Mestizos barred from power, caste system, banned marriages? The delusions of indigenism
The Spanish Empire never imposed a caste system that banned marriages or excluded mestizos from power. The historical record tells a very different story.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The idea of a Spanish Empire with a rigid caste system that banned mixed marriages and excluded mestizos from power does not hold up against the historical documentation.
The indigenist narrative often paints a picture of insurmountable racial segregation in colonial America, where mixed origin condemned people to exclusion. It speaks of a "caste system" that barred access to public office and even marriage with peninsular Spaniards. However, the historical documentation and specific cases suggest a far more complex and nuanced reality.
## The chieftain who spoke with the king
A clear example is **Diego de Torres Moyachoque**. The son of a Spanish encomendero and a Muisca noblewoman, he was not only legally recognized as Cacique of **Turmequé** by the **Real Audiencia**, exercising the highest political and judicial authority of his community in New Granada. He even traveled to the Iberian Peninsula and was received in direct audience by King **Felipe II** on two occasions, in **1578** and **1584**. There he presented his petitions of grievances, proving that the mechanisms of imperial justice were open to him.
## Marriage without legal barriers
But it does not end there. In **1583**, Diego de Torres Moyachoque married legitimately in **Madrid** **Juana de Oropesa**, a Spanish woman from the peninsula. They had three children together. This documented fact disproves the supposed legal and social prohibition of marriages between people of mixed origin and peninsular Spaniards. The colonial legislation and social reality of the time were not governed by a rigid pyramid of racial segregation, but by a legal and estate-based order in which mixed origin did not nullify political rights or the ability to marry peninsular subjects.
The indigenist narrative often paints a picture of insurmountable racial segregation in colonial America, where mixed origin condemned people to exclusion. It speaks of a "caste system" that barred access to public office and even marriage with peninsular Spaniards. However, the historical documentation and specific cases suggest a far more complex and nuanced reality.
## The chieftain who spoke with the king
A clear example is **Diego de Torres Moyachoque**. The son of a Spanish encomendero and a Muisca noblewoman, he was not only legally recognized as Cacique of **Turmequé** by the **Real Audiencia**, exercising the highest political and judicial authority of his community in New Granada. He even traveled to the Iberian Peninsula and was received in direct audience by King **Felipe II** on two occasions, in **1578** and **1584**. There he presented his petitions of grievances, proving that the mechanisms of imperial justice were open to him.
## Marriage without legal barriers
But it does not end there. In **1583**, Diego de Torres Moyachoque married legitimately in **Madrid** **Juana de Oropesa**, a Spanish woman from the peninsula. They had three children together. This documented fact disproves the supposed legal and social prohibition of marriages between people of mixed origin and peninsular Spaniards. The colonial legislation and social reality of the time were not governed by a rigid pyramid of racial segregation, but by a legal and estate-based order in which mixed origin did not nullify political rights or the ability to marry peninsular subjects.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (1 replies).
More summaries
-
The Madrid buildings that vanished without a trace
A giant globe over the Retiro park, a Nordic-style electric colossus and workers' housing estates now priced at a million: the Madrid that was wiped off the map.
-
Why Europe accepted a Habsburg in Madrid but not a Bourbon
The balance of power and fear of Louis XIV explain the Spanish succession. Why a Habsburg was acceptable and a Bourbon was not.
-
Philip V, the Spanish king who believed he was a frog and had bipolar disorder
Philip V believed he was a frog and swung between mania and depression. Ferdinand VI ate his own faeces in his final year. The mental health of Spain's Bourbons is under debate.
-
ETA and GAL: two arms of the same Gladio network in Spain
Investigation linking ETA and GAL as arms of the same NATO Gladio network, with drug trafficking funding and CIA control.
-
Your TV and Your Phone Are Damaging Your Soul (Father Spyridon)
Father Spyridon argues that screens and constant entertainment scatter the soul and lead to depression. A warning rooted in the Church Fathers.
-
How the frenche became the uniform of communist leaders
The frenche jacket began as a military garment in World War I and ended up as the uniform of Stalin, Mao and Kim Il-sung. Here is how it happened.