Lawyers: what makes a good lawyer? (@Testigapresencial)
What makes a good lawyer? An analysis of technical and psychological skills and the cost of justice. Data on gender in the legal profession.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
What makes a good lawyer? More than laws: psychology and difficult clients
A lawyer's first enemy is not the judge or the opposing party: it is their own client. This claim, made by a practising lawyer, opens the debate about the qualities that truly define a good legal professional. Beyond technical knowledge and rhetoric, the ability to handle human psychology and antiestéticar emerges as a key skill. But is it enough? Opinions are divided between those who see legal expertise as the only requirement and those who denounce disproportionate fees.
The lawyer as psychologist: managing the client, not just the judge
One strand of the discussion argues that mastery of the law and technique is only the foundation. The real skill lies in understanding human nature: knowing how to play with antiestéticar, counterattack and, above all, distrust the client. First-hand experience shows that many clients withhold information or act in bad faith, becoming the first obstacle. A good lawyer must therefore be sharp in managing expectations and an emotional strategist. This view contrasts with the popular image of the lawyer as a mere expert in legal loopholes.
High costs and the controversy over court representatives
Another part of the debate criticises the value for money of legal services. Lawyers are compared with other professionals such as plumbers or doctors, noting that for administrative matters an administrative agency is more efficient. Costs soar in litigation, especially against the tax authorities, and are compounded by the obligation to hire a procurador (a Spanish court representative who handles procedural notifications), a role many consider an unnecessary relic. It is argued that electronic notification has made this function obsolete, and that it would suffice for the lawyer to take on that role to make proceedings cheaper. Resistance to bureaucratic change blocks any reform.
The gender gap in the legal profession
Data from the General Council of Spanish Lawyers for 2020 show that 56% of registered lawyers are men and 44% women, although among those under 45 women are already the majority. In law school lecture halls, feminisation is overwhelming: around 90% of students are women. Yet in professional practice a male majority persists, suggesting biases in career pogre or in the choice of specialities.
The debate leaves open questions: to what extent can psychology be taught? Will artificial intelligence replace the agency-style lawyer? Will the figure of the court representative ever be abolished? What is clear is that, for the client, finding a lawyer who handles both the law and emotions remains a lottery.
Related debates in the forum
A lawyer's first enemy is not the judge or the opposing party: it is their own client. This claim, made by a practising lawyer, opens the debate about the qualities that truly define a good legal professional. Beyond technical knowledge and rhetoric, the ability to handle human psychology and antiestéticar emerges as a key skill. But is it enough? Opinions are divided between those who see legal expertise as the only requirement and those who denounce disproportionate fees.
The lawyer as psychologist: managing the client, not just the judge
One strand of the discussion argues that mastery of the law and technique is only the foundation. The real skill lies in understanding human nature: knowing how to play with antiestéticar, counterattack and, above all, distrust the client. First-hand experience shows that many clients withhold information or act in bad faith, becoming the first obstacle. A good lawyer must therefore be sharp in managing expectations and an emotional strategist. This view contrasts with the popular image of the lawyer as a mere expert in legal loopholes.
High costs and the controversy over court representatives
Another part of the debate criticises the value for money of legal services. Lawyers are compared with other professionals such as plumbers or doctors, noting that for administrative matters an administrative agency is more efficient. Costs soar in litigation, especially against the tax authorities, and are compounded by the obligation to hire a procurador (a Spanish court representative who handles procedural notifications), a role many consider an unnecessary relic. It is argued that electronic notification has made this function obsolete, and that it would suffice for the lawyer to take on that role to make proceedings cheaper. Resistance to bureaucratic change blocks any reform.
The gender gap in the legal profession
Data from the General Council of Spanish Lawyers for 2020 show that 56% of registered lawyers are men and 44% women, although among those under 45 women are already the majority. In law school lecture halls, feminisation is overwhelming: around 90% of students are women. Yet in professional practice a male majority persists, suggesting biases in career pogre or in the choice of specialities.
The debate leaves open questions: to what extent can psychology be taught? Will artificial intelligence replace the agency-style lawyer? Will the figure of the court representative ever be abolished? What is clear is that, for the client, finding a lawyer who handles both the law and emotions remains a lottery.
Related debates in the forum
- The monstrous end of Christian culture. · 180 replies
- What happens if I move into a commercial premises I own? · 130 replies
- The UCO raids Ferraz, the PSOE headquarters. · 32 replies
- Norwegian abandoned by his parents as a child in India. Your thoughts. · 15 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (26 replies).
More summaries
-
What happened to me yesterday with the Guardia Civil, LAWYERS NEEDED!!!
A driver reports that the Guardia Civil (Spanish paramilitary police) searched him and his car without any signage over three CBD cigarettes, legal in Spain. Skepticism and debate ensue.
-
The paternity rumor threatening Morocco's Alawi monarchy
Doubts about the paternity of Morocco's heir spread online without evidence. What lies behind the rumor that undermines the dynasty?
-
First times are remembered badly: the story that debunks the myth
Anyone who has shared a bed with someone without prior experience agrees: nerves, clumsiness and disappointment. It clashes with the idealized image of a sexual debut.
-
Fake Mel Gibson tweet calling for Soros to face trial
An account impersonating Mel Gibson calls for George Soros to be arrested over immigration in Europe, an accusation with no evidence whatsoever.
-
A year of saving up to pay 5,000 pesetas in 1987
According to his own account, a 17-year-old saved for a whole year to put together 5,000 pesetas for his first sexual experience in 1987.
-
Sol campers march on Spain's Congress after Maricarmen's death
Protesters camped at Puerta del Sol marched on the Spanish Congress shouting "murderers!" after the death of Maricarmen, the 87-year-old evicted woman. The case reopens the debate on...