Spain: expecting third child, jobless for years, wants to keep living rent-free
A viral post claims a person is expecting a third child, has been out of work for years and wants to stay in a home without paying. No date or amount is given.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The post raises suspicions about benefits and housing, but provides no verifiable data: no nationality, no contract, no amount. Turning this case into a generalization about a group is an opinion, not a fact.
A text circulating on social media claims that a person is expecting their **third child**, has been jobless for years and wants to keep living in a home without paying. It adds that they will claim child benefits and asks why they don't demand the same in their own country. There is no name, city, date or amount.
## What is claimed and what is not
The central claim is a suspicion: that this person will want benefits and that the situation is unsustainable for **Spain**.
The text does not specify whether the housing situation is a rental, a mortgage or squatting, nor how long the person has been unemployed. The phrase "their country" assumes a foreign origin that is not documented. Without that data, the case allows no calculation of any public cost.
## Child benefits and housing
In **Spain**, child benefits are not automatic: they depend on income, the autonomous region and legal status. There is also no general right to live in a home without paying.
Mixing the two turns an individual case into an argument about borders and social spending. It concludes that **Spain** cannot be the world's charity: a value judgment, not a fact. Any housing or benefits case requires reviewing the rules with a professional.
A text circulating on social media claims that a person is expecting their **third child**, has been jobless for years and wants to keep living in a home without paying. It adds that they will claim child benefits and asks why they don't demand the same in their own country. There is no name, city, date or amount.
## What is claimed and what is not
The central claim is a suspicion: that this person will want benefits and that the situation is unsustainable for **Spain**.
The text does not specify whether the housing situation is a rental, a mortgage or squatting, nor how long the person has been unemployed. The phrase "their country" assumes a foreign origin that is not documented. Without that data, the case allows no calculation of any public cost.
## Child benefits and housing
In **Spain**, child benefits are not automatic: they depend on income, the autonomous region and legal status. There is also no general right to live in a home without paying.
Mixing the two turns an individual case into an argument about borders and social spending. It concludes that **Spain** cannot be the world's charity: a value judgment, not a fact. Any housing or benefits case requires reviewing the rules with a professional.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (13 replies).
More summaries
-
Spanish court orders father to keep paying support to children aged 26, 27 and 29
The Audiencia de A Coruña (provincial court in Spain) rejects a father's appeal and orders him to keep paying maintenance to his three adult children. Housing costs make independence impossible.
-
Murcia to apply Vox's national priority to housing aid in Spain
Murcia's regional president López Miras accepts Vox's national priority rule for housing aid, unblocking the affordable housing decree after weeks of political tension.
-
Having children: the luxury Spain's middle class can no longer afford
Dual incomes doubled housing costs and sank the birth rate. Children have become a luxury the middle class cannot afford.
-
Dabiz Muñoz's €19 Sandwich: The Business of Gourmet Storytelling
A sandwich 'designed' by Dabiz Muñoz sells for €18.95 in Spanish airports. Forum calculations suggest a cost of just €1.50 per unit.
-
Cáritas and informal work: the debate over who pays for charity
A testimony about Cáritas and undeclared work reopens the debate in Spain: the shadow economy, welfare benefits and who foots the bill for solidarity.
-
Can Sánchez hold on until October? The bet shaking Spain's economy
A growing bet in economic circles says Pedro Sánchez won't last until October. Concessions to Catalan separatists, the PSOE 'sewer' scandal and a possible state of emergency.