Teacher reports students shouting Francoist slogan in class

A primary school teacher claims his sixth-grade students enter class chanting 'Arriba España', while he admits to countering far-right rhetoric.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Teacher reports students shouting Francoist slogan in class
Teacher reports 'Arriba España' chants among sixth-graders

What happens when a group of eleven-year-olds enters the classroom shouting a political slogan? The teacher speaks out, and the conversation gets heated. The educator recounts that his sixth-grade pupils have turned the start of the day into a mini-rally: they enter the room chanting "Arriba España," which he has denounced as propaganda. A scene that would have been routine in the post-war era is now read as a symptom: children repeat what they hear outside school, turning the classroom into a thermometer of the culture war.

The teacher claims he enters shouting 'we must stop the far right', according to his own testimony, and says he is fed up with these "brats." The confession has its irony: if the professor opens class with slogans, he shouldn't be surprised if the kids return the gesture with another chant. Told this way, the anecdote shifts from a case of child indoctrination to a clash of slogans between the blackboard and the playground.

From 'Arriba España' to 'Long Live Segarro': the crowd's repertoire

Things get complicated when the issue mixes with other fronts. Some compare the shout to painting one's mouth or yelling "long live Segarro," as if it were all the same show. Others argue the teacher isn't complaining about the slogan itself, but because he's annoyed by their political chants. The underlying argument: if the teacher rallies, the students respond. Mutual provocation feeds itself.

The most pessimistic calculation suggests things will escalate: third-year secondary students (ESO), one message says, "will tell him Hi Hitler" and no propaganda will manipulate them anymore. The rhetorical escalation is pure forum talk, but it describes real tension: the classroom as a battlefield where each grade raises the stakes.

Is it indoctrination or simple teenage provocation?

The question divides opinion. Some see a legitimate complaint: a teacher shouldn't have to tolerate political slogans in class, regardless of origin. Others see a teacher complaining about noise he himself generates. And a third, more cynical group points out that if students entered shouting "Free Palestine," the teacher wouldn't just not complain, but "would even bump up their grades." The irony lies there: the yardstick isn't always the same.

What nobody disputes is the fact: eleven-year-old children have learned to use a political slogan as a tool for provocation. Where they get it—TV, mobile phones, family dinners—is another story.

In the end, the scene leaves a bitter taste. A teacher who shouts slogans and students who answer with others. Civic education, that pending subject, is learned on the playground.

Also available in: Deutsch

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (21 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back