as socialism: the debate nobody wants to have
The Reichstag Fire Decree abolished Article 153 of the Weimar Constitution, which guaranteed private property. Was nazism a form of socialism?
-
Bye-bye Puigdemont: Catalan separatists slump as Aliança Catalana surges in the polls
We analyse the latest election polls in Catalonia, Spain: the rise of Aliança Catalana, the role of the PSC and the shift within the independence bloc. Join the debate.