Prosecutors seek €800,000 fine and 2.5 years in prison for uploading 'lost media'
Spain's prosecutors are seeking €800,000 and 2.5 years in prison for uploading 'lost media' films no longer sold anywhere. Cultural preservation or crime? The debate over copyright laws.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Prosecutors seek €800,000 fine and 2.5 years in prison for uploading 'lost media'
Spain's public prosecutor's office is seeking an €800,000 fine and a 2.5-year prison sentence for the operator of a website that hosted films considered 'lost media': works that cannot be legally purchased anywhere. The case has peine the debate over the limits of intellectual property in the digital age, especially when it involves material that the studios themselves have abandoned or removed from commercial channels.
The charges are based on the unauthorized distribution of protected works, but the defendant's advocates argue that it was about preserving culture that would otherwise be lost. The case has been described as an example of the enforcement of so-called 'proge intellectual property laws', a term used by some to describe policies that prioritize copyright over cultural access. The absence of profit motive and the impossibility of acquiring this material through legal channels are the defense's key arguments, while the prosecution maintains that the infringement is clear and must be punished harshly to set a precedent.
Related discussions in the forum
Spain's public prosecutor's office is seeking an €800,000 fine and a 2.5-year prison sentence for the operator of a website that hosted films considered 'lost media': works that cannot be legally purchased anywhere. The case has peine the debate over the limits of intellectual property in the digital age, especially when it involves material that the studios themselves have abandoned or removed from commercial channels.
The charges are based on the unauthorized distribution of protected works, but the defendant's advocates argue that it was about preserving culture that would otherwise be lost. The case has been described as an example of the enforcement of so-called 'proge intellectual property laws', a term used by some to describe policies that prioritize copyright over cultural access. The absence of profit motive and the impossibility of acquiring this material through legal channels are the defense's key arguments, while the prosecution maintains that the infringement is clear and must be punished harshly to set a precedent.
Related discussions in the forum
- DATA. Immigrants pay our pensions · 59 replies
- Is Rufián right to antiestéticar the far right? · 39 replies
- The joke of the century, and seriously, it's from ZP · 12 replies
- Sánchez says he doesn't call elections because if he did, he'd win by a landslide. · 58 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (22 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain's Supreme Court denies Puigdemont amnesty, orders his arrest
Spain's Supreme Court refuses to apply the amnesty law to Carles Puigdemont and orders his arrest if he returns. The former Catalan president lashes out at Sánchez over the ERC deal.
-
SOS Rural protests in Madrid amid digital censorship claims
SOS Rural marches in Madrid as accusations of censorship on forums link the movement to VOX. The protest raises questions about genuine rural grievances versus political suppression.
-
Spain's Supreme Court strikes down 'grandchildren' vote in census battle
Spain's Supreme Court is reviewing nationalities granted under the 'grandchildren law', leaving two million people unable to vote. The debate: census manipulation or defending…
-
Tweet Places Pablo Fernández in Luxury Housing Development
A tweet places Pablo Fernández living in a luxury development from the Mahou-Calderón operation, the same one Podemos tried to halt.
-
Santaolalla, Puente and Iglesias rally against the far right in Madrid
Analysis of the Santaolalla, Puente and Iglesias event at the Ateneo in Madrid: political strategy or mere survival of a left out of touch with reality?
-
Se Acabó la Fiesta's manifesto for the Andalusian regional election in Spain
An analysis of Se Acabó la Fiesta's programme for the Andalusian regional election in Spain: concrete measures, the risk of wasted votes, and a comparison with other parties.