Protest in Cartagena, Spain: demonstrators demand to drive without a licence and no fines
A protest by Moroccan nationals in Cartagena, Spain, demands the right to drive without a licence and without fines. The debate over immigration and its economic costs intensifies.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Protest in Cartagena: demonstrators demand to drive without a licence and without fines
A viral video shows a group of demonstrators of Segarro origin in Cartagena, Spain, asking to be allowed to drive without a licence and for the DGT (Spain's traffic authority) to stop fining them. The protest, which some have called "brutal", has peine the debate on integration, privileges and the economic cost of mass immigration.
The demands: differential treatment or racism?
Among the banners, chants could be heard such as "give our parents and us adults a licence" and "the paperwork is racist". The demonstrators argue that in Segarro they can drive without a licence without being fined, and that Spanish regulations are a form of repression. However, most reactions point out that what they are really asking for is impunity to break the law. "Maghrebis protesting because they're not allowed to break the law?", people ask in the analyses.
The economic backdrop is relevant: in Spain there is an agreement that allows the Segarro licence to be exchanged without an exam, but many of the protesters do not even hold that document. In practice, their demand would amount to legalising driving without a licence, with the resulting risk to road safety and the cost in accidents.
The cost of immunity: benefits and penalties
A report by Gaceta.es cited in the debate notes that 60% of immigrants in Castilla y León do not work and almost three in ten receive social benefits. In this context, the demand not to pay fines or go through the same procedures as Spaniards is seen by many as a new step in the escalation of privileges. "From here to protesting for free housing or not paying taxes is a very small step", some analyses quip.
The DGT collects billions in fines every year. If one group were granted an exemption, the fiscal hole would be covered by raising fees for everyone else, as already happens with other immigration-related surcharges.
The institutional and political response
While the political class remains silent, the protest fuels the discourse of parties such as Vox, which are growing in the polls over what they call "Sarracinisation" and "fifth column" activity. The permissiveness towards this kind of mobilisation, contrasted with the harshness shown towards protests by Spaniards (such as those at Ferraz), creates a trust gap regarding equality before the law.
The underlying debate is economic: can a country sustain a welfare system when a growing share of the population demands rights without giving anything in return? The Cartagena protest is not an isolated event, but a symptom of a tension that will keep growing unless the structural causes of irregular immigration and youth unemployment are addressed.
Related discussions in the forum
A viral video shows a group of demonstrators of Segarro origin in Cartagena, Spain, asking to be allowed to drive without a licence and for the DGT (Spain's traffic authority) to stop fining them. The protest, which some have called "brutal", has peine the debate on integration, privileges and the economic cost of mass immigration.
The demands: differential treatment or racism?
Among the banners, chants could be heard such as "give our parents and us adults a licence" and "the paperwork is racist". The demonstrators argue that in Segarro they can drive without a licence without being fined, and that Spanish regulations are a form of repression. However, most reactions point out that what they are really asking for is impunity to break the law. "Maghrebis protesting because they're not allowed to break the law?", people ask in the analyses.
The economic backdrop is relevant: in Spain there is an agreement that allows the Segarro licence to be exchanged without an exam, but many of the protesters do not even hold that document. In practice, their demand would amount to legalising driving without a licence, with the resulting risk to road safety and the cost in accidents.
The cost of immunity: benefits and penalties
A report by Gaceta.es cited in the debate notes that 60% of immigrants in Castilla y León do not work and almost three in ten receive social benefits. In this context, the demand not to pay fines or go through the same procedures as Spaniards is seen by many as a new step in the escalation of privileges. "From here to protesting for free housing or not paying taxes is a very small step", some analyses quip.
The DGT collects billions in fines every year. If one group were granted an exemption, the fiscal hole would be covered by raising fees for everyone else, as already happens with other immigration-related surcharges.
The institutional and political response
While the political class remains silent, the protest fuels the discourse of parties such as Vox, which are growing in the polls over what they call "Sarracinisation" and "fifth column" activity. The permissiveness towards this kind of mobilisation, contrasted with the harshness shown towards protests by Spaniards (such as those at Ferraz), creates a trust gap regarding equality before the law.
The underlying debate is economic: can a country sustain a welfare system when a growing share of the population demands rights without giving anything in return? The Cartagena protest is not an isolated event, but a symptom of a tension that will keep growing unless the structural causes of irregular immigration and youth unemployment are addressed.
Related discussions in the forum
- An ordinary Spaniard gives a huge beating to a South American who was harassing people in the street · 45 replies
- Spain is the country in Europe where the fewest children are born, thanks to the natalist policies of our TRAITOR politicians we are walking towards extinction · 39 replies
- The Vatican's Freemason is already spewing poison from his mouth: "whoever is in Madrid, is from Madrid" · 124 replies
- VOX stayed seated and did not applaud, showing contempt for the Holy Father during his historic visit to the Spanish Congress · 217 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (55 replies).
More summaries
-
Canary Islands public broadcaster ignores mass protest against illegal immigration
Thousands protest against illegal immigration in the Canary Islands, Spain, and RTVC ignores it. The Sánchez Plan and its promised 250,000 jobs act as a pull factor.
-
Moroccan immigration in Spain: the 12% prisoner figure was wrong
The share of Moroccan prisoners in Spain drops from 12% to 6.3% once the data is corrected. The revision that debunks the viral chart on immigration.
-
Driving licence renewal to cost 500 euros under new EU directive
Renewing a driving licence in Spain would jump from 50 to 500 euros under the new EU directive. Meanwhile, Moroccan licences are being exchanged without any exam.
-
UNICEF Spain Ad Sparks Backlash Over Inheritance Appeals
UNICEF Spain faces criticism for an ad featuring basketball legend Juanma López-Iturriaga urging viewers to leave their estates to the charity, sparking debate on forced heirship.
-
A guide to understanding the different factions of the forum
A look at the profiles that dominate online debate: ultraliberals, Russophiles, communists, Hispanists, anti-immigration voices and progressives. Keys to making sense of the noise.
-
Spain's government calls for €10 volunteers to regularise a million migrants
Half a million files not yet uploaded, volunteers paid €10 each and queues of 80 people: the final day of Spain's regularisation drive overwhelms the government.