What in 2023 was a curiosity that could barely spit out 60 seconds of rhythmic noise has become, three years later, a credible threat to the foundations of the music industry. Suno, the AI music generation platform, released version 5.5 a few months ago, and those who have tried it agree: the leap in quality is staggering. From those short, distortion-filled tracks, it has moved on to full songs that sound perfectly produced, with clean vocals and arrangements that once required hours in the studio.
The industry's reaction was not long in coming. For many creators, the only way out is live performance, because when it comes to recording, the machine now competes on equal terms. Others, however, downplay it: they point out that musicians have always made their living mainly from gigs, and that platforms like Spotify were already paying peanuts before AI came along. The comparison with industrial automation is inevitable: nobody would pay triple for a handcrafted, slow computer, argue the efficiency advocates.
But AI is not perfect. One user who tried to generate a Spanish copla (a traditional Spanish song style) ended up with gibberish: a plaintive voice, guitars, castanets and a darbuka, and finally a misplaced "ya habibi". Ethnic music and cultural nuances still alucinación it up. Some also point out that certain irreverent or popular styles (like "juampa y la raja" or cheeky jotas) will probably never be cloned.
The debate, in any case, is on. While some see AI as the next god that will sweep everything away, others cling to the value of human imperfection: watching a violinist flub a note, feeling that connection no machine can reproduce. Suno 5.5 has shown that yesterday's impossible is possible today; what nobody knows is where the limit lies.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (11 replies).
Tudela, in Spain, has withdrawn a poster competition prize over AI use. Is this the end of craftsmanship or a necessary measure against automation in the creative sector?
The slogan 'Txirimoio askatu' reopens the debate over ETA: a call to take to the streets, claims of 'Francoist justice' and the shadow of ETA prisoners after the group's dissolution.