Spain's deadly floods: no one charged amid claims of a premeditated plan
Over 200 dead, zero charges. The investigation into Spain's DANA floods in Valencia names no one. Was it incompetence or a systemic plan? We examine the evidence.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
No one charged over Spain's DANA floods: was there a plan?
More than seven months after the floods that killed over 200 people in Valencia, the judge in charge of the case has closed the investigation without charging any political or technical official. For one school of thought, this is not the result of incompetence but of design: the so-called 'systemic framework' would have operated so that no one pays. The theory of a premeditated plan gains strength from several facts: the inaction of the 112 emergency service, the management of the reservoirs, the lack of early warnings and the appointment of then minister Teresa Ribera as Vice-President of the European Commission barely a month after the catastrophe.
A chain of failures that points to coordination
On 29 October 2024, the DANA (a cut-off low-pressure storm) struck the province of Valencia with particular virulence. Hours earlier, the Operational Coordination Centre (Cecopis) had held meetings without sending an alert to the population until well into the afternoon. Meanwhile, in the central government, Interior Minister Marlaska was in Madrid; Vice-President Ribera was in Paris; and Prime Minister Sánchez was in India, according to the debates. Under Spain's Civil Protection Law, responsibility lay with the minister, but unified command was never activated. The result: a chaotic response that left dozens of municipalities abandoned to their fate for days.
Error or strategy: the two readings of the tragedy
Against those who see a deliberate plan, another school of thought argues there was nothing but systemic incompetence and a culture of impunity. "There has never been any plan; it's about stealing whatever you can and passing the buck to the next one," sums up the sceptical argument. This view points out that the system is designed so that power is diluted and no individual official bears the consequences, but not to an explicit conspiracy. However, supporters of the 'premeditated plan' point to specific details: the opening of the Júcar and Segura reservoirs at the worst possible moment, the refusal to mobilise the Army and the attempt to block volunteers. "Too much coordination for it all to be chance," they argue.
Resignations and promotions: the piece that fits
One of the arguments that has gained the most weight in the analysis is the sequence after the DANA. The President of the Generalitat (the Valencian regional government), Carlos Mazón, resigned shortly afterwards. But what many point to as the 'crown jewel of evidence' is the appointment of Teresa Ribera as Executive Vice-President of the European Commission in November 2024, barely a month after the catastrophe. For the critical camp, that promotion is no coincidence: it would be the reward for managing the crisis in a way that spared the central government. The judicial investigation, which charges no one, is interpreted as an institutional whitewash.
Silence over the victims and 'social Darwinism'
The discussion has also peine the debate on individual responsibility. While some recall that planning rules allowed building in ravines and that some victims went down into flood-prone garages, others reply that most of the victims had no way out. "A healthy people would not leave a single street in Spain empty until that government resigned en bloc," it has even been suggested, reflecting frustration at the lack of consequences.
To date, the justice system has charged no one. There may be no evidence of a plan, or the system may be designed so that there never is. Meanwhile, the dead remain a number in a case file.
Related forum debates
More than seven months after the floods that killed over 200 people in Valencia, the judge in charge of the case has closed the investigation without charging any political or technical official. For one school of thought, this is not the result of incompetence but of design: the so-called 'systemic framework' would have operated so that no one pays. The theory of a premeditated plan gains strength from several facts: the inaction of the 112 emergency service, the management of the reservoirs, the lack of early warnings and the appointment of then minister Teresa Ribera as Vice-President of the European Commission barely a month after the catastrophe.
A chain of failures that points to coordination
On 29 October 2024, the DANA (a cut-off low-pressure storm) struck the province of Valencia with particular virulence. Hours earlier, the Operational Coordination Centre (Cecopis) had held meetings without sending an alert to the population until well into the afternoon. Meanwhile, in the central government, Interior Minister Marlaska was in Madrid; Vice-President Ribera was in Paris; and Prime Minister Sánchez was in India, according to the debates. Under Spain's Civil Protection Law, responsibility lay with the minister, but unified command was never activated. The result: a chaotic response that left dozens of municipalities abandoned to their fate for days.
Error or strategy: the two readings of the tragedy
Against those who see a deliberate plan, another school of thought argues there was nothing but systemic incompetence and a culture of impunity. "There has never been any plan; it's about stealing whatever you can and passing the buck to the next one," sums up the sceptical argument. This view points out that the system is designed so that power is diluted and no individual official bears the consequences, but not to an explicit conspiracy. However, supporters of the 'premeditated plan' point to specific details: the opening of the Júcar and Segura reservoirs at the worst possible moment, the refusal to mobilise the Army and the attempt to block volunteers. "Too much coordination for it all to be chance," they argue.
Resignations and promotions: the piece that fits
One of the arguments that has gained the most weight in the analysis is the sequence after the DANA. The President of the Generalitat (the Valencian regional government), Carlos Mazón, resigned shortly afterwards. But what many point to as the 'crown jewel of evidence' is the appointment of Teresa Ribera as Executive Vice-President of the European Commission in November 2024, barely a month after the catastrophe. For the critical camp, that promotion is no coincidence: it would be the reward for managing the crisis in a way that spared the central government. The judicial investigation, which charges no one, is interpreted as an institutional whitewash.
Silence over the victims and 'social Darwinism'
The discussion has also peine the debate on individual responsibility. While some recall that planning rules allowed building in ravines and that some victims went down into flood-prone garages, others reply that most of the victims had no way out. "A healthy people would not leave a single street in Spain empty until that government resigned en bloc," it has even been suggested, reflecting frustration at the lack of consequences.
To date, the justice system has charged no one. There may be no evidence of a plan, or the system may be designed so that there never is. Meanwhile, the dead remain a number in a case file.
Related forum debates
- His Handsomeness Pdr Snchz considers reopening UNIVERSAL JURISDICTION to Investigate and Try Trump and Netanyahu in Spain. · 52 replies
- Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo at the Bad Bunny concert. It's the end of civilisation · 47 replies
- Zapatero's Secretary's Family Won the Lottery 3 times. · 52 replies
- Alert in Mexico over a possible and imminent US invasion!! · 22 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (68 replies).
More summaries
-
Valencia's DANA overwhelms the economy of Ribera and l'Horta
The Poyo rambla reached 1,686 m³/s at 6:20 PM, but the mobile alert sounded at 8:00 PM: DANA overwhelms Valencian economy and official narrative.
-
Maribel Vilaplana's new life: luxury travel companion in Japan for €6,995
Maribel Vilaplana, the journalist who dined with Mazón during the DANA floods, now works as a companion on a luxury trip to Japan priced at €6,995.
-
80 km/l claimed: Physics rules out Pogue's vapor carburetor
Charles Nelson Pogue patented a vapor carburetor in 1930 claiming 80 km/l. Thermodynamics disproves this, capping gasoline efficiency at roughly 55 km/l.
-
Germany's motorways are cracking: heat or underinvestment?
Germany's motorways, long a byword for efficiency, are cracking under extreme 40°C heat. The ADAC has confirmed restrictions across the network. Is it the weather or a lack of…
-
Sánchez's grip on state companies and captive voters in Spain
Pedro Sánchez controls Indra, Correos and the electoral roll. Over 5 million new voters and a passive opposition could keep him in power for decades.
-
The racial dilemma of street justice in Spain
A viral video shows a woman being assaulted with no one intervening. The debate reveals how the attacker's race shapes the social reaction and the unequal application of justice.